-
PDF
- Split View
-
Views
-
Cite
Cite
John C. Wise, Anthony H. VanWoerkom, Larry J. Gut, Drosophila Suzukii Control in Tart Cherries, 2016, Arthropod Management Tests, Volume 42, Issue 1, January 2017, tsx065, https://doi.org/10.1093/amt/tsx065
- Share Icon Share
This trial was conducted to evaluate the efficacy of several rates and timings of various insecticides against spotted wing drosophila (SWD) in tart cherry. Single tree plots were established in a 21-yr-old ‘Montmorency’ cherry planting (Tart Cherry 4, 15 × 20 ft spacing) at the Trevor Nichols Research Center in Fennville, MI. Treatment plots were replicated four times and set up in an RCB design. Applications began 20 July at the first trap catch and were reapplied on 7-day intervals until 10 Aug (Table 1). Test materials were applied with an FMC 1029 airblast sprayer calibrated to deliver 100 gpa at 2.5 mph. Regular maintenance foliar applications were applied to all treatments and included the fungicides Topsin, Bravo Weatherstick, Indar, Elite, Rally, Kocide 3000, Gem 500, Rally 40, Indar, Bravo Weatherstik, Cuprofix Ultra, and Badge. Alion and 2, 4-D Weedar were banded below the trees for weed control. Applications of test materials were made as outlined in Table 1.
Treatment/ . | Rate product/acre . | Appl. timing . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Formulation . | . | . | 7 Jul 2016 . | 14 Jul 2016 . | 20 Jul 2016 . |
Untreated check | 1.1ab | 4.6a | 19.1ab | ||
Movento 240 SC | 6.25 fl oz/a | AB | 0.6 abc | 2.4ab | 5.0abc |
R-11 90 EC | 0.25% v/v | AB | |||
Leverage 2.7 SE | 2.8 oz/a | CD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | ABCD | 0.1c | 0.2b | 0.7abc |
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | ABCD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | AB | 0.1c | 0.1b | 0.5bc |
TriFol L | 0.063% v/v | AB | |||
Exirel 0.83 SC | 13.5 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.5abc | 0.8b | 5.3abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.3abc | 0.8b | 3.5abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Admire Pro 550 SC | 2.8 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 0.3b | 7.0abc |
Indicator 5 90 EC | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.4abc | 0.6b | 29.1a |
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.2bc | 0.9b | 4.4abc |
R-56 P | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 1.3a | 2.5ab | 9.6abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | AC | 0.3abc | 0.2b | 3.8abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | AC | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | BD | |||
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | BD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 2.1ab | 4.4abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Pounce 25 WP | 12.8 oz/a | ABCD | |||
Harvanta 50 SL | 16.4 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.0c | 0.3b | 0.3c |
Harvanta 50 SL | 22 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.1bc | 0.0b | 0.7abc |
Dimilin 2 L | 16 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 1.2b | 1.1abc |
Rimon 0.83 EC | 20 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 0.2b | 5.4abc |
Treatment/ . | Rate product/acre . | Appl. timing . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Formulation . | . | . | 7 Jul 2016 . | 14 Jul 2016 . | 20 Jul 2016 . |
Untreated check | 1.1ab | 4.6a | 19.1ab | ||
Movento 240 SC | 6.25 fl oz/a | AB | 0.6 abc | 2.4ab | 5.0abc |
R-11 90 EC | 0.25% v/v | AB | |||
Leverage 2.7 SE | 2.8 oz/a | CD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | ABCD | 0.1c | 0.2b | 0.7abc |
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | ABCD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | AB | 0.1c | 0.1b | 0.5bc |
TriFol L | 0.063% v/v | AB | |||
Exirel 0.83 SC | 13.5 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.5abc | 0.8b | 5.3abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.3abc | 0.8b | 3.5abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Admire Pro 550 SC | 2.8 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 0.3b | 7.0abc |
Indicator 5 90 EC | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.4abc | 0.6b | 29.1a |
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.2bc | 0.9b | 4.4abc |
R-56 P | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 1.3a | 2.5ab | 9.6abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | AC | 0.3abc | 0.2b | 3.8abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | AC | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | BD | |||
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | BD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 2.1ab | 4.4abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Pounce 25 WP | 12.8 oz/a | ABCD | |||
Harvanta 50 SL | 16.4 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.0c | 0.3b | 0.3c |
Harvanta 50 SL | 22 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.1bc | 0.0b | 0.7abc |
Dimilin 2 L | 16 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 1.2b | 1.1abc |
Rimon 0.83 EC | 20 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 0.2b | 5.4abc |
Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P = 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). ANOVA performed on square-root transformed data; original means are shown. A = 24 Jun (first trap catch with ripe fruit), B = 1 Jul (A + 7 days), C = 8 Jul (B + 7 days), D = 15 Jul (C + 7 days).
