Table 2.

HRQOL before and after KT (N = 17)

ReferencesPatient characteristics
Effect measureHRQOL using SF-36 and KDQOL
HRQOL using WHOQOL
Physical
Mental
Disease-specific
Mean age (years)Male, %LDKT, %RRT before KT, %Time after KT (minutes)PCSPFRPBPGHMCSVTSFREMHSEKDBKDPHYPSYSOCENVTotal
Mousavi- Roknabadi et al. [23]3965373Mean rank (after/ before)55/50e40/27e48/47e65/13e56/24e49/54e47/26e54/30e
Russcher et al. [21]5164100363Mean change624b015b18b16b102
Gil et al. [24]36651003Mean (after/before)52/43b93/75b81/35b92/8578/60b56/46b74/58b92/64b93/58b86/70b-78/41b-
651/43b94/75b70/35b80/8270/60b53/46b76/58b80/64b79/58b85/70b
Virzi et al. [19]41a58100926Mean (after/before)77/7258/38e21/32c78/70c63/56c62/49c-77/60c-74/41b-
Griva et al. [57]435431006Cohen's d1.31.20.50.51.60.80.71.00.60.7
Painter et al. [22]44851006Mean change7b7b11b3b5b27b15b309b19b24b
Lopes et al. [17]37a6310012Median (after/ before)100/70b100/25b100/72b72/40b80/55b100/62b100/100b84/68b
Mitsui et al. [26]44a86100383% > MCID (PEKT/ non-PEKT)40/4040/4580/6020/3570/6055/6055/7070/6535/3060/60
1250/3333/5033/2525/2583/9258/7567/8367/5833/3350/42
Balaska et al. [20]44a525410012Mean (after/before)77/5662/10c90/4684/34d83/26c78/3183/40c68/23
Purnajo et al. [25]486734-12% > MCID3758393942414423
Lonning et al. [28]727121902Mean difference (SD)<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5<0.5
6<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
12<0.5>0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
von der Lippe et al. [27]576610040Mean differenceb<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5b<0.5>0.5d>0.5d
Shrestha et al. [16]39a5310046Mean (after/before)65/35c71/48c65/17c72/5954/22c69/39c63/30c77/43c76/44c79/59c
Das et al. [14]60%: 30–45g801006Mean (after/before)76/47c84/47c77/62c74/55c
Lumsdaine et al. [29]37a511001.5Mean (after/before)15/11f16/1516/1617/16
1216/11f16/1516/1616/16
Junchotikul et al. [15]88%: 33–60g62Mean difference----29c
Mendonca et al. [18]396297Mean (after/before)17/10c18/13c17/13c14/12c18/9c
ReferencesPatient characteristics
Effect measureHRQOL using SF-36 and KDQOL
HRQOL using WHOQOL
Physical
Mental
Disease-specific
Mean age (years)Male, %LDKT, %RRT before KT, %Time after KT (minutes)PCSPFRPBPGHMCSVTSFREMHSEKDBKDPHYPSYSOCENVTotal
Mousavi- Roknabadi et al. [23]3965373Mean rank (after/ before)55/50e40/27e48/47e65/13e56/24e49/54e47/26e54/30e
Russcher et al. [21]5164100363Mean change624b015b18b16b102
Gil et al. [24]36651003Mean (after/before)52/43b93/75b81/35b92/8578/60b56/46b74/58b92/64b93/58b86/70b-78/41b-
651/43b94/75b70/35b80/8270/60b53/46b76/58b80/64b79/58b85/70b
Virzi et al. [19]41a58100926Mean (after/before)77/7258/38e21/32c78/70c63/56c62/49c-77/60c-74/41b-
Griva et al. [57]435431006Cohen's d1.31.20.50.51.60.80.71.00.60.7
Painter et al. [22]44851006Mean change7b7b11b3b5b27b15b309b19b24b
Lopes et al. [17]37a6310012Median (after/ before)100/70b100/25b100/72b72/40b80/55b100/62b100/100b84/68b
Mitsui et al. [26]44a86100383% > MCID (PEKT/ non-PEKT)40/4040/4580/6020/3570/6055/6055/7070/6535/3060/60
1250/3333/5033/2525/2583/9258/7567/8367/5833/3350/42
Balaska et al. [20]44a525410012Mean (after/before)77/5662/10c90/4684/34d83/26c78/3183/40c68/23
Purnajo et al. [25]486734-12% > MCID3758393942414423
Lonning et al. [28]727121902Mean difference (SD)<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5<0.5
6<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
12<0.5>0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
von der Lippe et al. [27]576610040Mean differenceb<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5b<0.5>0.5d>0.5d
Shrestha et al. [16]39a5310046Mean (after/before)65/35c71/48c65/17c72/5954/22c69/39c63/30c77/43c76/44c79/59c
Das et al. [14]60%: 30–45g801006Mean (after/before)76/47c84/47c77/62c74/55c
Lumsdaine et al. [29]37a511001.5Mean (after/before)15/11f16/1516/1617/16
1216/11f16/1516/1616/16
Junchotikul et al. [15]88%: 33–60g62Mean difference----29c
Mendonca et al. [18]396297Mean (after/before)17/10c18/13c17/13c14/12c18/9c

