Skip to Main Content

Losing Twice: Harms of Indifference in the Supreme Court

Online ISBN:
9780199894444
Print ISBN:
9780195399745
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
Book

Losing Twice: Harms of Indifference in the Supreme Court

Emily M. Calhoun
Emily M. Calhoun

Professor of Law

University of Colorado Law School
Find on
Published online:
1 May 2011
Published in print:
8 March 2011
Online ISBN:
9780199894444
Print ISBN:
9780195399745
Publisher:
Oxford University Press

Abstract

Constitutional “losers” represent a thorny and longstanding problem in American constitutional law. Given the adversarial system in the United States, the way that rights cases are decided means that regardless of whether a losing side has committed any actions that cause harm to others, they typically suffer unnecessary harm as a consequence of decisions. In areas such as affirmative action and gay rights, the losers are essentially punished for losing despite neither intending nor causing injury. This book draws upon conflict resolution theory, political theory, and Habermasian discourse theory to argue that in such cases, the Court must work harder to avoid inflicting unnecessary harm on Constitutional losers. But for this to happen, the book contends, the role of judges needs to be reconceptualized. It contends that the Court should not perceive itself simply as an adversarial forum, but also as a “transactional” one, where losers are not simply losers but participants in a process capable of addressing and ameliorating the effects that come with loss.

Contents
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close