Table 2.

Health-care Professional Responses by Geographic Region

MidwestNortheastSoutheastSouthwestWestTotal
n = 358n = 408n = 212n = 108n = 565N = 1651
Shortages reported
 Intensivists32 (10%)81 (22%)26 (13%)10 (10%)40 (8%)189 (12%)
 ICU nurses107 (32%)177 (48%)40 (20%)28 (27%)73 (14%)425 (28%)
 ICU beds29 (10%)74 (23%)16 (9%)8 (10%)22 (5%)149 (11%)
PPE availability
Surgical mask
 Always available253 (89%)133 (84%)76 (81%)536 (79%)171 (75%)1169 (81%)
 Availability restricteda25 (9%)18 (11%)11 (12%)101 (15%)40 (18%)195 (13%)
 Intermittent supply shortages5 (2%)8 (5%)7 (7%)44 (6%)17 (7%)81 (6%)
N95 mask
 Always available100 (35%)63 (40%)40 (43%)195 (29%)82 (36%)480 (33%)
 Availability restricteda177 (63%)85 (53%)48 (51%)415 (61%)125 (55%)850 (59%)
 Intermittent supply shortages6 (2%)11 (7%)6 (6%)70 (10%)21 (9%)114 (8%)
Eye protection
 Always available152 (54%)76 (48%)50 (53%)320 (47%)122 (54%)720 (50%)
 Availability restricteda109 (39%)61 (38%)34 (36%)252 (37%)85 (37%)541 (37%)
 Intermittent supply shortages22 (8%)22 (14%)10 (11%)109 (16%)21 (9%)184 (13%)
Face shield
 Always available147 (52%)81 (51%)46 (49%)301 (44%)120 (53%)695 (48%)
 Availability restricteda129 (46%)63 (40%)35 (37%)290 (43%)89 (39%)606 (42%)
 Intermittent supply shortages7 (2%)15 (9%)13 (14%)89 (13%)19 (8%)143 (10%)
PAPRs
 Always available48 (17%)21 (13%)10 (11%)98 (14%)40 (18%)217 (15%)
 Availability restricteda169 (60%)83 (52%)54 (57%)391 (58%)117 (51%)814 (56%)
 Intermittent supply shortages66 (23%)55 (35%)30 (32%)191 (28%)71 (31%)413 (29%)
Gowns
 Always available274 (97%)150 (94%)92 (98%)664 (98%)219 (96%)1399 (97%)
 Availability restricteda9 (3%)9 (6%)1 (1%)13 (2%)6 (3%)38 (3%)
 Intermittent supply shortages0 (0%)0 (0%)1 (1%)3 (0%)3 (1%)7 (0%)
Gloves
 Always available209 (74%)106 (67%)73 (78%)467 (69%)173 (76%)1028 (71%)
 Availability restricteda66 (23%)38 (24%)15 (16%)170 (25%)47 (21%)336 (23%)
 Intermittent supply shortages8 (3%)15 (9%)6 (6%)43 (6%)8 (4%)80 (6%)
Agreement with hospital’s PPE policy
 Agree completely80 (25%)92 (26%)71 (37%)18 (19%)132 (27%)393 (27%)
 Agree somewhat152 (47%)166 (47%)80 (42%)37 (38%)234 (47%)669 (46%)
 Disagree somewhat58 (18%)59 (17%)29 (15%)23 (24%)79 (16%)248 (17%)
 Disagree completely31 (10%)34 (10%)12 (6%)19 (20%)50 (10%)146 (10%)
COVID-19 testing availability
Testing available for patients
 All patients87 (28%)157 (44%)66 (34%)19 (19%)206 (42%)535 (37%)
 Select patients, based on symptoms/risk factors228 (72%)197 (56%)131 (66%)79 (81%)284 (58%)919 (63%)
 No patients0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)
Testing available for HCPs
 All HCPs38 (13%)51 (15%)25 (14%)9 (9%)65 (14%)188 (13%)
 Select HCPs, based on symptoms/risk factors246 (82%)280 (81%)133 (73%)69 (72%)383 (81%)1111 (79%)
