Table 4

Taxa where post‐glacial or late‐glacial inter‐oceanic relationships were inferred (or suspected), and divergence estimates

SpeciesPost‐ or late‐glacial invasionContact regionnet p‐dist. (%)n Pac / n Atlττ / L (%)References
Bivalves
Hiatella L aNP → NWA dNWA1.1059/26Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Hiatella L aNP → NWANWA f0.0259/480.650.10Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Macoma balthicaNP → NEA gNEA0.0926/260.550.09Nikula, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2007)
Macoma calcarea  aNEP/A/NWA/NEA b0.3020/850.240.04This study, Layton et al. 2013
Mytilus trossulusNP → NWA/NEA gNWA/NEA0.08194/680.530.10Marko et al. 2010, this study
Gastropods
Acanthodoris pilosaNA → NEPNEP0.112/15BOLD
Dendronotus venustus/frondosusNEA → NEPNEP0.512/10Dewaard 2017, Korshunova et al. 2019, Pola & Gosliner 2010,
Ekimova et al. 2016
Limacina helicinaf0.28209/138Abyzova et al. 2018, Chichvarkhin 2016, Shimizu et al. 2017, Hunt et al. 2010, Layton, Martel & Hebert 2014, Jennings et al. 2010
Velutina velutina?0.472/8BOLD
Crustaceans
Balanus crenatusNP → NWA d/NEA dNWA/NEA0.229/241.580.08This study
Balanus crenatus(NP → NWA/NEA) h(NWA/NEA)0.004/57This study
Centropages abdominalisNA → NEP0.346/19Young 2016, BOLD
Pandalus borealisNP → ARC ← NAARC f0.705/20This study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Gammarus setosus  aNWP/NANWPThis study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Pleopsis polyphaemoides(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.272/20Durbin et al. (2008)
Podon leukcartii(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.046/12Durbin et al. (2008)
Echinoderms
Echinarachnius parmaNP → NWA d0.3063/530.530.08This study
Henricia cf. oculataNEP → NWA0.343/4Corstorphine (2010)
Henricia sp. AAB9183NEP → NWANWA0.492/13Layton, Corstorphine & Hebert 2016
Henricia sp. EAC06NEP/NWACorstorphine (2010)
Strongylocentrotus droebachiensisNP → NWA dNWA f0.4133/1151.280.31Palumbi & Kessing 1991, Addison and Hart (2005), this study
Strongylocentrotus pallidusNP/NWA/NEABalakirev et al 2008, Corstophine 2010, Hardy et al. 2011
Polychaetes
Glycera capitataBer/NWA/NEACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe imbricata groupNEP/ARC/NWANEP/ARC/NWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe rarispina CMC03NWA → NEPNEP0.118/17Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03NWA → Ber1/26Hardy et al. 2010, Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03aBer/NWANWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Phyllodoce sp. CMC01aBer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe baltica ABer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe minuta ABer/ARC‐NWA0.554/29Carr et al. (2011)
NEP/NEANEAThis study
Fishes
Anisarchus medius  aNP → ARC ← NWA (?)ARCMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Aspidophoroides monopterygiusNP c → NWANWAMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Clupea pallasiiNWP → NEA gNEA0.06111/2422.320.21Laakkonen et al. (2013)
Eumesogrammus praecisus  aNP c → ARC ← NWAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Gadus chalcogrammus (G. finnmarchicus)NP → NEANEAUrsvik et al. (2007),Gorbachev et al. 2014
Gadus macrocephalus (G. ogac)NP → NWANWACoulson et al. (2006)
Gymnocanthus tricuspisNA → NPBerYamazaki et al. 2013
Leptagonus decagonus  aNWP c → ARC ← NAARC fMcCusker et al. 2012, BOLD
Leptoclinus maculatus  aNP → ARC ← NAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Liopsetta glacialisNWP → NEA b0.167/17This study, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Lumpenus fabriciiNP → NEANEA eThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Mallotus villosusNP → ARC/NWANWADodson et al. (2007)
Myoxocephalus scorpius  aNEA/NWA → NEPNEPThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Osmerus dentexNWP → ARC/NEANEA0.224/9Kovpak et al. 2011, Skurikhina et al. 2013
Reinhardtius hippoglossoides  aNP/NWA/NEA0.065/280Vis et al. 1997, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Mammals