Treatment/ . | Rate product/acre . | Appl. timing . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Formulation . | . | . | 7 Jul 2016 . | 14 Jul 2016 . | 20 Jul 2016 . |
Untreated check | 1.1ab | 4.6a | 19.1ab | ||
Movento 240 SC | 6.25 fl oz/a | AB | 0.6 abc | 2.4ab | 5.0abc |
R-11 90 EC | 0.25% v/v | AB | |||
Leverage 2.7 SE | 2.8 oz/a | CD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | ABCD | 0.1c | 0.2b | 0.7abc |
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | ABCD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | AB | 0.1c | 0.1b | 0.5bc |
TriFol L | 0.063% v/v | AB | |||
Exirel 0.83 SC | 13.5 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.5abc | 0.8b | 5.3abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.3abc | 0.8b | 3.5abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Admire Pro 550 SC | 2.8 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 0.3b | 7.0abc |
Indicator 5 90 EC | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.4abc | 0.6b | 29.1a |
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.2bc | 0.9b | 4.4abc |
R-56 P | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 1.3a | 2.5ab | 9.6abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | AC | 0.3abc | 0.2b | 3.8abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | AC | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | BD | |||
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | BD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 2.1ab | 4.4abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Pounce 25 WP | 12.8 oz/a | ABCD | |||
Harvanta 50 SL | 16.4 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.0c | 0.3b | 0.3c |
Harvanta 50 SL | 22 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.1bc | 0.0b | 0.7abc |
Dimilin 2 L | 16 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 1.2b | 1.1abc |
Rimon 0.83 EC | 20 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 0.2b | 5.4abc |
Treatment/ . | Rate product/acre . | Appl. timing . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . | # SWD per lb . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Formulation . | . | . | 7 Jul 2016 . | 14 Jul 2016 . | 20 Jul 2016 . |
Untreated check | 1.1ab | 4.6a | 19.1ab | ||
Movento 240 SC | 6.25 fl oz/a | AB | 0.6 abc | 2.4ab | 5.0abc |
R-11 90 EC | 0.25% v/v | AB | |||
Leverage 2.7 SE | 2.8 oz/a | CD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | ABCD | 0.1c | 0.2b | 0.7abc |
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | ABCD | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | AB | 0.1c | 0.1b | 0.5bc |
TriFol L | 0.063% v/v | AB | |||
Exirel 0.83 SC | 13.5 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.5abc | 0.8b | 5.3abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Delegate 25 WG | 6 oz/a | AB | 0.3abc | 0.8b | 3.5abc |
APTA 15 SC | 24 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Admire Pro 550 SC | 2.8 fl oz/a | CD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 0.3b | 7.0abc |
Indicator 5 90 EC | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.4abc | 0.6b | 29.1a |
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.2bc | 0.9b | 4.4abc |
R-56 P | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 1.3a | 2.5ab | 9.6abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | AC | 0.3abc | 0.2b | 3.8abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | AC | |||
Imidan 70 WP | 2.125 lb/a | BD | |||
TriFol L | 0.5 pt/100 gal | BD | |||
Grandevo WDG | 2 lb/a | ABCD | 0.3abc | 2.1ab | 4.4abc |
Tactic L | 0.125% v/v | ABCD | |||
Pounce 25 WP | 12.8 oz/a | ABCD | |||
Harvanta 50 SL | 16.4 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.0c | 0.3b | 0.3c |
Harvanta 50 SL | 22 fl oz/a | ABC | 0.1bc | 0.0b | 0.7abc |
Dimilin 2 L | 16 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 1.2b | 1.1abc |
Rimon 0.83 EC | 20 fl oz/a | AC | 0.1c | 0.2b | 5.4abc |
Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P = 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). ANOVA performed on square-root transformed data; original means are shown. A = 24 Jun (first trap catch with ripe fruit), B = 1 Jul (A + 7 days), C = 8 Jul (B + 7 days), D = 15 Jul (C + 7 days).
Four pound samples of ripe fruit were hand-picked from each replicate plot on 7, 14, and 20 Jul from one-tree plots. The collected fruit was then evaluated through the Washington State Department of Agriculture brown sugar method as follows. Cherries were crushed in a solution with the ratio of 7 pounds brown sugar to 5 gal water. The larvae were allowed to float and were subsequently counted. Data are presented as pupae per pound of fruit. Transformed treatment means were analyzed using ANOVA and means separation by Tukey’s HSD at P = 0.05.
In the 7-Jul evaluation, Imidan, Imidan/Exirel, Grandevo + R56, Rimon, Dimilin, and the two Harvanta treatments all provided significant protection from SWD larval infestation, compared to the untreated check (Table 1). In the 14-Jul evaluation, all treatments except Movento/Leverage, Grandevo + Tactic, Grandevo + Tactic/Pounce significantly reduced the incidence of SWD larvae in fruit. In the 20-Jul evaluation, only Imidan/Exirel and Harvanta (16.4 oz rate) provided significant fruit protection against SWD.
Author notes
* This research was supported by industry gift(s) of pesticides and/or research funding.
Subject Editor: Jonathan Babcock