-
Views
-
Cite
Cite
Maja Tarka, Geir H. Bolstad, Sebastian Wacker, Katja Räsänen, Thomas F. Hansen, Christophe Pélabon, Did natural selection make the Dutch taller? A cautionary note on the importance of quantification in understanding evolution, Evolution, Volume 69, Issue 12, 1 December 2015, Pages 3204–3206, https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12803
- Share Icon Share
Abstract
One of the main achievements of the modern synthesis is a rigorous mathematical theory for evolution by natural selection. Combining this theory with statistical models makes it possible to estimate the relevant parameters so as to quantify selection and evolution in nature. Although quantification is a sign of a mature science, statistical models are unfortunately often interpreted independently of the motivating mathematical theory. Without a link to theory, numerical results do not represent proper quantifications, because they lack the connections that designate their biological meaning. Here, we want to raise awareness and exemplify this problem by examining a recent study on natural selection in a contemporary human population. Stulp et al. (2015) concluded that natural selection may partly explain the increasing stature of the Dutch population. This conclusion was based on a qualitative assessment of the presence of selection on height. Here, we provide a quantitative interpretation of these results using standard evolutionary theory to show that natural selection has had a minuscule effect.