Phoca hispida (sspp. hispida & ochotensis)aNEA /ARC/ NWP bThis study
SpeciesPost‐ or late‐glacial invasionContact regionnet p‐dist. (%)n Pac / n Atlττ / L (%)References
Bivalves
Hiatella L aNP → NWA dNWA1.1059/26Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Hiatella L aNP → NWANWA f0.0259/480.650.10Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Macoma balthicaNP → NEA gNEA0.0926/260.550.09Nikula, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2007)
Macoma calcarea  aNEP/A/NWA/NEA b0.3020/850.240.04This study, Layton et al. 2013
Mytilus trossulusNP → NWA/NEA gNWA/NEA0.08194/680.530.10Marko et al. 2010, this study
Gastropods
Acanthodoris pilosaNA → NEPNEP0.112/15BOLD
Dendronotus venustus/frondosusNEA → NEPNEP0.512/10Dewaard 2017, Korshunova et al. 2019, Pola & Gosliner 2010,
Ekimova et al. 2016
Limacina helicinaf0.28209/138Abyzova et al. 2018, Chichvarkhin 2016, Shimizu et al. 2017, Hunt et al. 2010, Layton, Martel & Hebert 2014, Jennings et al. 2010
Velutina velutina?0.472/8BOLD
Crustaceans
Balanus crenatusNP → NWA d/NEA dNWA/NEA0.229/241.580.08This study
Balanus crenatus(NP → NWA/NEA) h(NWA/NEA)0.004/57This study
Centropages abdominalisNA → NEP0.346/19Young 2016, BOLD
Pandalus borealisNP → ARC ← NAARC f0.705/20This study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Gammarus setosus  aNWP/NANWPThis study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Pleopsis polyphaemoides(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.272/20Durbin et al. (2008)
Podon leukcartii(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.046/12Durbin et al. (2008)
Echinoderms
Echinarachnius parmaNP → NWA d0.3063/530.530.08This study
Henricia cf. oculataNEP → NWA0.343/4Corstorphine (2010)
Henricia sp. AAB9183NEP → NWANWA0.492/13Layton, Corstorphine & Hebert 2016
Henricia sp. EAC06NEP/NWACorstorphine (2010)
Strongylocentrotus droebachiensisNP → NWA dNWA f0.4133/1151.280.31Palumbi & Kessing 1991, Addison and Hart (2005), this study
Strongylocentrotus pallidusNP/NWA/NEABalakirev et al 2008, Corstophine 2010, Hardy et al. 2011
Polychaetes
Glycera capitataBer/NWA/NEACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe imbricata groupNEP/ARC/NWANEP/ARC/NWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe rarispina CMC03NWA → NEPNEP0.118/17Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03NWA → Ber1/26Hardy et al. 2010, Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03aBer/NWANWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Phyllodoce sp. CMC01aBer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe baltica ABer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe minuta ABer/ARC‐NWA0.554/29Carr et al. (2011)
NEP/NEANEAThis study
Fishes
Anisarchus medius  aNP → ARC ← NWA (?)ARCMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Aspidophoroides monopterygiusNP c → NWANWAMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Clupea pallasiiNWP → NEA gNEA0.06111/2422.320.21Laakkonen et al. (2013)
Eumesogrammus praecisus  aNP c → ARC ← NWAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Gadus chalcogrammus (G. finnmarchicus)NP → NEANEAUrsvik et al. (2007),Gorbachev et al. 2014
Gadus macrocephalus (G. ogac)NP → NWANWACoulson et al. (2006)
Gymnocanthus tricuspisNA → NPBerYamazaki et al. 2013
Leptagonus decagonus  aNWP c → ARC ← NAARC fMcCusker et al. 2012, BOLD
Leptoclinus maculatus  aNP → ARC ← NAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Liopsetta glacialisNWP → NEA b0.167/17This study, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Lumpenus fabriciiNP → NEANEA eThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Mallotus villosusNP → ARC/NWANWADodson et al. (2007)
Myoxocephalus scorpius  aNEA/NWA → NEPNEPThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Osmerus dentexNWP → ARC/NEANEA0.224/9Kovpak et al. 2011, Skurikhina et al. 2013
Reinhardtius hippoglossoides  aNP/NWA/NEA0.065/280Vis et al. 1997, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Mammals
Phoca hispida (sspp. hispida & ochotensis)aNEA /ARC/ NWP bThis study

