Table 3:

Differences in earnings, job satisfaction, and social capital by educational attainment and underemployment status

(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)
Pr (low earnings)Pr (high earnings)Pr (job dissatisfaction)HealthSocial trustCivic participationPolitical efficacy
AUTMG vs MiG–0.0911*0.183–0.03000.0613
MiG vs MnG0.0738*0.970***0.05600.142**
BELMG vs MiG–0.0937*0.154***–0.04730.006880.06310.06130.00567
MiG vs MnG–0.172***0.263***0.03780.335***1.092*** 0.0820 #0.262***
CANMG vs MiG–0.0840***0.196***0.403***0.0839***0.0206
MiG vs MnG0.02400.0949*0.488***0.110***0.140***
CYPMG vs MiG–0.237***0.347***–0.150**0.318**0.380** 0.0773 #0.0239
MiG vs MnG–0.0786 0.0898 # 0.0903 #–0.04060.01280.113**0.0249
CZEMG vs MiG–0.122*0.235***–0.0910*0.1610.2680.0976*0.0672
MiG vs MnG–0.148**0.146**–0.003780.307*0.656***0.02970.175**
DNKMG vs MiG–0.204***0.273***–0.0932***0.09070.514***0.01700.0416
MiG vs MnG–0.03690.124***0.0842**0.1220.694***0.03280.0254
ESTMG vs MiG–0.192***0.209***–0.130*** 0.109 #0.355***0.0823**0.135***
MiG vs MnG–0.0993**0.113***0.02580.294***0.540***0.104***0.106***
FINMG vs MiG–0.363***0.397***–0.0738*0.353**0.627**0.02170.114**
MiG vs MnG–0.03680.04680.04290.1030.439* 0.0989 #0.0842*
FRAMG vs MiG–0.278***0.367***–0.0740**0.208**0.471***0.01150.00697
MiG vs MnG–0.0764**0.124***0.02680.05790.895***0.0985**0.119***
DEUMG vs MiG–0.271***0.372*** –0.0871 # 0.198 #0.604**0.05400.0336
MiG vs MnG0.01070.02530.06770.1460.529**0.08590.174**
IRLMG vs MiG–0.185***0.302***–0.131*** 0.184 #0.375* 0.0657 #0.0834*
MiG vs MnG–0.228***0.242***0.04350.1290.499***0.03690.103**
ITAMG vs MiG–0.280***0.257***–0.121*0.03970.2660.0345–0.0319
MiG vs MnG0.006150.07680.08250.08270.4360.07590.170**
JPNMG vs MiG–0.164***0.295***–0.106***–0.0010.104–0.009580.0283
MiG vs MnG–0.108***0.108***–0.008360.120*0.565***0.0618*0.161***
KORMG vs MiG–0.113***0.127***–0.169***0.206**0.1160.03240.0344
MiG vs MnG–0.127***0.189***–0.04560.04280.367***0.126***0.0714*
NLDMG vs MiG–0.297***0.311***–0.0636**0.327***0.290*0.06240.112**
MiG vs MnG0.02070.0991** 0.0464 #–0.02040.867***0.0349 0.0684 #
NORMG vs MiG–0.315***0.294*** –0.0490 #0.0040.673***0.02820.142***
MiG vs MnG–0.0596 0.0795 #0.03560.278**0.839***0.0284 0.0811 #
POLMG vs MiG–0.235***0.290***–0.05370.234*0.422**0.0991*0.0654
MiG vs MnG–0.153**0.172***–0.04650.187*0.338*0.106*0.189***
SVKMG vs MiG–0.0910*0.150**–0.04720.0166 0.256 #0.04040.0125
MiG vs MnG–0.214***0.244*** –0.0650 #0.400***0.266*0.135**0.186***
ESPMG vs MiG–0.136***0.252***–0.0910**–0.0040.913***0.105*** 0.0757 #
MiG vs MnG–0.138***0.162***0.03630.08850.0501–0.002680.0106
SWEMG vs MiG–0.340***0.312***–0.0784* 0.196 #0.543**–0.04060.0165
MiG vs MnG–0.04140.101** 0.0552 #–0.01710.615***0.0850*0.126**
GBRMG vs MnG–0.259***0.343***–0.0828*0.1020.382**0.0963**0.0369