 No HCPs15 (5%)16 (5%)24 (13%)18 (19%)26 (5%)99 (7%)
HCP concerns
 Insufficient access to PPE138 (39%)166 (41%)73 (34%)53 (49%)231 (41%)661 (40%)
 Feel that hospital is unable to keep me safe92 (26%)109 (27%)42 (20%)41 (38%)140 (25%)424 (26%)
 Poor communication from supervisors86 (24%)90 (22%)41 (19%)38 (35%)104 (18%)359 (22%)
 Worries about own health196 (55%)204 (50%)98 (46%)61 (56%)254 (45%)813 (49%)
 Worries about financial situation40 (11%)61 (15%)30 (14%)18 (17%)55 (10%)204 (12%)
 Worries about transmitting infection to their family and community254 (71%)267 (65%)140 (66%)73 (68%)359 (64%)1093 (66%)
 Social stigma from my community101 (28%)94 (23%)49 (23%)41 (38%)138 (24%)423 (26%)
 Witnessing colleagues at hospital contract COVID-19155 (43%)159 (39%)62 (29%)34 (31%)191 (34%)601 (36%)
 Hearing about other providers contract COVID-19 from news171 (48%)186 (46%)82 (39%)42 (39%)258 (46%)739 (45%)
 Emotional distress/burnout231 (65%)233 (57%)117 (55%)68 (63%)302 (53%)951 (58%)
HCP behavior outside hospital to protect family
 Living separately from family36 (12%)46 (15%)14 (8%)12 (14%)38 (9%)146 (11%)
 Completely isolated from family11 (4%)11 (3%)4 (2%)3 (4%)10 (2%)39 (3%)
 Partially isolated from family42 (14%)65 (21%)22 (13%)13 (16%)85 (20%)227 (18%)
 Not isolated but extra precautions168 (57%)158 (50%)108 (63%)46 (55%)243 (56%)723 (56%)
 No changes compared to before pandemic37 (13%)35 (11%)23 (13%)9 (11%)58 (13%)162 (12%)
MidwestNortheastSoutheastSouthwestWestTotal
n = 358n = 408n = 212n = 108n = 565N = 1651
Shortages reported
 Intensivists32 (10%)81 (22%)26 (13%)10 (10%)40 (8%)189 (12%)
 ICU nurses107 (32%)177 (48%)40 (20%)28 (27%)73 (14%)425 (28%)
 ICU beds29 (10%)74 (23%)16 (9%)8 (10%)22 (5%)149 (11%)
PPE availability
Surgical mask
 Always available253 (89%)133 (84%)76 (81%)536 (79%)171 (75%)1169 (81%)
 Availability restricteda25 (9%)18 (11%)11 (12%)101 (15%)40 (18%)195 (13%)
 Intermittent supply shortages5 (2%)8 (5%)7 (7%)44 (6%)17 (7%)81 (6%)
N95 mask
 Always available100 (35%)63 (40%)40 (43%)195 (29%)82 (36%)480 (33%)
 Availability restricteda177 (63%)85 (53%)48 (51%)415 (61%)125 (55%)850 (59%)
 Intermittent supply shortages6 (2%)11 (7%)6 (6%)70 (10%)21 (9%)114 (8%)
Eye protection
 Always available152 (54%)76 (48%)50 (53%)320 (47%)122 (54%)720 (50%)
 Availability restricteda109 (39%)61 (38%)34 (36%)252 (37%)85 (37%)541 (37%)
 Intermittent supply shortages22 (8%)22 (14%)10 (11%)109 (16%)21 (9%)184 (13%)
Face shield
 Always available147 (52%)81 (51%)46 (49%)301 (44%)120 (53%)695 (48%)
 Availability restricteda129 (46%)63 (40%)35 (37%)290 (43%)89 (39%)606 (42%)
 Intermittent supply shortages7 (2%)15 (9%)13 (14%)89 (13%)19 (8%)143 (10%)
PAPRs
 Always available48 (17%)21 (13%)10 (11%)98 (14%)40 (18%)217 (15%)
 Availability restricteda169 (60%)83 (52%)54 (57%)391 (58%)117 (51%)814 (56%)
