Journal Article

Tuberculosis Prevalence in People Tested Is a Strong Predictor of Xpert Specificity in Community and Risk Group Screening

The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Volume 232, Issue 6, 15 December 2025, Pages e1062–e1064, https://doi.org/10.1093/infdis/jiaf418
Published:
07 August 2025
Article history
Received:
09 June 2025
Editorial decision:
05 August 2025
Accepted:
05 August 2025
Published:
07 August 2025
Corrected and typeset:
14 August 2025

We thank Veeken et al for their excellent review of studies estimating the specificity of Xpert in community settings [1]. We agree with their conclusion that the specificity of Xpert may often be higher in community settings than is suggested by estimates from testing people with presumptive tuberculosis (TB), and would like to highlight an additional finding that can be drawn from the data they assembled.

Using data from Veeken et al [1] and a Cochrane systematic review [2], we plotted estimated Xpert specificity against estimated TB prevalence, from studies conducting community-wide screening (community active case finding or prevalence surveys [1], Figure 1A and 1B) and from studies testing people in high-risk groups [2] (Figure 1C). For studies conducting community-wide screening, we plotted the data separately by estimated prevalence in all people screened (Figure 1A) and estimated prevalence in people who were screen positive according to the study criteria only (Figure 1B). For studies in high-risk groups, only estimates of prevalence in people tested were available. Finally, we split the data by TB nucleic acid amplification diagnostic test and interpretation of trace results: Algorithm 1 includes both Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra with trace considered negative, and algorithm 2 consists of Xpert Ultra with trace considered positive.

Figure 1. Graphs labeled A through D, showing the relationship between tuberculosis prevalence and estimated Xpert specificity, and the relationship between estimated tuberculosis prevalence in people tested and the predicted ratio of false-positive to true-positive diagnoses.
Figure 1.

Relationship between tuberculosis (TB) prevalence and estimated Xpert specificity in community settings (A and B) and among high-risk groups (C). A, Estimated TB prevalence in the community. B, Estimated TB prevalence in people who are screen positive. C, Estimated TB prevalence in people tested. D, Relationship between TB prevalence in people tested and estimated ratio of false-positive to true-positive diagnoses, calculated as (1 – prevalence) × (1 – specificity)/(prevalence × sensitivity), and assuming a sensitivity of 0.618 for Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra (trace as negative) and 0.690 for Xpert Ultra (trace as positive). Uncertainty intervals are 95% confidence intervals incorporating the uncertainty in the ratio of false-positive to true-positive diagnoses.

The plots show that there are very strong relationships between prevalence and specificity for the community-wide screening studies, with specificity decreasing with increasing prevalence. Estimated specificity correlated less strongly with the estimated prevalence in the people screened, versus in people who were screen positive (r = −0.75 vs −0.96, respectively, for algorithm 1, and r = −0.91 vs −0.98, respectively, for algorithm 2). The observed relationship between prevalence and specificity was less strong for studies conducted in high-risk groups (r = −0.72, Figure 1C), and absent for studies conducted in people with presumptive TB (r = 0.50 for algorithm 1 and r = 0.38 for algorithm 2, using data from a second Cochrane systematic review [3], plot not shown).

Figure 1D shows the predicted relationship between estimated prevalence in people tested and the ratio of false-positive to true-positive diagnoses in community screening. For both algorithms, the ratio of false-positive to true-positive diagnoses is predicted to be relatively stable at higher prevalences, but increases sharply when prevalences are low.

We suggest 2 factors contributing to the relationship between prevalence and specificity. The first is that people with recent TB, resolved through treatment or self-cure, have an increased risk of false-positive Xpert results [4]. The second is that the “gold standard” test, culture, has an imperfect sensitivity [5], and some people will therefore be incorrectly classified as false positives. The prevalence of both people with recent TB and “false false positives” are likely to correlate strongly with the prevalence of current TB in a population. People with recent TB and “false false positives” are also likely to have an increased probability of screening positive on symptom screen and/or chest X-ray, providing an explanation for why specificity correlates more strongly with prevalence in people tested than in people screened. In more highly selected groups of participants, such as people with presumptive TB, it is probable that many additional factors will have affected study participation, masking the relationship between prevalence and specificity.