Continuous variables are presented as the mean if not otherwise indicated. HRQOL results are presented in bold if they were reportedly significant according to statistical testing (P < 0.05) or a threshold for mean difference (difference > 0.5 SD or Cohen’s d > 0) or the percentages of patients who reported an improvement larger than MCID >50%.

–, not reported; ENV, environmental; MCID, minimal clinically important difference; MCS, mental component summary; PCS, physical component summary; PHY, physical; PSY, psychological; S, symptom; SOC, social.

a

Values presented as median.

b

P < 0.05.

c

P < 0.01.

d

P < 0.001.

e

P < 0.0001.

f

Statistical test conducted for comparison at three time points (before KT, 1.5 and 12 months after KT) and P < 0.05.

g

Percentage within the indicated range.

Table 2.

HRQOL before and after KT (N = 17)

ReferencesPatient characteristics
Effect measureHRQOL using SF-36 and KDQOL
HRQOL using WHOQOL
Physical
Mental
Disease-specific
Mean age (years)Male, %LDKT, %RRT before KT, %Time after KT (minutes)PCSPFRPBPGHMCSVTSFREMHSEKDBKDPHYPSYSOCENVTotal
Mousavi- Roknabadi et al. [23]3965373Mean rank (after/ before)55/50e40/27e48/47e65/13e56/24e49/54e47/26e54/30e
Russcher et al. [21]5164100363Mean change624b015b18b16b102
Gil et al. [24]36651003Mean (after/before)52/43b93/75b81/35b92/8578/60b56/46b74/58b92/64b93/58b86/70b-78/41b-
651/43b94/75b70/35b80/8270/60b53/46b76/58b80/64b79/58b85/70b
Virzi et al. [19]41a58100926Mean (after/before)77/7258/38e21/32c78/70c63/56c62/49c-77/60c-74/41b-
Griva et al. [57]435431006Cohen's d1.31.20.50.51.60.80.71.00.60.7
Painter et al. [22]44851006Mean change7b7b11b3b5b27b15b309b19b24b
Lopes et al. [17]37a6310012Median (after/ before)100/70b100/25b100/72b72/40b80/55b100/62b100/100b84/68b
Mitsui et al. [26]44a86100383% > MCID (PEKT/ non-PEKT)40/4040/4580/6020/3570/6055/6055/7070/6535/3060/60
1250/3333/5033/2525/2583/9258/7567/8367/5833/3350/42
Balaska et al. [20]44a525410012Mean (after/before)77/5662/10c90/4684/34d83/26c78/3183/40c68/23
Purnajo et al. [25]486734-12% > MCID3758393942414423
Lonning et al. [28]727121902Mean difference (SD)<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5<0.5
6<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
12<0.5>0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
von der Lippe et al. [27]576610040Mean differenceb<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5b<0.5>0.5d>0.5d
Shrestha et al. [16]39a5310046Mean (after/before)65/35c71/48c65/17c72/5954/22c69/39c63/30c77/43c76/44c79/59c
Das et al. [14]60%: 30–45g801006Mean (after/before)76/47c84/47c77/62c74/55c
Lumsdaine et al. [29]37a511001.5Mean (after/before)15/11f16/1516/1617/16
1216/11f16/1516/1616/16
Junchotikul et al. [15]88%: 33–60g62Mean difference----29c
Mendonca et al. [18]396297Mean (after/before)17/10c18/13c17/13c14/12c18/9c