IMa analysis was performed only for taxa with sample sizes n > 10 in both basins: τ is an estimate of distance in terms of the number of observed inter‐oceanic nucleotide differences, and τ / L is the relative distance (per site), from the IMa analysis. The genetically documented distribution of the invading lineage and the inferred direction of post‐glacial spread and possible intra‐generic contact regions are indicated. References for previously published sequence data are listed in Table S2.

Net distance estimates between relevant clades are indicated, if sequence data were available (n > 2 for each population). Estimates were calculated with MEGA (Tamura et al. 2013). For a subset of comparisons, the population split time estimate from the IM analysis, translated to per‐site distance units, is also given.

a

Boreal–arctic species with possibly continuous range through the Arctic.

b

Post‐glacial spread without refugial disjunction.

c

No sequence data (from the actual basin).

d

Inferred spread in the last interglacial (ca 110–130 kya).

e

Other intra‐species contacts (not related to trans‐Arctic dispersal).

f

Contacts of late‐glacial lineages.

g

Instances where hybridization has been documented.

h

Suspected anthropogenic invasion.

Table 4

Taxa where post‐glacial or late‐glacial inter‐oceanic relationships were inferred (or suspected), and divergence estimates

SpeciesPost‐ or late‐glacial invasionContact regionnet p‐dist. (%)n Pac / n Atlττ / L (%)References
Bivalves
Hiatella L aNP → NWA dNWA1.1059/26Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Hiatella L aNP → NWANWA f0.0259/480.650.10Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Macoma balthicaNP → NEA gNEA0.0926/260.550.09Nikula, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2007)
Macoma calcarea  aNEP/A/NWA/NEA b0.3020/850.240.04This study, Layton et al. 2013
Mytilus trossulusNP → NWA/NEA gNWA/NEA0.08194/680.530.10Marko et al. 2010, this study
Gastropods
Acanthodoris pilosaNA → NEPNEP0.112/15BOLD
Dendronotus venustus/frondosusNEA → NEPNEP0.512/10Dewaard 2017, Korshunova et al. 2019, Pola & Gosliner 2010,
Ekimova et al. 2016
Limacina helicinaf0.28209/138Abyzova et al. 2018, Chichvarkhin 2016, Shimizu et al. 2017, Hunt et al. 2010, Layton, Martel & Hebert 2014, Jennings et al. 2010
Velutina velutina?0.472/8BOLD
Crustaceans
Balanus crenatusNP → NWA d/NEA dNWA/NEA0.229/241.580.08This study
Balanus crenatus(NP → NWA/NEA) h(NWA/NEA)0.004/57This study
Centropages abdominalisNA → NEP0.346/19Young 2016, BOLD
Pandalus borealisNP → ARC ← NAARC f0.705/20This study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Gammarus setosus  aNWP/NANWPThis study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Pleopsis polyphaemoides(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.272/20Durbin et al. (2008)
Podon leukcartii(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.046/12Durbin et al. (2008)
Echinoderms
Echinarachnius parmaNP → NWA d0.3063/530.530.08This study
Henricia cf. oculataNEP → NWA0.343/4Corstorphine (2010)
Henricia sp. AAB9183NEP → NWANWA0.492/13Layton, Corstorphine & Hebert 2016
Henricia sp. EAC06NEP/NWACorstorphine (2010)
Strongylocentrotus droebachiensisNP → NWA dNWA f0.4133/1151.280.31Palumbi & Kessing 1991, Addison and Hart (2005), this study
Strongylocentrotus pallidusNP/NWA/NEABalakirev et al 2008, Corstophine 2010, Hardy et al. 2011
Polychaetes
