-
PDF
- Split View
-
Views
-
Cite
Cite
Mabel Aoun, Najla Hilal, Beaini Chadia, Ghassan Sleilaty, Joseph Hajal, Celine Boueri, Dania Nehme Chelala, P1869
COFFEE INTAKE AND HEADACHE IN HAEMODIALYSIS (COFFEEHD TRIAL): A RANDOMIZED DOUBLE BLIND MULTICENTER CLINICAL TRIAL, Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, Volume 35, Issue Supplement_3, June 2020, gfaa145.P1869, https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfaa145.P1869 - Share Icon Share
Abstract
Coffee with its major component caffeine can enhance alertness and decrease tiredness and headache. Headache was reported in 40 to 75 % of hemodialysis patients. Caffeine circulates unbound in the blood and passes the dialysis membrane. Some authors suggested that headache can result from caffeine withdrawal. This study aims to compare the incidence of headache and hypotension between patients taking or not coffee during dialysis.
This is a randomized double-blind multicenter trial. Patients of three hemodialysis units were included. Patients with atrial fibrillation were excluded. 156 patients were randomized to two groups, group A was given 80 cc of coffee and group B 80 cc of decaffeinated coffee in the middle of the session for 12 consecutive sessions. Ultrafiltration rate was fixed to a maximum of 13 ml/kg/h. The primary outcome was the incidence of headache and the secondary incidence of hypotension. This clinical trial received the approval of the ethics committee of Saint-Joseph University (HDF-1463) and was registered on ClinicalTrials.Gov (NCT04057313).
A total of 139 patients completed the trial (6.4% vs 15.4 % of withdrawal in groups A and B respectively). Baseline characteristics are summarized in Table 1. The number of sessions with headache was not significantly different between group A and B (34% vs 37% respectively, p=0.522), nor the number of sessions with hypotension (27% vs 26% respectively, p= 0.539). In a subgroup analysis, headache was higher in group B (p=0.06) in two categories of patients: those with the highest potassium dialysate (K=2) and the non-hypertensive patients.
Headache occurred in 34 to 37% of dialysis sessions. There was no difference in headache or hypotensive episodes between patients in the coffee versus decaffeinated group.
Table 1. Baseline characteristics: comparison of group A and B.
. | . | A . | B . | P-value . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Age | 64.3 ± 13 | 69 ± 11.4 | 0.016* | |
Sex | M | 56(71.8%) | 46(59%) | 0.092** |
F | 22(28.2%) | 32(41%) | ||
Dialysis Vintage | 39[17 - 84] | 27[14 - 55] | 0.086*** | |
Smoking | N | 51(65.4%) | 60(76.9%) | 0.112** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 18(23.1%) | ||
Alcohol | N | 75(96.2%) | 75(96.2%) | 1.000**** |
Y | 3(3.8%) | 3(3.8%) | ||
Hypertension | N | 7(9%) | 12(15.4%) | 0.221** |
Y | 71(91%) | 66(84.6%) | ||
Coffee cups per day | 2.4 ± 1.4 | 2.3 ± 1.5 | 0.783* | |
Coffee intake before session | N | 36(46.2%) | 37(47.4%) | 0.873** |
Y | 42(53.8%) | 41(52.6%) | ||
Coffee during dialysis | N | 51(65.4%) | 47(60.3%) | 0.508** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 31(39.7%) | ||
Diabetes | N | 45(57.7%) | 36(46.2%) | 0.149** |
Y | 33(42.3%) | 42(53.8%) | ||