ReferencesPatient characteristics
Effect measureHRQOL using SF-36 and KDQOL
HRQOL using WHOQOL
Physical
Mental
Disease-specific
Mean age (years)Male, %LDKT, %RRT before KT, %Time after KT (minutes)PCSPFRPBPGHMCSVTSFREMHSEKDBKDPHYPSYSOCENVTotal
Mousavi- Roknabadi et al. [23]3965373Mean rank (after/ before)55/50e40/27e48/47e65/13e56/24e49/54e47/26e54/30e
Russcher et al. [21]5164100363Mean change624b015b18b16b102
Gil et al. [24]36651003Mean (after/before)52/43b93/75b81/35b92/8578/60b56/46b74/58b92/64b93/58b86/70b-78/41b-
651/43b94/75b70/35b80/8270/60b53/46b76/58b80/64b79/58b85/70b
Virzi et al. [19]41a58100926Mean (after/before)77/7258/38e21/32c78/70c63/56c62/49c-77/60c-74/41b-
Griva et al. [57]435431006Cohen's d1.31.20.50.51.60.80.71.00.60.7
Painter et al. [22]44851006Mean change7b7b11b3b5b27b15b309b19b24b
Lopes et al. [17]37a6310012Median (after/ before)100/70b100/25b100/72b72/40b80/55b100/62b100/100b84/68b
Mitsui et al. [26]44a86100383% > MCID (PEKT/ non-PEKT)40/4040/4580/6020/3570/6055/6055/7070/6535/3060/60
1250/3333/5033/2525/2583/9258/7567/8367/5833/3350/42
Balaska et al. [20]44a525410012Mean (after/before)77/5662/10c90/4684/34d83/26c78/3183/40c68/23
Purnajo et al. [25]486734-12% > MCID3758393942414423
Lonning et al. [28]727121902Mean difference (SD)<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5<0.5
6<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
12<0.5>0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5>0.5<0.5
von der Lippe et al. [27]576610040Mean differenceb<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5<0.5>0.5b<0.5>0.5d>0.5d
Shrestha et al. [16]39a5310046Mean (after/before)65/35c71/48c65/17c72/5954/22c69/39c63/30c77/43c76/44c79/59c
Das et al. [14]60%: 30–45g801006Mean (after/before)76/47c84/47c77/62c74/55c
Lumsdaine et al. [29]37a511001.5Mean (after/before)15/11f16/1516/1617/16
1216/11f16/1516/1616/16
Junchotikul et al. [15]88%: 33–60g62Mean difference----29c
Mendonca et al. [18]396297Mean (after/before)17/10c18/13c17/13c14/12c18/9c

Continuous variables are presented as the mean if not otherwise indicated. HRQOL results are presented in bold if they were reportedly significant according to statistical testing (P < 0.05) or a threshold for mean difference (difference > 0.5 SD or Cohen’s d > 0) or the percentages of patients who reported an improvement larger than MCID >50%.

–, not reported; ENV, environmental; MCID, minimal clinically important difference; MCS, mental component summary; PCS, physical component summary; PHY, physical; PSY, psychological; S, symptom; SOC, social.

a

Values presented as median.

b

P < 0.05.

c

P < 0.01.

d

P < 0.001.

e

P < 0.0001.

f

Statistical test conducted for comparison at three time points (before KT, 1.5 and 12 months after KT) and P < 0.05.

g

Percentage within the indicated range.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close