MiG vs MnG–0.03750.104**0.0724*0.218**0.537***0.122***0.153***
USAMG vs MnG–0.179***0.305***–0.128***0.206*0.549***0.02160.0477
MiG vs MnG–0.149***0.157***0.03850.409***0.513***0.210***0.145***
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)
Pr (low earnings)Pr (high earnings)Pr (job dissatisfaction)HealthSocial trustCivic participationPolitical efficacy
AUTMG vs MiG–0.0911*0.183–0.03000.0613
MiG vs MnG0.0738*0.970***0.05600.142**
BELMG vs MiG–0.0937*0.154***–0.04730.006880.06310.06130.00567
MiG vs MnG–0.172***0.263***0.03780.335***1.092*** 0.0820 #0.262***
CANMG vs MiG–0.0840***0.196***0.403***0.0839***0.0206
MiG vs MnG0.02400.0949*0.488***0.110***0.140***
CYPMG vs MiG–0.237***0.347***–0.150**0.318**0.380** 0.0773 #0.0239
MiG vs MnG–0.0786 0.0898 # 0.0903 #–0.04060.01280.113**0.0249
CZEMG vs MiG–0.122*0.235***–0.0910*0.1610.2680.0976*0.0672
MiG vs MnG–0.148**0.146**–0.003780.307*0.656***0.02970.175**
DNKMG vs MiG–0.204***0.273***–0.0932***0.09070.514***0.01700.0416
MiG vs MnG–0.03690.124***0.0842**0.1220.694***0.03280.0254
ESTMG vs MiG–0.192***0.209***–0.130*** 0.109 #0.355***0.0823**0.135***
MiG vs MnG–0.0993**0.113***0.02580.294***0.540***0.104***0.106***
FINMG vs MiG–0.363***0.397***–0.0738*0.353**0.627**0.02170.114**
MiG vs MnG–0.03680.04680.04290.1030.439* 0.0989 #0.0842*
FRAMG vs MiG–0.278***0.367***–0.0740**0.208**0.471***0.01150.00697
MiG vs MnG–0.0764**0.124***0.02680.05790.895***0.0985**0.119***
DEUMG vs MiG–0.271***0.372*** –0.0871 # 0.198 #0.604**0.05400.0336
MiG vs MnG0.01070.02530.06770.1460.529**0.08590.174**
IRLMG vs MiG–0.185***0.302***–0.131*** 0.184 #0.375* 0.0657 #0.0834*
MiG vs MnG–0.228***0.242***0.04350.1290.499***0.03690.103**
ITAMG vs MiG–0.280***0.257***–0.121*0.03970.2660.0345–0.0319
MiG vs MnG0.006150.07680.08250.08270.4360.07590.170**
JPNMG vs MiG–0.164***0.295***–0.106***–0.0010.104–0.009580.0283
MiG vs MnG–0.108***0.108***–0.008360.120*0.565***0.0618*0.161***
KORMG vs MiG–0.113***0.127***–0.169***0.206**0.1160.03240.0344
MiG vs MnG–0.127***0.189***–0.04560.04280.367***0.126***0.0714*
NLDMG vs MiG–0.297***0.311***–0.0636**0.327***0.290*0.06240.112**
MiG vs MnG0.02070.0991** 0.0464 #–0.02040.867***0.0349 0.0684 #
NORMG vs MiG–0.315***0.294*** –0.0490 #0.0040.673***0.02820.142***
MiG vs MnG–0.0596 0.0795 #0.03560.278**0.839***0.0284 0.0811 #
POLMG vs MiG–0.235***0.290***–0.05370.234*0.422**0.0991*0.0654
MiG vs MnG–0.153**0.172***–0.04650.187*0.338*0.106*0.189***
SVKMG vs MiG–0.0910*0.150**–0.04720.0166 0.256 #0.04040.0125
MiG vs MnG–0.214***0.244*** –0.0650 #0.400***0.266*0.135**0.186***
ESPMG vs MiG–0.136***0.252***–0.0910**–0.0040.913***0.105*** 0.0757 #
MiG vs MnG–0.138***0.162***0.03630.08850.0501–0.002680.0106
SWEMG vs MiG–0.340***0.312***–0.0784* 0.196 #0.543**–0.04060.0165
MiG vs MnG–0.04140.101** 0.0552 #–0.01710.615***0.0850*0.126**
