Table 9:
Open in new tab

The P-value results of BMSSA and other MAS on CEC 2014 obtained using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test (Dim = 30). The P-values greater than 0.05 are in bold.

FunDEHHOSMAFAFOAGWOMFOHGSSSA
F11.73440E−062.87860E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.36756E−025.44625E−02
F28.58958E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.19734E−031.63945E−05
F31.63945E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.65655E−02
F43.51524E−063.18168E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−066.63921E−048.30707E−04
F51.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.84214E−039.36756E−02
F63.72426E−051.73440E−062.21022E−011.73440E−061.73440E−066.03501E−031.73440E−067.52133E−022.76527E−03
F71.12654E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−065.98356E−028.93644E−01
F83.58241E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−06
F94.94980E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.26255E−011.73440E−063.06500E−041.47954E−02
F102.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.18168E−061.73440E−06
F111.73440E−061.92092E−065.19307E−021.73440E−061.73440E−069.71105E−051.73440E−061.65655E−026.33914E−06
F121.73440E−061.73440E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−064.86026E−051.73440E−061.10792E−021.92092E−06
F131.36011E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.87860E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−06
F146.98378E−069.84214E−032.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.84342E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.49356E−05
F151.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.75184E−025.03833E−01
F161.73440E−061.73440E−063.60943E−031.73440E−061.73440E−063.32689E−021.73440E−062.41470E−031.92092E−06
F171.73440E−061.73440E−063.72426E−051.73440E−061.73440E−066.33914E−061.63945E−053.85424E−035.44006E−01
F183.16176E−031.73440E−064.68184E−031.73440E−061.73440E−062.22483E−048.18775E−058.72967E−036.43517E−01
F191.95692E−021.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.70877E−031.73440E−06
F204.28569E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.12654E−051.19734E−03
F211.35948E−044.28569E−061.79885E−051.73440E−061.73440E−065.28725E−041.36011E−052.61343E−041.30592E−01
F221.02463E−052.87860E−062.83079E−041.73440E−061.73440E−069.42611E−014.72920E−067.51366E−056.28843E−01
F234.32046E−081.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F241.73440E−061.82153E−052.56308E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.90625E−031.73440E−06
F251.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−065.60612E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F265.75165E−063.18168E−066.98378E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.14992E−041.92092E−061.92092E−067.49871E−01
F271.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F281.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F291.73440E−061.00000E+001.31834E−041.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F301.73440E−061.25000E−015.60612E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.25000E−011.73440E−06
FunDEHHOSMAFAFOAGWOMFOHGSSSA
F11.73440E−062.87860E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.36756E−025.44625E−02
F28.58958E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.19734E−031.63945E−05
F31.63945E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.65655E−02
F43.51524E−063.18168E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−066.63921E−048.30707E−04
F51.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.84214E−039.36756E−02
F63.72426E−051.73440E−062.21022E−011.73440E−061.73440E−066.03501E−031.73440E−067.52133E−022.76527E−03
F71.12654E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−065.98356E−028.93644E−01
F83.58241E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−06
F94.94980E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.26255E−011.73440E−063.06500E−041.47954E−02
F102.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.18168E−061.73440E−06
F111.73440E−061.92092E−065.19307E−021.73440E−061.73440E−069.71105E−051.73440E−061.65655E−026.33914E−06
F121.73440E−061.73440E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−064.86026E−051.73440E−061.10792E−021.92092E−06
F131.36011E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.87860E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−06
F146.98378E−069.84214E−032.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.84342E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.49356E−05
F151.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.75184E−025.03833E−01
F161.73440E−061.73440E−063.60943E−031.73440E−061.73440E−063.32689E−021.73440E−062.41470E−031.92092E−06
F171.73440E−061.73440E−063.72426E−051.73440E−061.73440E−066.33914E−061.63945E−053.85424E−035.44006E−01
F183.16176E−031.73440E−064.68184E−031.73440E−061.73440E−062.22483E−048.18775E−058.72967E−036.43517E−01
F191.95692E−021.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.70877E−031.73440E−06
F204.28569E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.12654E−051.19734E−03
F211.35948E−044.28569E−061.79885E−051.73440E−061.73440E−065.28725E−041.36011E−052.61343E−041.30592E−01
F221.02463E−052.87860E−062.83079E−041.73440E−061.73440E−069.42611E−014.72920E−067.51366E−056.28843E−01
F234.32046E−081.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F241.73440E−061.82153E−052.56308E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.90625E−031.73440E−06
F251.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−065.60612E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F265.75165E−063.18168E−066.98378E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.14992E−041.92092E−061.92092E−067.49871E−01
F271.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F281.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F291.73440E−061.00000E+001.31834E−041.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F301.73440E−061.25000E−015.60612E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.25000E−011.73440E−06
Table 9:
Open in new tab

The P-value results of BMSSA and other MAS on CEC 2014 obtained using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test (Dim = 30). The P-values greater than 0.05 are in bold.

