Table 2.1
Open in new tab
Summary: The Challenge to Justice
Hesiod’s Works and Days‘Sisyphus Fragment’Antiphon’s On Truth, B44Clouds and History
1. The gods (Zeus) gave justice to humanityAgree: 274–80Disagree: 5–8Disagree: 1.23–2.1; and see discussion on pp. 41–2Disagree:  Cl. 904–6
2. The gods reward those who are just and punish those who are unjustAgree: 280–5Disagree: 9–15Disagree: 2.3–10Disagree:  Cl. 904–6 and Thuc. 5.105.2
3. Justice is beneficial to the just agentAgree: 225–47Qualifiedly Agree: 37–40; and see discussion on pp. 35–7Disagree: By omission; see discussion on pp. 42–5Disagree:  Thuc. 5.107.1
4. The rewards the just receive are (primarily) External GoodsAgree: 225–47Possibly Agree: See n.10Possibly Agree: See n.24Agree:  Cl. 1071–4
5. It is, all things considered, prudent for the individual to be justAgree: 270–3Disagree: see discussion on pp. 37–9Disagree: 1.12–23; and see discussion on pp. 45–7Disagree:  Cl. 1075–82
Hesiod’s Works and Days‘Sisyphus Fragment’Antiphon’s On Truth, B44Clouds and History
1. The gods (Zeus) gave justice to humanityAgree: 274–80Disagree: 5–8Disagree: 1.23–2.1; and see discussion on pp. 41–2Disagree:  Cl. 904–6
2. The gods reward those who are just and punish those who are unjustAgree: 280–5Disagree: 9–15Disagree: 2.3–10Disagree:  Cl. 904–6 and Thuc. 5.105.2
3. Justice is beneficial to the just agentAgree: 225–47Qualifiedly Agree: 37–40; and see discussion on pp. 35–7Disagree: By omission; see discussion on pp. 42–5Disagree:  Thuc. 5.107.1
4. The rewards the just receive are (primarily) External GoodsAgree: 225–47Possibly Agree: See n.10Possibly Agree: See n.24Agree:  Cl. 1071–4
5. It is, all things considered, prudent for the individual to be justAgree: 270–3Disagree: see discussion on pp. 37–9Disagree: 1.12–23; and see discussion on pp. 45–7Disagree:  Cl. 1075–82
Table 2.1
Open in new tab
Summary: The Challenge to Justice
Hesiod’s Works and Days‘Sisyphus Fragment’Antiphon’s On Truth, B44Clouds and History
1. The gods (Zeus) gave justice to humanityAgree: 274–80Disagree: 5–8Disagree: 1.23–2.1; and see discussion on pp. 41–2Disagree:  Cl. 904–6
2. The gods reward those who are just and punish those who are unjustAgree: 280–5Disagree: 9–15Disagree: 2.3–10Disagree:  Cl. 904–6 and Thuc. 5.105.2
3. Justice is beneficial to the just agentAgree: 225–47Qualifiedly Agree: 37–40; and see discussion on pp. 35–7Disagree: By omission; see discussion on pp. 42–5Disagree:  Thuc. 5.107.1
4. The rewards the just receive are (primarily) External GoodsAgree: 225–47Possibly Agree: See n.10Possibly Agree: See n.24Agree:  Cl. 1071–4
5. It is, all things considered, prudent for the individual to be justAgree: 270–3Disagree: see discussion on pp. 37–9Disagree: 1.12–23; and see discussion on pp. 45–7Disagree:  Cl. 1075–82
Hesiod’s Works and Days‘Sisyphus Fragment’Antiphon’s On Truth, B44Clouds and History
1. The gods (Zeus) gave justice to humanityAgree: 274–80Disagree: 5–8Disagree: 1.23–2.1; and see discussion on pp. 41–2Disagree:  Cl. 904–6
2. The gods reward those who are just and punish those who are unjustAgree: 280–5Disagree: 9–15Disagree: 2.3–10Disagree:  Cl. 904–6 and Thuc. 5.105.2
3. Justice is beneficial to the just agentAgree: 225–47Qualifiedly Agree: 37–40; and see discussion on pp. 35–7Disagree: By omission; see discussion on pp. 42–5Disagree:  Thuc. 5.107.1
4. The rewards the just receive are (primarily) External GoodsAgree: 225–47Possibly Agree: See n.10Possibly Agree: See n.24Agree:  Cl. 1071–4
5. It is, all things considered, prudent for the individual to be justAgree: 270–3Disagree: see discussion on pp. 37–9Disagree: 1.12–23; and see discussion on pp. 45–7Disagree:  Cl. 1075–82
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close