Training and validation performance (RMSE and balanced accuracy, both measured on the final state) of different approaches for planetary collision treatment. Classification is performed as a post-processing step on top of predicted masses. We assume the SPH simulation data to be the ground truth. For single-task learning (lower half of the table), each entry corresponds to the performance of individually trained ML models and column headers indicate optimized tasks, respectively. We use data from Timpe et al. (2020b) to obtain results in the lower half. Best results are indicated in bold, whereas * indicate statistically significant results according to a Wilcoxon test (comparing FFN and RES). Our proposed RES model outperforms the other baseline methods in most experiments.
Method . | Split . | Mass . | Material . | Position . | Velocity . | Total . | Accuracy . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PIM | Training | |$0.1388^{+0.0008}_{-0.0012}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.4055^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0022}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0010}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training | |$0.0441^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.1617^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.1579^{+0.0011}_{-0.0015}$| | |$0.1375^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.2296^{+0.0068}_{-0.0088}$| |
FFN | Training | |$0.0060^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0115^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0403^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0446^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0367^{+0.0005}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.4422^{+0.0444}_{-0.0416}$| |
RES | Training | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0047^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0108^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0339^{+0.0003}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5234^{+0.0089}_{-0.0182}}$| |
PIM | Validation | |$0.1388^{+0.0048}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0004}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4056^{+0.0031}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0071}_{-0.0087}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0030}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation | |$0.0443^{+0.0012}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0005}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.1619^{+0.0024}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.1581^{+0.0066}_{-0.0042}$| | |$0.1377^{+0.0033}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.2380^{+0.0485}_{-0.0220}$| |
FFN | Validation | |$0.0066^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0117^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0420^{+0.0016}_{-0.0017}$| | |$0.0458^{+0.0023}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0379^{+0.0012}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.4558^{+0.0328}_{-0.0334}$| |
RES | Validation | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0052^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0111^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0320^{+0.0019}_{-0.0012}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0382^{+0.0015}_{-0.0022}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0309^{+0.0014}_{-0.0010}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5381^{+0.0438}_{-0.0631}}$| |
PIM | Training, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0014}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0019}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0017}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0528^{+0.0005}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0493^{+0.0004}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.2040^{+0.0013}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.1691^{+0.0009}_{-0.0007}$| | – | |$0.3019^{+0.0063}_{-0.0037}$| |
FFN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0124^{+0.0003}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0145^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0757^{+0.0017}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0589^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}$| | – | |$0.4172^{+0.0040}_{-0.0040}$| |
RES | Training, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0112^{+0.0004}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0138^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0658^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0548^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.4252^{+0.0063}_{-0.0059}}$| |
PIM | Validation, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0035}_{-0.0058}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0056}_{-0.0077}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0066}_{-0.0070}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0529^{+0.0015}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0495^{+0.0014}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.2044^{+0.0046}_{-0.0064}$| | |$0.1695^{+0.0043}_{-0.0046}$| | – | |$0.3010^{+0.0181}_{-0.0105}$| |
FFN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0137^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.0155^{+0.0009}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.0834^{+0.0056}_{-0.0025}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0642^{+0.0024}_{-0.0019}}$| | – | |$0.4196^{+0.0163}_{-0.0116}$| |
RES | Validation, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0130^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0152^{+0.0005}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0826^{+0.0054}_{-0.0035}}$| | |$0.0649^{+0.0028}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{0.4265^{+0.0059}_{-0.0049}}$| |
Method . | Split . | Mass . | Material . | Position . | Velocity . | Total . | Accuracy . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PIM | Training | |$0.1388^{+0.0008}_{-0.0012}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.4055^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0022}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0010}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training | |$0.0441^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.1617^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.1579^{+0.0011}_{-0.0015}$| | |$0.1375^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.2296^{+0.0068}_{-0.0088}$| |
FFN | Training | |$0.0060^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0115^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0403^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0446^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0367^{+0.0005}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.4422^{+0.0444}_{-0.0416}$| |
RES | Training | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0047^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0108^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0339^{+0.0003}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5234^{+0.0089}_{-0.0182}}$| |
