Table 1

Main general characteristics of included studies

First author, yearCountryStudy designSample sizeCardiac
amyloidosis excluded
AS definitionLF-LG AS
n (%)
Primary outcomeSecondary outcome (Y/N)AVR (%)
All-cause mortalityHF hospitalization
Hammer M, 202115Asia (Israel)Prospective single centre57NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + strokeNoYesTAVR (88%), SAVR (12%)
Tamarappoo B, 202020America (USA)Retrospective single centre150NoAHA/ESC guidelines150 (100%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Han D, 202121America (USA)Retrospective single centre109NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNALVEF recovery (absolute increase of LVEF ≥ 10%)NoNoTAVR (100%)
Suzuki M, 202122Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre95NoAHA/ESC guidelines9 (9%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (78%), SAVR (22%)
Scully PR, 202223Europe (UK)Retrospective single centre106YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Ishiyama M, 202324Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre71NoAHA/ESC guidelines14 (19.7%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Vignale D, 202325Europe (Italy)Prospective single centre113NoAHA/ESC guidelines15 (13%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Koike H, 202426America (USA)Retrospective single centre300No (1 patient excluded for prior history of CA)AHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Takahashi M, 202427Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre127NoAHA/ESC guidelines6 (5%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Patel KP, 202428Europe
(UK)
Prospective single centre95YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
First author, yearCountryStudy designSample sizeCardiac
amyloidosis excluded
AS definitionLF-LG AS
n (%)
Primary outcomeSecondary outcome (Y/N)AVR (%)
All-cause mortalityHF hospitalization
Hammer M, 202115Asia (Israel)Prospective single centre57NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + strokeNoYesTAVR (88%), SAVR (12%)
Tamarappoo B, 202020America (USA)Retrospective single centre150NoAHA/ESC guidelines150 (100%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Han D, 202121America (USA)Retrospective single centre109NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNALVEF recovery (absolute increase of LVEF ≥ 10%)NoNoTAVR (100%)
Suzuki M, 202122Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre95NoAHA/ESC guidelines9 (9%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (78%), SAVR (22%)
Scully PR, 202223Europe (UK)Retrospective single centre106YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Ishiyama M, 202324Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre71NoAHA/ESC guidelines14 (19.7%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Vignale D, 202325Europe (Italy)Prospective single centre113NoAHA/ESC guidelines15 (13%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Koike H, 202426America (USA)Retrospective single centre300No (1 patient excluded for prior history of CA)AHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Takahashi M, 202427Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre127NoAHA/ESC guidelines6 (5%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Patel KP, 202428Europe
(UK)
Prospective single centre95YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)

LF-LG, low flow, low gradient; AS, aortic stenosis; AVR, aortic valve replacement; HF, heart failure; ASE, American Society of Echocardiography; ESC, European Society of Cardiology; TAVR, transcatheter aortic valve replacement; SAVR, surgical aortic valve replacement; LVEF, left ventricular ejection fraction; CA, cardiac amyloidosis; NA, not available.

Table 1

Main general characteristics of included studies

First author, yearCountryStudy designSample sizeCardiac
amyloidosis excluded
AS definitionLF-LG AS
n (%)
Primary outcomeSecondary outcome (Y/N)AVR (%)
All-cause mortalityHF hospitalization
Hammer M, 202115Asia (Israel)Prospective single centre57NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + strokeNoYesTAVR (88%), SAVR (12%)
Tamarappoo B, 202020America (USA)Retrospective single centre150NoAHA/ESC guidelines150 (100%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Han D, 202121America (USA)Retrospective single centre109NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNALVEF recovery (absolute increase of LVEF ≥ 10%)NoNoTAVR (100%)
Suzuki M, 202122Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre95NoAHA/ESC guidelines9 (9%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (78%), SAVR (22%)
Scully PR, 202223Europe (UK)Retrospective single centre106YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Ishiyama M, 202324Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre71NoAHA/ESC guidelines14 (19.7%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Vignale D, 202325Europe (Italy)Prospective single centre113NoAHA/ESC guidelines15 (13%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Koike H, 202426America (USA)Retrospective single centre300No (1 patient excluded for prior history of CA)AHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Takahashi M, 202427Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre127NoAHA/ESC guidelines6 (5%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Patel KP, 202428Europe
(UK)
Prospective single centre95YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
First author, yearCountryStudy designSample sizeCardiac
amyloidosis excluded
AS definitionLF-LG AS
n (%)
Primary outcomeSecondary outcome (Y/N)AVR (%)
All-cause mortalityHF hospitalization
Hammer M, 202115Asia (Israel)Prospective single centre57NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + strokeNoYesTAVR (88%), SAVR (12%)
Tamarappoo B, 202020America (USA)Retrospective single centre150NoAHA/ESC guidelines150 (100%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Han D, 202121America (USA)Retrospective single centre109NoAHA/ESC guidelinesNALVEF recovery (absolute increase of LVEF ≥ 10%)NoNoTAVR (100%)
Suzuki M, 202122Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre95NoAHA/ESC guidelines9 (9%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (78%), SAVR (22%)
Scully PR, 202223Europe (UK)Retrospective single centre106YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Ishiyama M, 202324Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre71NoAHA/ESC guidelines14 (19.7%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Vignale D, 202325Europe (Italy)Prospective single centre113NoAHA/ESC guidelines15 (13%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesYesTAVR (100%)
Koike H, 202426America (USA)Retrospective single centre300No (1 patient excluded for prior history of CA)AHA/ESC guidelinesNAHF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)
Takahashi M, 202427Asia (Japan)Retrospective single centre127NoAHA/ESC guidelines6 (5%)HF hospitalization + all-cause mortalityNoNoTAVR (100%)
Patel KP, 202428Europe
(UK)
Prospective single centre95YesAHA/ESC guidelinesNAAll-cause mortalityYesNoTAVR (100%)

LF-LG, low flow, low gradient; AS, aortic stenosis; AVR, aortic valve replacement; HF, heart failure; ASE, American Society of Echocardiography; ESC, European Society of Cardiology; TAVR, transcatheter aortic valve replacement; SAVR, surgical aortic valve replacement; LVEF, left ventricular ejection fraction; CA, cardiac amyloidosis; NA, not available.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close