 Intermittent supply shortages66 (23%)55 (35%)30 (32%)191 (28%)71 (31%)413 (29%)
Gowns
 Always available274 (97%)150 (94%)92 (98%)664 (98%)219 (96%)1399 (97%)
 Availability restricteda9 (3%)9 (6%)1 (1%)13 (2%)6 (3%)38 (3%)
 Intermittent supply shortages0 (0%)0 (0%)1 (1%)3 (0%)3 (1%)7 (0%)
Gloves
 Always available209 (74%)106 (67%)73 (78%)467 (69%)173 (76%)1028 (71%)
 Availability restricteda66 (23%)38 (24%)15 (16%)170 (25%)47 (21%)336 (23%)
 Intermittent supply shortages8 (3%)15 (9%)6 (6%)43 (6%)8 (4%)80 (6%)
Agreement with hospital’s PPE policy
 Agree completely80 (25%)92 (26%)71 (37%)18 (19%)132 (27%)393 (27%)
 Agree somewhat152 (47%)166 (47%)80 (42%)37 (38%)234 (47%)669 (46%)
 Disagree somewhat58 (18%)59 (17%)29 (15%)23 (24%)79 (16%)248 (17%)
 Disagree completely31 (10%)34 (10%)12 (6%)19 (20%)50 (10%)146 (10%)
COVID-19 testing availability
Testing available for patients
 All patients87 (28%)157 (44%)66 (34%)19 (19%)206 (42%)535 (37%)
 Select patients, based on symptoms/risk factors228 (72%)197 (56%)131 (66%)79 (81%)284 (58%)919 (63%)
 No patients0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)
Testing available for HCPs
 All HCPs38 (13%)51 (15%)25 (14%)9 (9%)65 (14%)188 (13%)
 Select HCPs, based on symptoms/risk factors246 (82%)280 (81%)133 (73%)69 (72%)383 (81%)1111 (79%)
 No HCPs15 (5%)16 (5%)24 (13%)18 (19%)26 (5%)99 (7%)
HCP concerns
 Insufficient access to PPE138 (39%)166 (41%)73 (34%)53 (49%)231 (41%)661 (40%)
 Feel that hospital is unable to keep me safe92 (26%)109 (27%)42 (20%)41 (38%)140 (25%)424 (26%)
 Poor communication from supervisors86 (24%)90 (22%)41 (19%)38 (35%)104 (18%)359 (22%)
 Worries about own health196 (55%)204 (50%)98 (46%)61 (56%)254 (45%)813 (49%)
 Worries about financial situation40 (11%)61 (15%)30 (14%)18 (17%)55 (10%)204 (12%)
 Worries about transmitting infection to their family and community254 (71%)267 (65%)140 (66%)73 (68%)359 (64%)1093 (66%)
 Social stigma from my community101 (28%)94 (23%)49 (23%)41 (38%)138 (24%)423 (26%)
 Witnessing colleagues at hospital contract COVID-19155 (43%)159 (39%)62 (29%)34 (31%)191 (34%)601 (36%)
 Hearing about other providers contract COVID-19 from news171 (48%)186 (46%)82 (39%)42 (39%)258 (46%)739 (45%)
 Emotional distress/burnout231 (65%)233 (57%)117 (55%)68 (63%)302 (53%)951 (58%)
HCP behavior outside hospital to protect family
 Living separately from family36 (12%)46 (15%)14 (8%)12 (14%)38 (9%)146 (11%)
 Completely isolated from family11 (4%)11 (3%)4 (2%)3 (4%)10 (2%)39 (3%)
 Partially isolated from family42 (14%)65 (21%)22 (13%)13 (16%)85 (20%)227 (18%)
 Not isolated but extra precautions168 (57%)158 (50%)108 (63%)46 (55%)243 (56%)723 (56%)
 No changes compared to before pandemic37 (13%)35 (11%)23 (13%)9 (11%)58 (13%)162 (12%)