Glycera capitataBer/NWA/NEACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe imbricata groupNEP/ARC/NWANEP/ARC/NWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe rarispina CMC03NWA → NEPNEP0.118/17Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03NWA → Ber1/26Hardy et al. 2010, Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03aBer/NWANWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Phyllodoce sp. CMC01aBer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe baltica ABer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe minuta ABer/ARC‐NWA0.554/29Carr et al. (2011)
NEP/NEANEAThis study
Fishes
Anisarchus medius  aNP → ARC ← NWA (?)ARCMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Aspidophoroides monopterygiusNP c → NWANWAMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Clupea pallasiiNWP → NEA gNEA0.06111/2422.320.21Laakkonen et al. (2013)
Eumesogrammus praecisus  aNP c → ARC ← NWAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Gadus chalcogrammus (G. finnmarchicus)NP → NEANEAUrsvik et al. (2007),Gorbachev et al. 2014
Gadus macrocephalus (G. ogac)NP → NWANWACoulson et al. (2006)
Gymnocanthus tricuspisNA → NPBerYamazaki et al. 2013
Leptagonus decagonus  aNWP c → ARC ← NAARC fMcCusker et al. 2012, BOLD
Leptoclinus maculatus  aNP → ARC ← NAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Liopsetta glacialisNWP → NEA b0.167/17This study, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Lumpenus fabriciiNP → NEANEA eThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Mallotus villosusNP → ARC/NWANWADodson et al. (2007)
Myoxocephalus scorpius  aNEA/NWA → NEPNEPThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Osmerus dentexNWP → ARC/NEANEA0.224/9Kovpak et al. 2011, Skurikhina et al. 2013
Reinhardtius hippoglossoides  aNP/NWA/NEA0.065/280Vis et al. 1997, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Mammals
Phoca hispida (sspp. hispida & ochotensis)aNEA /ARC/ NWP bThis study
SpeciesPost‐ or late‐glacial invasionContact regionnet p‐dist. (%)n Pac / n Atlττ / L (%)References
Bivalves
Hiatella L aNP → NWA dNWA1.1059/26Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Hiatella L aNP → NWANWA f0.0259/480.650.10Laakkonen, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2015)
Macoma balthicaNP → NEA gNEA0.0926/260.550.09Nikula, Strelkov, and Väinölä (2007)
Macoma calcarea  aNEP/A/NWA/NEA b0.3020/850.240.04This study, Layton et al. 2013
Mytilus trossulusNP → NWA/NEA gNWA/NEA0.08194/680.530.10Marko et al. 2010, this study
Gastropods
Acanthodoris pilosaNA → NEPNEP0.112/15BOLD
Dendronotus venustus/frondosusNEA → NEPNEP0.512/10Dewaard 2017, Korshunova et al. 2019, Pola & Gosliner 2010,
Ekimova et al. 2016
Limacina helicinaf0.28209/138Abyzova et al. 2018, Chichvarkhin 2016, Shimizu et al. 2017, Hunt et al. 2010, Layton, Martel & Hebert 2014, Jennings et al. 2010
Velutina velutina?0.472/8BOLD
Crustaceans
Balanus crenatusNP → NWA d/NEA dNWA/NEA0.229/241.580.08This study
Balanus crenatus(NP → NWA/NEA) h(NWA/NEA)0.004/57This study
Centropages abdominalisNA → NEP0.346/19Young 2016, BOLD
Pandalus borealisNP → ARC ← NAARC f0.705/20This study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Gammarus setosus  aNWP/NANWPThis study, BOLD, Radulovici et al 2009
Pleopsis polyphaemoides(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.272/20Durbin et al. (2008)
Podon leukcartii(NA → NEP)h(NEP)0.046/12Durbin et al. (2008)
Echinoderms
Echinarachnius parmaNP → NWA d0.3063/530.530.08This study
Henricia cf. oculataNEP → NWA0.343/4Corstorphine (2010)
Henricia sp. AAB9183NEP → NWANWA0.492/13Layton, Corstorphine & Hebert 2016