Coronary artery disease | N | 49(62.8%) | 42(53.8%) | 0.256** |
Y | 29(37.2%) | 36(46.2%) | ||
Headache usually | N | 64(82.1%) | 67(85.9%) | 0.513** |
Y | 14(17.9%) | 11(14.1%) | ||
Beta-blockers | N | 18(23.1%) | 17(21.8%) | 0.848** |
Y | 60(76.9%) | 61(78.2%) | ||
Antidepressant/benzodiazepin | N | 58(74.4%) | 58(74.4%) | 1.000** |
Y | 20(25.6%) | 20(25.6%) | ||
Urea Reduction Ratio | 75.6 ± 5.3 | 76.5 ± 4.9 | 0.274* | |
Dialysate potassium | 0 | 4(5.1%) | 6(7.7%) | 0.468** |
1 | 33(42.3%) | 26(33.3%) | ||
2 | 41(52.6%) | 46(59%) | ||
Pre HD systolic pressure (averaged) | 146.5 ± 21.7 | 140.4 ± 21.1 | 0.076* | |
Pre HD diastolic pressure (averaged) | 76.7 ± 12.8 | 72.6 ± 11.9 | 0.036* | |
Pre HD heart rate (averaged) | 71.6 ± 10 | 68.8 ± 10 | 0.077* |
. | . | A . | B . | P-value . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Age | 64.3 ± 13 | 69 ± 11.4 | 0.016* | |
Sex | M | 56(71.8%) | 46(59%) | 0.092** |
F | 22(28.2%) | 32(41%) | ||
Dialysis Vintage | 39[17 - 84] | 27[14 - 55] | 0.086*** | |
Smoking | N | 51(65.4%) | 60(76.9%) | 0.112** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 18(23.1%) | ||
Alcohol | N | 75(96.2%) | 75(96.2%) | 1.000**** |
Y | 3(3.8%) | 3(3.8%) | ||
Hypertension | N | 7(9%) | 12(15.4%) | 0.221** |
Y | 71(91%) | 66(84.6%) | ||
Coffee cups per day | 2.4 ± 1.4 | 2.3 ± 1.5 | 0.783* | |
Coffee intake before session | N | 36(46.2%) | 37(47.4%) | 0.873** |
Y | 42(53.8%) | 41(52.6%) | ||
Coffee during dialysis | N | 51(65.4%) | 47(60.3%) | 0.508** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 31(39.7%) | ||
Diabetes | N | 45(57.7%) | 36(46.2%) | 0.149** |
Y | 33(42.3%) | 42(53.8%) | ||
Coronary artery disease | N | 49(62.8%) | 42(53.8%) | 0.256** |
Y | 29(37.2%) | 36(46.2%) | ||
Headache usually | N | 64(82.1%) | 67(85.9%) | 0.513** |
Y | 14(17.9%) | 11(14.1%) | ||
Beta-blockers | N | 18(23.1%) | 17(21.8%) | 0.848** |
Y | 60(76.9%) | 61(78.2%) | ||
Antidepressant/benzodiazepin | N | 58(74.4%) | 58(74.4%) | 1.000** |
Y | 20(25.6%) | 20(25.6%) | ||
Urea Reduction Ratio | 75.6 ± 5.3 | 76.5 ± 4.9 | 0.274* | |
Dialysate potassium | 0 | 4(5.1%) | 6(7.7%) | 0.468** |
1 | 33(42.3%) | 26(33.3%) | ||
2 | 41(52.6%) | 46(59%) | ||
Pre HD systolic pressure (averaged) | 146.5 ± 21.7 | 140.4 ± 21.1 | 0.076* | |
Pre HD diastolic pressure (averaged) | 76.7 ± 12.8 | 72.6 ± 11.9 | 0.036* | |
Pre HD heart rate (averaged) | 71.6 ± 10 | 68.8 ± 10 | 0.077* |
*Independent Samples Test; **Pearson Chi-Square; ***Mann-Whitney U;****Fischer's Exact Test
N, No; Y; Yes
Table 1. Baseline characteristics: comparison of group A and B.
. | . | A . | B . | P-value . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Age | 64.3 ± 13 | 69 ± 11.4 | 0.016* | |
Sex | M | 56(71.8%) | 46(59%) | 0.092** |
F | 22(28.2%) | 32(41%) | ||
Dialysis Vintage | 39[17 - 84] | 27[14 - 55] | 0.086*** | |
Smoking | N | 51(65.4%) | 60(76.9%) | 0.112** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 18(23.1%) | ||
Alcohol | N | 75(96.2%) | 75(96.2%) | 1.000**** |
Y | 3(3.8%) | 3(3.8%) | ||
Hypertension | N | 7(9%) | 12(15.4%) | 0.221** |
Y | 71(91%) | 66(84.6%) | ||
Coffee cups per day | 2.4 ± 1.4 | 2.3 ± 1.5 | 0.783* | |
Coffee intake before session | N | 36(46.2%) | 37(47.4%) | 0.873** |
Y | 42(53.8%) | 41(52.6%) | ||
