Table 1.

Diagnostic Criteria for Acute and Early Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection Used at Clinical Research Sites for Enrollment of Participants in the A5354/EARLIER (Early Antiretroviral Therapy to Limit Infection and Establishment of Reservoir) Study

Inclusion AEHI CriterionCriterion to Diagnose HIV InfectionCriterion to Establish RecencyEstimated Fiebig Stage Group
ADetectable HIV RNA within 28 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
BDetectable HIV RNA or reactive HIV antibody within 28 daysandNegative/indeterminate WB or Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay within 7 daysIII/IV
CReactive HIV antibody, positive WB that is negative for p31 band, or positive Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay that is negative for p31 band within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody or undetectable HIV RNA within 90 days prior to study entryV
DARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥10 within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
EARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥ 1 within 7 days and prior S/CO <0.5 within 90 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
FDetectable HIV RNA within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 days and ARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO 0.5–9.9 within 7 daysI/II
Inclusion AEHI CriterionCriterion to Diagnose HIV InfectionCriterion to Establish RecencyEstimated Fiebig Stage Group
ADetectable HIV RNA within 28 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
BDetectable HIV RNA or reactive HIV antibody within 28 daysandNegative/indeterminate WB or Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay within 7 daysIII/IV
CReactive HIV antibody, positive WB that is negative for p31 band, or positive Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay that is negative for p31 band within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody or undetectable HIV RNA within 90 days prior to study entryV
DARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥10 within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
EARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥ 1 within 7 days and prior S/CO <0.5 within 90 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
FDetectable HIV RNA within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 days and ARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO 0.5–9.9 within 7 daysI/II

Eligibility for enrollment was assessed using available test results to satisfy 1 of 6 study-specific criteria for acute and early HIV infection, each of which was mapped to an estimated Fiebig stage group (defined by protocol as I/II, III/IV, or V). Criteria were designed to support HIV diagnosis in early stages of infection and establish relative recency of infection (including minimizing the risk of progression to Fiebig VI by the time of enrollment) while accommodating differences in testing procedures at study sites. Time periods refer to the number of days that a test could be collected prior to screening for study entry. Criteria D–F were designed to capture participants in the earliest stages of human immunodeficiency virus infection, with low-level viremia and before development of antibody responses to HIV. The S/CO was used as a surrogate for HIV RNA based on the understanding that p24 antigen detection at an S/CO of 0.5–10 (and a negative immunoglobulin M/immunoglobulin G immunoassay) corresponds roughly to an HIV RNA of 4.0–5.5 log10 copies/mL but is also the most common range for false-positive tests [30]. A recent increase of S/CO from below to within this range was considered indicative of new infection (criterion E). To minimize false-positive diagnoses, participants with this range of S/CO but no prior S/CO assessment required HIV RNA testing prior to enrollment (criterion F). The concomitant requirement for a nonreactive HIV antibody test within the preceding 7 days was designed a priori to exclude participants in Fiebig stages III–V.

Abbreviations: AEHI, acute and early HIV infection; HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; S/CO, signal-to-cutoff ratio (from ARCHITECT HIV Antigen/Antibody Combo assay or GS HIV Combo Antigen/Antibody enzyme immunoassay); WB, Western blot.

Table 1.

Diagnostic Criteria for Acute and Early Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection Used at Clinical Research Sites for Enrollment of Participants in the A5354/EARLIER (Early Antiretroviral Therapy to Limit Infection and Establishment of Reservoir) Study

Inclusion AEHI CriterionCriterion to Diagnose HIV InfectionCriterion to Establish RecencyEstimated Fiebig Stage Group
ADetectable HIV RNA within 28 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
BDetectable HIV RNA or reactive HIV antibody within 28 daysandNegative/indeterminate WB or Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay within 7 daysIII/IV
CReactive HIV antibody, positive WB that is negative for p31 band, or positive Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay that is negative for p31 band within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody or undetectable HIV RNA within 90 days prior to study entryV
DARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥10 within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
EARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥ 1 within 7 days and prior S/CO <0.5 within 90 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
FDetectable HIV RNA within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 days and ARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO 0.5–9.9 within 7 daysI/II
Inclusion AEHI CriterionCriterion to Diagnose HIV InfectionCriterion to Establish RecencyEstimated Fiebig Stage Group
ADetectable HIV RNA within 28 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
BDetectable HIV RNA or reactive HIV antibody within 28 daysandNegative/indeterminate WB or Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay within 7 daysIII/IV
CReactive HIV antibody, positive WB that is negative for p31 band, or positive Geenius HIV-1/2 Supplemental Assay that is negative for p31 band within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody or undetectable HIV RNA within 90 days prior to study entryV
DARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥10 within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
EARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO ≥ 1 within 7 days and prior S/CO <0.5 within 90 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 daysI/II
FDetectable HIV RNA within 7 daysandNonreactive HIV antibody within 7 days and ARCHITECT or GS HIV Combo S/CO 0.5–9.9 within 7 daysI/II

Eligibility for enrollment was assessed using available test results to satisfy 1 of 6 study-specific criteria for acute and early HIV infection, each of which was mapped to an estimated Fiebig stage group (defined by protocol as I/II, III/IV, or V). Criteria were designed to support HIV diagnosis in early stages of infection and establish relative recency of infection (including minimizing the risk of progression to Fiebig VI by the time of enrollment) while accommodating differences in testing procedures at study sites. Time periods refer to the number of days that a test could be collected prior to screening for study entry. Criteria D–F were designed to capture participants in the earliest stages of human immunodeficiency virus infection, with low-level viremia and before development of antibody responses to HIV. The S/CO was used as a surrogate for HIV RNA based on the understanding that p24 antigen detection at an S/CO of 0.5–10 (and a negative immunoglobulin M/immunoglobulin G immunoassay) corresponds roughly to an HIV RNA of 4.0–5.5 log10 copies/mL but is also the most common range for false-positive tests [30]. A recent increase of S/CO from below to within this range was considered indicative of new infection (criterion E). To minimize false-positive diagnoses, participants with this range of S/CO but no prior S/CO assessment required HIV RNA testing prior to enrollment (criterion F). The concomitant requirement for a nonreactive HIV antibody test within the preceding 7 days was designed a priori to exclude participants in Fiebig stages III–V.

Abbreviations: AEHI, acute and early HIV infection; HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; S/CO, signal-to-cutoff ratio (from ARCHITECT HIV Antigen/Antibody Combo assay or GS HIV Combo Antigen/Antibody enzyme immunoassay); WB, Western blot.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close