Henricia sp. EAC06NEP/NWACorstorphine (2010)
Strongylocentrotus droebachiensisNP → NWA dNWA f0.4133/1151.280.31Palumbi & Kessing 1991, Addison and Hart (2005), this study
Strongylocentrotus pallidusNP/NWA/NEABalakirev et al 2008, Corstophine 2010, Hardy et al. 2011
Polychaetes
Glycera capitataBer/NWA/NEACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe imbricata groupNEP/ARC/NWANEP/ARC/NWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Harmothoe rarispina CMC03NWA → NEPNEP0.118/17Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03NWA → Ber1/26Hardy et al. 2010, Carr et al. (2011), BOLD
Nereis pelagica CMC03aBer/NWANWACarr et al. (2011), Hardy et al. 2011
Phyllodoce sp. CMC01aBer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe baltica ABer/ARC‐NWACarr et al. (2011)
Pholoe minuta ABer/ARC‐NWA0.554/29Carr et al. (2011)
NEP/NEANEAThis study
Fishes
Anisarchus medius  aNP → ARC ← NWA (?)ARCMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Aspidophoroides monopterygiusNP c → NWANWAMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Clupea pallasiiNWP → NEA gNEA0.06111/2422.320.21Laakkonen et al. (2013)
Eumesogrammus praecisus  aNP c → ARC ← NWAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Gadus chalcogrammus (G. finnmarchicus)NP → NEANEAUrsvik et al. (2007),Gorbachev et al. 2014
Gadus macrocephalus (G. ogac)NP → NWANWACoulson et al. (2006)
Gymnocanthus tricuspisNA → NPBerYamazaki et al. 2013
Leptagonus decagonus  aNWP c → ARC ← NAARC fMcCusker et al. 2012, BOLD
Leptoclinus maculatus  aNP → ARC ← NAARC fMecklenburg et al. (2011)
Liopsetta glacialisNWP → NEA b0.167/17This study, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Lumpenus fabriciiNP → NEANEA eThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Mallotus villosusNP → ARC/NWANWADodson et al. (2007)
Myoxocephalus scorpius  aNEA/NWA → NEPNEPThis study, Mecklenburg et al. (2011)
Osmerus dentexNWP → ARC/NEANEA0.224/9Kovpak et al. 2011, Skurikhina et al. 2013
Reinhardtius hippoglossoides  aNP/NWA/NEA0.065/280Vis et al. 1997, Kartavtsev et al. (2014)
Mammals
Phoca hispida (sspp. hispida & ochotensis)aNEA /ARC/ NWP bThis study

IMa analysis was performed only for taxa with sample sizes n > 10 in both basins: τ is an estimate of distance in terms of the number of observed inter‐oceanic nucleotide differences, and τ / L is the relative distance (per site), from the IMa analysis. The genetically documented distribution of the invading lineage and the inferred direction of post‐glacial spread and possible intra‐generic contact regions are indicated. References for previously published sequence data are listed in Table S2.

Net distance estimates between relevant clades are indicated, if sequence data were available (n > 2 for each population). Estimates were calculated with MEGA (Tamura et al. 2013). For a subset of comparisons, the population split time estimate from the IM analysis, translated to per‐site distance units, is also given.

a

Boreal–arctic species with possibly continuous range through the Arctic.

b

Post‐glacial spread without refugial disjunction.

c

No sequence data (from the actual basin).

d

Inferred spread in the last interglacial (ca 110–130 kya).

e

Other intra‐species contacts (not related to trans‐Arctic dispersal).

f

Contacts of late‐glacial lineages.

g

Instances where hybridization has been documented.

h

Suspected anthropogenic invasion.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close