GBRMG vs MnG–0.259***0.343***–0.0828*0.1020.382**0.0963**0.0369
MiG vs MnG–0.03750.104**0.0724*0.218**0.537***0.122***0.153***
USAMG vs MnG–0.179***0.305***–0.128***0.206*0.549***0.02160.0477
MiG vs MnG–0.149***0.157***0.03850.409***0.513***0.210***0.145***

Notes : Estimation sample of employed adult population in age group 25–65 with at least lower secondary levels of education. Outcomes are: (1) annual earnings in bottom two income quintiles, (2) annual earnings in the top two income quintiles, (3) not satisfied or extremely satisfied with current job, (4) self-assessed health in five categories, (5) sum score over two 4-level Likert items on the general trustworthiness of people, (6) at least some volunteer work in the last 12 months, (7) binary item that distinguishes between respondents who agree to the statement ‘People like me don’t have any say about what the government does’ versus those who disagree. The table displays the estimated marginal effects after either OLS (column 4), probit (columns 1, 2, 3, 6, and 7), or on the linear index after ordered probit (column 4). Estimations including controls (age-groups, cohabitation status, and dependent children dummy, all fully interacted with a gender dummy). Mismatched (underqualified) non-graduates were included in the regressions, but their coefficients are omitted for brevity. #p < 0.1, * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001.

Table 3:

Differences in earnings, job satisfaction, and social capital by educational attainment and underemployment status

(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)
Pr (low earnings)Pr (high earnings)Pr (job dissatisfaction)HealthSocial trustCivic participationPolitical efficacy
AUTMG vs MiG–0.0911*0.183–0.03000.0613
MiG vs MnG0.0738*0.970***0.05600.142**
BELMG vs MiG–0.0937*0.154***–0.04730.006880.06310.06130.00567
MiG vs MnG–0.172***0.263***0.03780.335***1.092*** 0.0820 #0.262***
CANMG vs MiG–0.0840***0.196***0.403***0.0839***0.0206
MiG vs MnG0.02400.0949*0.488***0.110***0.140***
CYPMG vs MiG–0.237***0.347***–0.150**0.318**0.380** 0.0773 #0.0239
MiG vs MnG–0.0786 0.0898 # 0.0903 #–0.04060.01280.113**0.0249
CZEMG vs MiG–0.122*0.235***–0.0910*0.1610.2680.0976*0.0672
MiG vs MnG–0.148**0.146**–0.003780.307*0.656***0.02970.175**
DNKMG vs MiG–0.204***0.273***–0.0932***0.09070.514***0.01700.0416
MiG vs MnG–0.03690.124***0.0842**0.1220.694***0.03280.0254
ESTMG vs MiG–0.192***0.209***–0.130*** 0.109 #0.355***0.0823**0.135***
MiG vs MnG–0.0993**0.113***0.02580.294***0.540***0.104***0.106***
FINMG vs MiG–0.363***0.397***–0.0738*0.353**0.627**0.02170.114**
MiG vs MnG–0.03680.04680.04290.1030.439* 0.0989 #0.0842*
FRAMG vs MiG–0.278***0.367***–0.0740**0.208**0.471***0.01150.00697
MiG vs MnG–0.0764**0.124***0.02680.05790.895***0.0985**0.119***
DEUMG vs MiG–0.271***0.372*** –0.0871 # 0.198 #0.604**0.05400.0336