Coffee during dialysis | N | 51(65.4%) | 47(60.3%) | 0.508** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 31(39.7%) | ||
Diabetes | N | 45(57.7%) | 36(46.2%) | 0.149** |
Y | 33(42.3%) | 42(53.8%) | ||
Coronary artery disease | N | 49(62.8%) | 42(53.8%) | 0.256** |
Y | 29(37.2%) | 36(46.2%) | ||
Headache usually | N | 64(82.1%) | 67(85.9%) | 0.513** |
Y | 14(17.9%) | 11(14.1%) | ||
Beta-blockers | N | 18(23.1%) | 17(21.8%) | 0.848** |
Y | 60(76.9%) | 61(78.2%) | ||
Antidepressant/benzodiazepin | N | 58(74.4%) | 58(74.4%) | 1.000** |
Y | 20(25.6%) | 20(25.6%) | ||
Urea Reduction Ratio | 75.6 ± 5.3 | 76.5 ± 4.9 | 0.274* | |
Dialysate potassium | 0 | 4(5.1%) | 6(7.7%) | 0.468** |
1 | 33(42.3%) | 26(33.3%) | ||
2 | 41(52.6%) | 46(59%) | ||
Pre HD systolic pressure (averaged) | 146.5 ± 21.7 | 140.4 ± 21.1 | 0.076* | |
Pre HD diastolic pressure (averaged) | 76.7 ± 12.8 | 72.6 ± 11.9 | 0.036* | |
Pre HD heart rate (averaged) | 71.6 ± 10 | 68.8 ± 10 | 0.077* |
. | . | A . | B . | P-value . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Age | 64.3 ± 13 | 69 ± 11.4 | 0.016* | |
Sex | M | 56(71.8%) | 46(59%) | 0.092** |
F | 22(28.2%) | 32(41%) | ||
Dialysis Vintage | 39[17 - 84] | 27[14 - 55] | 0.086*** | |
Smoking | N | 51(65.4%) | 60(76.9%) | 0.112** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 18(23.1%) | ||
Alcohol | N | 75(96.2%) | 75(96.2%) | 1.000**** |
Y | 3(3.8%) | 3(3.8%) | ||
Hypertension | N | 7(9%) | 12(15.4%) | 0.221** |
Y | 71(91%) | 66(84.6%) | ||
Coffee cups per day | 2.4 ± 1.4 | 2.3 ± 1.5 | 0.783* | |
Coffee intake before session | N | 36(46.2%) | 37(47.4%) | 0.873** |
Y | 42(53.8%) | 41(52.6%) | ||
Coffee during dialysis | N | 51(65.4%) | 47(60.3%) | 0.508** |
Y | 27(34.6%) | 31(39.7%) | ||
Diabetes | N | 45(57.7%) | 36(46.2%) | 0.149** |
Y | 33(42.3%) | 42(53.8%) | ||
Coronary artery disease | N | 49(62.8%) | 42(53.8%) | 0.256** |
Y | 29(37.2%) | 36(46.2%) | ||
Headache usually | N | 64(82.1%) | 67(85.9%) | 0.513** |
Y | 14(17.9%) | 11(14.1%) | ||
Beta-blockers | N | 18(23.1%) | 17(21.8%) | 0.848** |
Y | 60(76.9%) | 61(78.2%) | ||
Antidepressant/benzodiazepin | N | 58(74.4%) | 58(74.4%) | 1.000** |
Y | 20(25.6%) | 20(25.6%) | ||
Urea Reduction Ratio | 75.6 ± 5.3 | 76.5 ± 4.9 | 0.274* | |
Dialysate potassium | 0 | 4(5.1%) | 6(7.7%) | 0.468** |
1 | 33(42.3%) | 26(33.3%) | ||
2 | 41(52.6%) | 46(59%) | ||
Pre HD systolic pressure (averaged) | 146.5 ± 21.7 | 140.4 ± 21.1 | 0.076* | |
Pre HD diastolic pressure (averaged) | 76.7 ± 12.8 | 72.6 ± 11.9 | 0.036* | |
Pre HD heart rate (averaged) | 71.6 ± 10 | 68.8 ± 10 | 0.077* |
*Independent Samples Test; **Pearson Chi-Square; ***Mann-Whitney U;****Fischer's Exact Test
N, No; Y; Yes
- atrial fibrillation
- ethanol
- potassium
- smoking
- beta-blockers
- hypertension
- hemodialysis
- coronary arteriosclerosis
- coffee
- diabetes mellitus
- hypotension
- caffeine
- heart rate
- systolic blood pressure
- antidepressive agents
- diabetes mellitus, type 2
- consciousness related finding
- fatigue
- headache
- dialysis solutions
- ethics committees
- tissue membrane
- ultrafiltration
- dialysis procedure
- diastolic blood pressure
- caffeine withdrawal
- chief complaint
- urea reduction ratio
- primary outcome measure
Comments