PIM | Validation | |$0.1388^{+0.0048}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0004}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4056^{+0.0031}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0071}_{-0.0087}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0030}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation | |$0.0443^{+0.0012}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0005}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.1619^{+0.0024}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.1581^{+0.0066}_{-0.0042}$| | |$0.1377^{+0.0033}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.2380^{+0.0485}_{-0.0220}$| |
FFN | Validation | |$0.0066^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0117^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0420^{+0.0016}_{-0.0017}$| | |$0.0458^{+0.0023}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0379^{+0.0012}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.4558^{+0.0328}_{-0.0334}$| |
RES | Validation | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0052^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0111^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0320^{+0.0019}_{-0.0012}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0382^{+0.0015}_{-0.0022}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0309^{+0.0014}_{-0.0010}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5381^{+0.0438}_{-0.0631}}$| |
PIM | Training, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0014}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0019}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0017}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0528^{+0.0005}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0493^{+0.0004}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.2040^{+0.0013}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.1691^{+0.0009}_{-0.0007}$| | – | |$0.3019^{+0.0063}_{-0.0037}$| |
FFN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0124^{+0.0003}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0145^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0757^{+0.0017}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0589^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}$| | – | |$0.4172^{+0.0040}_{-0.0040}$| |
RES | Training, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0112^{+0.0004}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0138^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0658^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0548^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.4252^{+0.0063}_{-0.0059}}$| |
PIM | Validation, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0035}_{-0.0058}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0056}_{-0.0077}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0066}_{-0.0070}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0529^{+0.0015}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0495^{+0.0014}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.2044^{+0.0046}_{-0.0064}$| | |$0.1695^{+0.0043}_{-0.0046}$| | – | |$0.3010^{+0.0181}_{-0.0105}$| |
FFN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0137^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.0155^{+0.0009}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.0834^{+0.0056}_{-0.0025}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0642^{+0.0024}_{-0.0019}}$| | – | |$0.4196^{+0.0163}_{-0.0116}$| |
RES | Validation, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0130^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0152^{+0.0005}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0826^{+0.0054}_{-0.0035}}$| | |$0.0649^{+0.0028}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{0.4265^{+0.0059}_{-0.0049}}$| |
Training and validation performance (RMSE and balanced accuracy, both measured on the final state) of different approaches for planetary collision treatment. Classification is performed as a post-processing step on top of predicted masses. We assume the SPH simulation data to be the ground truth. For single-task learning (lower half of the table), each entry corresponds to the performance of individually trained ML models and column headers indicate optimized tasks, respectively. We use data from Timpe et al. (2020b) to obtain results in the lower half. Best results are indicated in bold, whereas * indicate statistically significant results according to a Wilcoxon test (comparing FFN and RES). Our proposed RES model outperforms the other baseline methods in most experiments.
Method . | Split . | Mass . | Material . | Position . | Velocity . | Total . | Accuracy . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PIM | Training | |$0.1388^{+0.0008}_{-0.0012}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.4055^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0022}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0010}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training | |$0.0441^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.1617^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.1579^{+0.0011}_{-0.0015}$| | |$0.1375^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.2296^{+0.0068}_{-0.0088}$| |
FFN | Training | |$0.0060^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0115^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0403^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0446^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0367^{+0.0005}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.4422^{+0.0444}_{-0.0416}$| |
RES | Training | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0047^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0108^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0339^{+0.0003}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5234^{+0.0089}_{-0.0182}}$| |
PIM | Validation | |$0.1388^{+0.0048}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0004}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4056^{+0.0031}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0071}_{-0.0087}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0030}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation | |$0.0443^{+0.0012}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0005}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.1619^{+0.0024}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.1581^{+0.0066}_{-0.0042}$| | |$0.1377^{+0.0033}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.2380^{+0.0485}_{-0.0220}$| |
FFN | Validation | |$0.0066^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0117^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0420^{+0.0016}_{-0.0017}$| | |$0.0458^{+0.0023}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0379^{+0.0012}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.4558^{+0.0328}_{-0.0334}$| |
RES | Validation | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0052^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0111^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0320^{+0.0019}_{-0.0012}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0382^{+0.0015}_{-0.0022}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0309^{+0.0014}_{-0.0010}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5381^{+0.0438}_{-0.0631}}$| |