MiG vs MnG0.01070.02530.06770.1460.529**0.08590.174**
IRLMG vs MiG–0.185***0.302***–0.131*** 0.184 #0.375* 0.0657 #0.0834*
MiG vs MnG–0.228***0.242***0.04350.1290.499***0.03690.103**
ITAMG vs MiG–0.280***0.257***–0.121*0.03970.2660.0345–0.0319
MiG vs MnG0.006150.07680.08250.08270.4360.07590.170**
JPNMG vs MiG–0.164***0.295***–0.106***–0.0010.104–0.009580.0283
MiG vs MnG–0.108***0.108***–0.008360.120*0.565***0.0618*0.161***
KORMG vs MiG–0.113***0.127***–0.169***0.206**0.1160.03240.0344
MiG vs MnG–0.127***0.189***–0.04560.04280.367***0.126***0.0714*
NLDMG vs MiG–0.297***0.311***–0.0636**0.327***0.290*0.06240.112**
MiG vs MnG0.02070.0991** 0.0464 #–0.02040.867***0.0349 0.0684 #
NORMG vs MiG–0.315***0.294*** –0.0490 #0.0040.673***0.02820.142***
MiG vs MnG–0.0596 0.0795 #0.03560.278**0.839***0.0284 0.0811 #
POLMG vs MiG–0.235***0.290***–0.05370.234*0.422**0.0991*0.0654
MiG vs MnG–0.153**0.172***–0.04650.187*0.338*0.106*0.189***
SVKMG vs MiG–0.0910*0.150**–0.04720.0166 0.256 #0.04040.0125
MiG vs MnG–0.214***0.244*** –0.0650 #0.400***0.266*0.135**0.186***
ESPMG vs MiG–0.136***0.252***–0.0910**–0.0040.913***0.105*** 0.0757 #
MiG vs MnG–0.138***0.162***0.03630.08850.0501–0.002680.0106
SWEMG vs MiG–0.340***0.312***–0.0784* 0.196 #0.543**–0.04060.0165
MiG vs MnG–0.04140.101** 0.0552 #–0.01710.615***0.0850*0.126**
GBRMG vs MnG–0.259***0.343***–0.0828*0.1020.382**0.0963**0.0369
MiG vs MnG–0.03750.104**0.0724*0.218**0.537***0.122***0.153***
USAMG vs MnG–0.179***0.305***–0.128***0.206*0.549***0.02160.0477
MiG vs MnG–0.149***0.157***0.03850.409***0.513***0.210***0.145***
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)
Pr (low earnings)Pr (high earnings)Pr (job dissatisfaction)HealthSocial trustCivic participationPolitical efficacy
AUTMG vs MiG–0.0911*0.183–0.03000.0613
MiG vs MnG0.0738*0.970***0.05600.142**
BELMG vs MiG–0.0937*0.154***–0.04730.006880.06310.06130.00567
MiG vs MnG–0.172***0.263***0.03780.335***1.092*** 0.0820 #0.262***
CANMG vs MiG–0.0840***0.196***0.403***0.0839***0.0206
MiG vs MnG0.02400.0949*0.488***0.110***0.140***
CYPMG vs MiG–0.237***0.347***–0.150**0.318**0.380** 0.0773 #0.0239
MiG vs MnG–0.0786 0.0898 # 0.0903 #–0.04060.01280.113**0.0249
CZEMG vs MiG–0.122*0.235***–0.0910*0.1610.2680.0976*0.0672
MiG vs MnG–0.148**0.146**–0.003780.307*0.656***0.02970.175**
DNKMG vs MiG–0.204***0.273***–0.0932***0.09070.514***0.01700.0416
MiG vs MnG–0.03690.124***0.0842**0.1220.694***0.03280.0254
ESTMG vs MiG–0.192***0.209***–0.130*** 0.109 #0.355***0.0823**0.135***
MiG vs MnG–0.0993**0.113***0.02580.294***0.540***0.104***0.106***
FINMG vs MiG–0.363***0.397***–0.0738*0.353**0.627**0.02170.114**
MiG vs MnG–0.03680.04680.04290.1030.439* 0.0989 #0.0842*
FRAMG vs MiG–0.278***0.367***–0.0740**0.208**0.471***0.01150.00697
MiG vs MnG–0.0764**0.124***0.02680.05790.895***0.0985**0.119***