Responses are regarding availability of personnel, supplies, COVID-19 testing, and concerns.

Abbreviations: COVID-19, coronavirus disease 2019; HCP, health-care professional; ICU, intensive care unit; PAPR, powered air purifying respirators; PPE, personal protective equipment.

aAvailability restricted for select provider or based on patient characteristics.

Table 2.

Health-care Professional Responses by Geographic Region

MidwestNortheastSoutheastSouthwestWestTotal
n = 358n = 408n = 212n = 108n = 565N = 1651
Shortages reported
 Intensivists32 (10%)81 (22%)26 (13%)10 (10%)40 (8%)189 (12%)
 ICU nurses107 (32%)177 (48%)40 (20%)28 (27%)73 (14%)425 (28%)
 ICU beds29 (10%)74 (23%)16 (9%)8 (10%)22 (5%)149 (11%)
PPE availability
Surgical mask
 Always available253 (89%)133 (84%)76 (81%)536 (79%)171 (75%)1169 (81%)
 Availability restricteda25 (9%)18 (11%)11 (12%)101 (15%)40 (18%)195 (13%)
 Intermittent supply shortages5 (2%)8 (5%)7 (7%)44 (6%)17 (7%)81 (6%)
N95 mask
 Always available100 (35%)63 (40%)40 (43%)195 (29%)82 (36%)480 (33%)
 Availability restricteda177 (63%)85 (53%)48 (51%)415 (61%)125 (55%)850 (59%)
 Intermittent supply shortages6 (2%)11 (7%)6 (6%)70 (10%)21 (9%)114 (8%)
Eye protection
 Always available152 (54%)76 (48%)50 (53%)320 (47%)122 (54%)720 (50%)
 Availability restricteda109 (39%)61 (38%)34 (36%)252 (37%)85 (37%)541 (37%)
 Intermittent supply shortages22 (8%)22 (14%)10 (11%)109 (16%)21 (9%)184 (13%)
Face shield
 Always available147 (52%)81 (51%)46 (49%)301 (44%)120 (53%)695 (48%)
 Availability restricteda129 (46%)63 (40%)35 (37%)290 (43%)89 (39%)606 (42%)
 Intermittent supply shortages7 (2%)15 (9%)13 (14%)89 (13%)19 (8%)143 (10%)
PAPRs
 Always available48 (17%)21 (13%)10 (11%)98 (14%)40 (18%)217 (15%)
 Availability restricteda169 (60%)83 (52%)54 (57%)391 (58%)117 (51%)814 (56%)
 Intermittent supply shortages66 (23%)55 (35%)30 (32%)191 (28%)71 (31%)413 (29%)
Gowns
 Always available274 (97%)150 (94%)92 (98%)664 (98%)219 (96%)1399 (97%)
 Availability restricteda9 (3%)9 (6%)1 (1%)13 (2%)6 (3%)38 (3%)
 Intermittent supply shortages0 (0%)0 (0%)1 (1%)3 (0%)3 (1%)7 (0%)
Gloves
 Always available209 (74%)106 (67%)73 (78%)467 (69%)173 (76%)1028 (71%)
 Availability restricteda66 (23%)38 (24%)15 (16%)170 (25%)47 (21%)336 (23%)
 Intermittent supply shortages8 (3%)15 (9%)6 (6%)43 (6%)8 (4%)80 (6%)
Agreement with hospital’s PPE policy
 Agree completely80 (25%)92 (26%)71 (37%)18 (19%)132 (27%)393 (27%)
 Agree somewhat152 (47%)166 (47%)80 (42%)37 (38%)234 (47%)669 (46%)
 Disagree somewhat58 (18%)59 (17%)29 (15%)23 (24%)79 (16%)248 (17%)
 Disagree completely31 (10%)34 (10%)12 (6%)19 (20%)50 (10%)146 (10%)
COVID-19 testing availability
Testing available for patients
 All patients87 (28%)157 (44%)66 (34%)19 (19%)206 (42%)535 (37%)
 Select patients, based on symptoms/risk factors228 (72%)197 (56%)131 (66%)79 (81%)284 (58%)919 (63%)
 No patients0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)
Testing available for HCPs
 All HCPs38 (13%)51 (15%)25 (14%)9 (9%)65 (14%)188 (13%)