FunDEHHOSMAFAFOAGWOMFOHGSSSA
F11.73440E−062.87860E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.36756E−025.44625E−02
F28.58958E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.19734E−031.63945E−05
F31.63945E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.65655E−02
F43.51524E−063.18168E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−066.63921E−048.30707E−04
F51.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.84214E−039.36756E−02
F63.72426E−051.73440E−062.21022E−011.73440E−061.73440E−066.03501E−031.73440E−067.52133E−022.76527E−03
F71.12654E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−065.98356E−028.93644E−01
F83.58241E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−06
F94.94980E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.26255E−011.73440E−063.06500E−041.47954E−02
F102.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.18168E−061.73440E−06
F111.73440E−061.92092E−065.19307E−021.73440E−061.73440E−069.71105E−051.73440E−061.65655E−026.33914E−06
F121.73440E−061.73440E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−064.86026E−051.73440E−061.10792E−021.92092E−06
F131.36011E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.87860E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−06
F146.98378E−069.84214E−032.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.84342E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.49356E−05
F151.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.75184E−025.03833E−01
F161.73440E−061.73440E−063.60943E−031.73440E−061.73440E−063.32689E−021.73440E−062.41470E−031.92092E−06
F171.73440E−061.73440E−063.72426E−051.73440E−061.73440E−066.33914E−061.63945E−053.85424E−035.44006E−01
F183.16176E−031.73440E−064.68184E−031.73440E−061.73440E−062.22483E−048.18775E−058.72967E−036.43517E−01
F191.95692E−021.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.70877E−031.73440E−06
F204.28569E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.12654E−051.19734E−03
F211.35948E−044.28569E−061.79885E−051.73440E−061.73440E−065.28725E−041.36011E−052.61343E−041.30592E−01
F221.02463E−052.87860E−062.83079E−041.73440E−061.73440E−069.42611E−014.72920E−067.51366E−056.28843E−01
F234.32046E−081.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F241.73440E−061.82153E−052.56308E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.90625E−031.73440E−06
F251.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−065.60612E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F265.75165E−063.18168E−066.98378E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.14992E−041.92092E−061.92092E−067.49871E−01
F271.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F281.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F291.73440E−061.00000E+001.31834E−041.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F301.73440E−061.25000E−015.60612E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.25000E−011.73440E−06
FunDEHHOSMAFAFOAGWOMFOHGSSSA
F11.73440E−062.87860E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.36756E−025.44625E−02
F28.58958E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.19734E−031.63945E−05
F31.63945E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.65655E−02
F43.51524E−063.18168E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−066.63921E−048.30707E−04
F51.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.84214E−039.36756E−02
F63.72426E−051.73440E−062.21022E−011.73440E−061.73440E−066.03501E−031.73440E−067.52133E−022.76527E−03
F71.12654E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−065.98356E−028.93644E−01
F83.58241E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−06
F94.94980E−021.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−069.26255E−011.73440E−063.06500E−041.47954E−02
F102.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.18168E−061.73440E−06
F111.73440E−061.92092E−065.19307E−021.73440E−061.73440E−069.71105E−051.73440E−061.65655E−026.33914E−06
F121.73440E−061.73440E−062.35342E−061.73440E−061.73440E−064.86026E−051.73440E−061.10792E−021.92092E−06
F131.36011E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.87860E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−06
F146.98378E−069.84214E−032.60333E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.84342E−051.73440E−061.73440E−061.49356E−05
F151.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.75184E−025.03833E−01
F161.73440E−061.73440E−063.60943E−031.73440E−061.73440E−063.32689E−021.73440E−062.41470E−031.92092E−06
F171.73440E−061.73440E−063.72426E−051.73440E−061.73440E−066.33914E−061.63945E−053.85424E−035.44006E−01
F183.16176E−031.73440E−064.68184E−031.73440E−061.73440E−062.22483E−048.18775E−058.72967E−036.43517E−01
F191.95692E−021.73440E−062.12664E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.70877E−031.73440E−06
F204.28569E−061.73440E−061.92092E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.12654E−051.19734E−03
F211.35948E−044.28569E−061.79885E−051.73440E−061.73440E−065.28725E−041.36011E−052.61343E−041.30592E−01
F221.02463E−052.87860E−062.83079E−041.73440E−061.73440E−069.42611E−014.72920E−067.51366E−056.28843E−01
F234.32046E−081.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F241.73440E−061.82153E−052.56308E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−063.90625E−031.73440E−06
F251.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−065.60612E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F265.75165E−063.18168E−066.98378E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.14992E−041.92092E−061.92092E−067.49871E−01
F271.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F281.73440E−061.00000E+001.00000E+001.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F291.73440E−061.00000E+001.31834E−041.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.00000E+001.73440E−06
F301.73440E−061.25000E−015.60612E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.73440E−061.25000E−011.73440E−06
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close