The World Health Organization recommends that community screening can be conducted in settings with TB prevalences of 0.5% or higher [6]. At this prevalence, we estimate that the ratio of false-positive to true-positive diagnoses will be 0.85 (1.73) with algorithm 1 (algorithm 2), with only moderate reductions to 0.74 (1.34) and 0.63 (1.01) if symptom screening (sensitivity 71%, specificity 64% [6]) or chest X-ray screening (any abnormality, sensitivity 94%, specificity 89% [6]) is used. These figures are likely to be overestimates, as they do not allow for the imperfect sensitivity of culture.

There are a number of limitations to this analysis. We assumed that the estimated prevalence reported by the studies was the true prevalence. Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra (trace as negative) were grouped based on observed similarities in the data, as opposed to an a priori decision. The results are based on a post hoc analysis and limited data, and should therefore be treated as hypothesis-generating. Nevertheless, the strength and biological plausibility of the observed relationship lends substantial support to the hypothesis that TB prevalence is a strong predictor of Xpert specificity in community and risk group screening. Additional data from future prevalence surveys and research studies can be used to validate the observed relationships, and well as improve estimates of the relationship between prevalence and specificity.

Notes

Author contributions. Conceptualization: N. M. Methodology: N. M. and P. Y. K. Visualization: N. M. Writing—original draft: N. M. Writing—review & editing: P. Y. K., A. D. G., and I. G.

Data availability. Data and code are available at https://github.com/NickyMcC/SpecificityLetter.

Rights retention. For the purpose of open access, the authors have applied a creative commons attribution (CC BY license) to any author-accepted manuscript version arising from this work.

Financial support. N. M. is funded by the UK Medical Research Centre (MR/Z504270/1).

References

1

Veeken
 
LD
,
Schwalb
 
A
,
Horton
 
KC
, et al.  
Mind the clinic-community gap: re-evaluation of test performance and false positive results in community-wide Tuberculosis screening
.
J Infect Dis
 
2025
;
232
:
e242
–
6
.

2

Zifodya
 
JS
,
Kreniske
 
JS
,
Schiller
 
I
, et al.  
Xpert Ultra versus Xpert MTB/RIF for pulmonary tuberculosis and rifampicin resistance in adults with presumptive pulmonary tuberculosis
.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev
 
2021
;
2
:
CD009593
.

3

Shapiro
 
AE
,
Ross
 
JM
,
Yao
 
M
, et al.  
Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra assays for screening for pulmonary tuberculosis and rifampicin resistance in adults, irrespective of signs or symptoms
.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev
 
2021
;
3
:
CD013694
.

4

Theron
 
G
,
Venter
 
R
,
Smith
 
L
, et al.  
False-positive Xpert MTB/RIF results in retested patients with previous tuberculosis: frequency, profile, and prospective clinical outcomes
.
J Clin Microbiol
 
2018
;
56
:
e01696-17
.

5

Yilmaz
 
A
,
Bayram Selvi
 
U
,
Damadoğlu
 
E
, et al.  
Diagnostic value of repeated sputum examinations in pulmonary tuberculosis: how many sputum specimens are adequate?
 
Tuberk Toraks
 
2008
;
56
:
158
–
62
.

6

World Health Organization (WHO)
.
WHO consolidated guidelines on tuberculosis. Module 2: screening—systematic screening for tuberculosis disease
.
Geneva, Switzerland
:
WHO
,
2021
.

Author notes

Potential conflicts of interest. All authors: No reported conflicts.

All authors have submitted the ICMJE Form for Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest. Conflicts that the editors consider relevant to the content of the manuscript have been disclosed.

This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (https://dbpia.nl.go.kr/pages/standard-publication-reuse-rights)
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close

Gift article access

As a benefit of your subscription, you can share temporary access to restricted articles.

Each link will stop working after 30 days or 10 uses. You may create up to 10 links in a 30 day period.

Please sign in to your personal account to gift article access.

Gift article access

Please create a link below to share with others. This will provide temporary access to this restricted article.

The link will stop working after 30 days or 10 uses. You may create up to 10 links in a 30 day period.

Gift articles remaining: --

Gift article access

The link will stop working after 30 days or 10 uses. You may create up to 10 links in a 30 day period.

Gift articles remaining: --

Gift article access

As a benefit of your subscription, you can share temporary access to restricted articles.

Each link will stop working after 30 days or 10 uses.

You have reached the limit of 10 links within a 30 day period