 Select HCPs, based on symptoms/risk factors246 (82%)280 (81%)133 (73%)69 (72%)383 (81%)1111 (79%)
 No HCPs15 (5%)16 (5%)24 (13%)18 (19%)26 (5%)99 (7%)
HCP concerns
 Insufficient access to PPE138 (39%)166 (41%)73 (34%)53 (49%)231 (41%)661 (40%)
 Feel that hospital is unable to keep me safe92 (26%)109 (27%)42 (20%)41 (38%)140 (25%)424 (26%)
 Poor communication from supervisors86 (24%)90 (22%)41 (19%)38 (35%)104 (18%)359 (22%)
 Worries about own health196 (55%)204 (50%)98 (46%)61 (56%)254 (45%)813 (49%)
 Worries about financial situation40 (11%)61 (15%)30 (14%)18 (17%)55 (10%)204 (12%)
 Worries about transmitting infection to their family and community254 (71%)267 (65%)140 (66%)73 (68%)359 (64%)1093 (66%)
 Social stigma from my community101 (28%)94 (23%)49 (23%)41 (38%)138 (24%)423 (26%)
 Witnessing colleagues at hospital contract COVID-19155 (43%)159 (39%)62 (29%)34 (31%)191 (34%)601 (36%)
 Hearing about other providers contract COVID-19 from news171 (48%)186 (46%)82 (39%)42 (39%)258 (46%)739 (45%)
 Emotional distress/burnout231 (65%)233 (57%)117 (55%)68 (63%)302 (53%)951 (58%)
HCP behavior outside hospital to protect family
 Living separately from family36 (12%)46 (15%)14 (8%)12 (14%)38 (9%)146 (11%)
 Completely isolated from family11 (4%)11 (3%)4 (2%)3 (4%)10 (2%)39 (3%)
 Partially isolated from family42 (14%)65 (21%)22 (13%)13 (16%)85 (20%)227 (18%)
 Not isolated but extra precautions168 (57%)158 (50%)108 (63%)46 (55%)243 (56%)723 (56%)
 No changes compared to before pandemic37 (13%)35 (11%)23 (13%)9 (11%)58 (13%)162 (12%)
MidwestNortheastSoutheastSouthwestWestTotal
n = 358n = 408n = 212n = 108n = 565N = 1651
Shortages reported
 Intensivists32 (10%)81 (22%)26 (13%)10 (10%)40 (8%)189 (12%)
 ICU nurses107 (32%)177 (48%)40 (20%)28 (27%)73 (14%)425 (28%)
 ICU beds29 (10%)74 (23%)16 (9%)8 (10%)22 (5%)149 (11%)
PPE availability
Surgical mask
 Always available253 (89%)133 (84%)76 (81%)536 (79%)171 (75%)1169 (81%)
 Availability restricteda25 (9%)18 (11%)11 (12%)101 (15%)40 (18%)195 (13%)
 Intermittent supply shortages5 (2%)8 (5%)7 (7%)44 (6%)17 (7%)81 (6%)
N95 mask
 Always available100 (35%)63 (40%)40 (43%)195 (29%)82 (36%)480 (33%)
 Availability restricteda177 (63%)85 (53%)48 (51%)415 (61%)125 (55%)850 (59%)
 Intermittent supply shortages6 (2%)11 (7%)6 (6%)70 (10%)21 (9%)114 (8%)
Eye protection
 Always available152 (54%)76 (48%)50 (53%)320 (47%)122 (54%)720 (50%)
 Availability restricteda109 (39%)61 (38%)34 (36%)252 (37%)85 (37%)541 (37%)
 Intermittent supply shortages22 (8%)22 (14%)10 (11%)109 (16%)21 (9%)184 (13%)
Face shield
 Always available147 (52%)81 (51%)46 (49%)301 (44%)120 (53%)695 (48%)
 Availability restricteda129 (46%)63 (40%)35 (37%)290 (43%)89 (39%)606 (42%)
 Intermittent supply shortages7 (2%)15 (9%)13 (14%)89 (13%)19 (8%)143 (10%)
PAPRs
 Always available48 (17%)21 (13%)10 (11%)98 (14%)40 (18%)217 (15%)
 Availability restricteda169 (60%)83 (52%)54 (57%)391 (58%)117 (51%)814 (56%)
 Intermittent supply shortages66 (23%)55 (35%)30 (32%)191 (28%)71 (31%)413 (29%)
Gowns
 Always available274 (97%)150 (94%)92 (98%)664 (98%)219 (96%)1399 (97%)