PIM | Training, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0014}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0019}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0017}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0528^{+0.0005}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0493^{+0.0004}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.2040^{+0.0013}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.1691^{+0.0009}_{-0.0007}$| | – | |$0.3019^{+0.0063}_{-0.0037}$| |
FFN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0124^{+0.0003}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0145^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0757^{+0.0017}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0589^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}$| | – | |$0.4172^{+0.0040}_{-0.0040}$| |
RES | Training, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0112^{+0.0004}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0138^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0658^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0548^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.4252^{+0.0063}_{-0.0059}}$| |
PIM | Validation, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0035}_{-0.0058}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0056}_{-0.0077}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0066}_{-0.0070}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0529^{+0.0015}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0495^{+0.0014}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.2044^{+0.0046}_{-0.0064}$| | |$0.1695^{+0.0043}_{-0.0046}$| | – | |$0.3010^{+0.0181}_{-0.0105}$| |
FFN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0137^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.0155^{+0.0009}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.0834^{+0.0056}_{-0.0025}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0642^{+0.0024}_{-0.0019}}$| | – | |$0.4196^{+0.0163}_{-0.0116}$| |
RES | Validation, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0130^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0152^{+0.0005}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0826^{+0.0054}_{-0.0035}}$| | |$0.0649^{+0.0028}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{0.4265^{+0.0059}_{-0.0049}}$| |
Method . | Split . | Mass . | Material . | Position . | Velocity . | Total . | Accuracy . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PIM | Training | |$0.1388^{+0.0008}_{-0.0012}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.4055^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0022}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0010}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training | |$0.0441^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.1617^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.1579^{+0.0011}_{-0.0015}$| | |$0.1375^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.2296^{+0.0068}_{-0.0088}$| |
FFN | Training | |$0.0060^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0115^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0403^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0446^{+0.0006}_{-0.0007}$| | |$0.0367^{+0.0005}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.4422^{+0.0444}_{-0.0416}$| |
RES | Training | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0047^{+0.0001}_{-0.0001}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0108^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0339^{+0.0003}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0272^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5234^{+0.0089}_{-0.0182}}$| |
PIM | Validation | |$0.1388^{+0.0048}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0619^{+0.0004}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.4056^{+0.0031}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.4411^{+0.0071}_{-0.0087}$| | |$0.3619^{+0.0030}_{-0.0041}$| | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation | |$0.0443^{+0.0012}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0280^{+0.0005}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.1619^{+0.0024}_{-0.0018}$| | |$0.1581^{+0.0066}_{-0.0042}$| | |$0.1377^{+0.0033}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.2380^{+0.0485}_{-0.0220}$| |
FFN | Validation | |$0.0066^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0117^{+0.0002}_{-0.0001}$| | |$0.0420^{+0.0016}_{-0.0017}$| | |$0.0458^{+0.0023}_{-0.0032}$| | |$0.0379^{+0.0012}_{-0.0021}$| | |$0.4558^{+0.0328}_{-0.0334}$| |
RES | Validation | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0052^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0111^{+0.0003}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0320^{+0.0019}_{-0.0012}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0382^{+0.0015}_{-0.0022}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0309^{+0.0014}_{-0.0010}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.5381^{+0.0438}_{-0.0631}}$| |
PIM | Training, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0003}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0014}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0019}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0017}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0528^{+0.0005}_{-0.0004}$| | |$0.0493^{+0.0004}_{-0.0003}$| | |$0.2040^{+0.0013}_{-0.0014}$| | |$0.1691^{+0.0009}_{-0.0007}$| | – | |$0.3019^{+0.0063}_{-0.0037}$| |
FFN | Training, Timpe | |$0.0124^{+0.0003}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0145^{+0.0002}_{-0.0002}$| | |$0.0757^{+0.0017}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0589^{+0.0002}_{-0.0003}$| | – | |$0.4172^{+0.0040}_{-0.0040}$| |
RES | Training, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0112^{+0.0004}_{-0.0004}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0138^{+0.0005}_{-0.0006}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0658^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0548^{+0.0007}_{-0.0007}}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.4252^{+0.0063}_{-0.0059}}$| |
PIM | Validation, Timpe | |$0.2080^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}$| | |$0.1933^{+0.0035}_{-0.0058}$| | |$0.3598^{+0.0056}_{-0.0077}$| | |$0.2897^{+0.0066}_{-0.0070}$| | – | |$0.1667^{+0.0000}_{+0.0000}$| |
LIN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0529^{+0.0015}_{-0.0009}$| | |$0.0495^{+0.0014}_{-0.0005}$| | |$0.2044^{+0.0046}_{-0.0064}$| | |$0.1695^{+0.0043}_{-0.0046}$| | – | |$0.3010^{+0.0181}_{-0.0105}$| |
FFN | Validation, Timpe | |$0.0137^{+0.0010}_{-0.0008}$| | |$0.0155^{+0.0009}_{-0.0006}$| | |$0.0834^{+0.0056}_{-0.0025}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0642^{+0.0024}_{-0.0019}}$| | – | |$0.4196^{+0.0163}_{-0.0116}$| |
RES | Validation, Timpe | |$\boldsymbol{^{*}0.0130^{+0.0013}_{-0.0011}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0152^{+0.0005}_{-0.0003}}$| | |$\boldsymbol{0.0826^{+0.0054}_{-0.0035}}$| | |$0.0649^{+0.0028}_{-0.0017}$| | – | |$\boldsymbol{0.4265^{+0.0059}_{-0.0049}}$| |
This PDF is available to Subscribers Only
View Article Abstract & Purchase OptionsFor full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.