DEUMG vs MiG–0.271***0.372*** –0.0871 # 0.198 #0.604**0.05400.0336
MiG vs MnG0.01070.02530.06770.1460.529**0.08590.174**
IRLMG vs MiG–0.185***0.302***–0.131*** 0.184 #0.375* 0.0657 #0.0834*
MiG vs MnG–0.228***0.242***0.04350.1290.499***0.03690.103**
ITAMG vs MiG–0.280***0.257***–0.121*0.03970.2660.0345–0.0319
MiG vs MnG0.006150.07680.08250.08270.4360.07590.170**
JPNMG vs MiG–0.164***0.295***–0.106***–0.0010.104–0.009580.0283
MiG vs MnG–0.108***0.108***–0.008360.120*0.565***0.0618*0.161***
KORMG vs MiG–0.113***0.127***–0.169***0.206**0.1160.03240.0344
MiG vs MnG–0.127***0.189***–0.04560.04280.367***0.126***0.0714*
NLDMG vs MiG–0.297***0.311***–0.0636**0.327***0.290*0.06240.112**
MiG vs MnG0.02070.0991** 0.0464 #–0.02040.867***0.0349 0.0684 #
NORMG vs MiG–0.315***0.294*** –0.0490 #0.0040.673***0.02820.142***
MiG vs MnG–0.0596 0.0795 #0.03560.278**0.839***0.0284 0.0811 #
POLMG vs MiG–0.235***0.290***–0.05370.234*0.422**0.0991*0.0654
MiG vs MnG–0.153**0.172***–0.04650.187*0.338*0.106*0.189***
SVKMG vs MiG–0.0910*0.150**–0.04720.0166 0.256 #0.04040.0125
MiG vs MnG–0.214***0.244*** –0.0650 #0.400***0.266*0.135**0.186***
ESPMG vs MiG–0.136***0.252***–0.0910**–0.0040.913***0.105*** 0.0757 #
MiG vs MnG–0.138***0.162***0.03630.08850.0501–0.002680.0106
SWEMG vs MiG–0.340***0.312***–0.0784* 0.196 #0.543**–0.04060.0165
MiG vs MnG–0.04140.101** 0.0552 #–0.01710.615***0.0850*0.126**
GBRMG vs MnG–0.259***0.343***–0.0828*0.1020.382**0.0963**0.0369
MiG vs MnG–0.03750.104**0.0724*0.218**0.537***0.122***0.153***
USAMG vs MnG–0.179***0.305***–0.128***0.206*0.549***0.02160.0477
MiG vs MnG–0.149***0.157***0.03850.409***0.513***0.210***0.145***

Notes : Estimation sample of employed adult population in age group 25–65 with at least lower secondary levels of education. Outcomes are: (1) annual earnings in bottom two income quintiles, (2) annual earnings in the top two income quintiles, (3) not satisfied or extremely satisfied with current job, (4) self-assessed health in five categories, (5) sum score over two 4-level Likert items on the general trustworthiness of people, (6) at least some volunteer work in the last 12 months, (7) binary item that distinguishes between respondents who agree to the statement ‘People like me don’t have any say about what the government does’ versus those who disagree. The table displays the estimated marginal effects after either OLS (column 4), probit (columns 1, 2, 3, 6, and 7), or on the linear index after ordered probit (column 4). Estimations including controls (age-groups, cohabitation status, and dependent children dummy, all fully interacted with a gender dummy). Mismatched (underqualified) non-graduates were included in the regressions, but their coefficients are omitted for brevity. #p < 0.1, * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close