 Availability restricteda9 (3%)9 (6%)1 (1%)13 (2%)6 (3%)38 (3%)
 Intermittent supply shortages0 (0%)0 (0%)1 (1%)3 (0%)3 (1%)7 (0%)
Gloves
 Always available209 (74%)106 (67%)73 (78%)467 (69%)173 (76%)1028 (71%)
 Availability restricteda66 (23%)38 (24%)15 (16%)170 (25%)47 (21%)336 (23%)
 Intermittent supply shortages8 (3%)15 (9%)6 (6%)43 (6%)8 (4%)80 (6%)
Agreement with hospital’s PPE policy
 Agree completely80 (25%)92 (26%)71 (37%)18 (19%)132 (27%)393 (27%)
 Agree somewhat152 (47%)166 (47%)80 (42%)37 (38%)234 (47%)669 (46%)
 Disagree somewhat58 (18%)59 (17%)29 (15%)23 (24%)79 (16%)248 (17%)
 Disagree completely31 (10%)34 (10%)12 (6%)19 (20%)50 (10%)146 (10%)
COVID-19 testing availability
Testing available for patients
 All patients87 (28%)157 (44%)66 (34%)19 (19%)206 (42%)535 (37%)
 Select patients, based on symptoms/risk factors228 (72%)197 (56%)131 (66%)79 (81%)284 (58%)919 (63%)
 No patients0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)0 (0%)
Testing available for HCPs
 All HCPs38 (13%)51 (15%)25 (14%)9 (9%)65 (14%)188 (13%)
 Select HCPs, based on symptoms/risk factors246 (82%)280 (81%)133 (73%)69 (72%)383 (81%)1111 (79%)
 No HCPs15 (5%)16 (5%)24 (13%)18 (19%)26 (5%)99 (7%)
HCP concerns
 Insufficient access to PPE138 (39%)166 (41%)73 (34%)53 (49%)231 (41%)661 (40%)
 Feel that hospital is unable to keep me safe92 (26%)109 (27%)42 (20%)41 (38%)140 (25%)424 (26%)
 Poor communication from supervisors86 (24%)90 (22%)41 (19%)38 (35%)104 (18%)359 (22%)
 Worries about own health196 (55%)204 (50%)98 (46%)61 (56%)254 (45%)813 (49%)
 Worries about financial situation40 (11%)61 (15%)30 (14%)18 (17%)55 (10%)204 (12%)
 Worries about transmitting infection to their family and community254 (71%)267 (65%)140 (66%)73 (68%)359 (64%)1093 (66%)
 Social stigma from my community101 (28%)94 (23%)49 (23%)41 (38%)138 (24%)423 (26%)
 Witnessing colleagues at hospital contract COVID-19155 (43%)159 (39%)62 (29%)34 (31%)191 (34%)601 (36%)
 Hearing about other providers contract COVID-19 from news171 (48%)186 (46%)82 (39%)42 (39%)258 (46%)739 (45%)
 Emotional distress/burnout231 (65%)233 (57%)117 (55%)68 (63%)302 (53%)951 (58%)
HCP behavior outside hospital to protect family
 Living separately from family36 (12%)46 (15%)14 (8%)12 (14%)38 (9%)146 (11%)
 Completely isolated from family11 (4%)11 (3%)4 (2%)3 (4%)10 (2%)39 (3%)
 Partially isolated from family42 (14%)65 (21%)22 (13%)13 (16%)85 (20%)227 (18%)
 Not isolated but extra precautions168 (57%)158 (50%)108 (63%)46 (55%)243 (56%)723 (56%)
 No changes compared to before pandemic37 (13%)35 (11%)23 (13%)9 (11%)58 (13%)162 (12%)

Responses are regarding availability of personnel, supplies, COVID-19 testing, and concerns.

Abbreviations: COVID-19, coronavirus disease 2019; HCP, health-care professional; ICU, intensive care unit; PAPR, powered air purifying respirators; PPE, personal protective equipment.

aAvailability restricted for select provider or based on patient characteristics.

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close