Table 1.

Main GC parameters used in this work. For each cluster we provide: ID, average reddening, E(BV), distance module [|$(m-M)_V$|] and [Fe/H] (from the 2010 version of the Harris 1996, catalogue), cluster ages (this work), helium difference between 2G and 1G stars (⁠|$\rm \Delta \mathit{ Y}_{2G,1G}$|⁠), and maximum helium abundance variation (from Milone et al. 2018) and GC group (adapted from Milone et al. 2014, see Section 4.1).

Cluster namesE(BV) (mag)|$(m-M)_V \,\mathrm{ (mag)}$|[Fe/H]|$\rm [\alpha /Fe]$|Age (Gyr)|$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{2G,1G}$||$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{max}$|Group
NGC 0104, 47 Tuc0.0413.37−0.720.413.00 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0050.049 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 02880.0314.84−1.320.412.75 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.016 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 22980.1415.60−1.920.413.25 ± 0.50−0.003 ± 0.0080.011 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 28080.2215.59−1.140.412.00 ± 0.750.048 ± 0.0050.124 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 32010.2414.20−1.590.412.00 ± 0.50−0.001 ± 0.0130.028 ± 0.032M3-like
NGC 4590, M 680.0515.21−2.230.412.75 ± 0.750.007 ± 0.0090.012 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 48330.3215.08−1.850.413.25 ± 0.500.016 ± 0.0080.051 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 5024, M 530.0216.32−2.100.413.25 ± 0.750.013 ± 0.0070.044 ± 0.008M3-like
NGC 50530.0116.23−2.270.413.00 ± 0.50−0.002 ± 0.0130.004 ± 0.025M3-like
NGC 54660.0016.02−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.002 ± 0.0130.007 ± 0.024M3-like
NGC 5904, M 50.0314.46−1.290.412.25 ± 0.750.012 ± 0.0040.037 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 59270.4515.82−0.490.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0040.055 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 59860.2815.96−1.590.413.25 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0060.031 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 6093, M 800.1815.56−1.750.413.50 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0080.027 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 61010.0516.10−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0100.017 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 61440.3615.86−1.760.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.017 ± 0.013M13-like
NGC 6171, M 1070.3315.05−1.000.412.50 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0110.024 ± 0.014M3-like
NGC 6205, M 130.0214.33−1.520.412.25 ± 0.750.020 ± 0.0040.052 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6218, M 120.1914.01−1.370.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0070.011 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 6254, M 100.2814.08−1.560.412.75 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 63040.5415.52−0.450.212.50 ± 0.500.008 ± 0.0050.025 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 6341, M 920.0214.65−2.310.413.50 ± 0.750.022 ± 0.0040.039 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63520.2214.43−0.640.212.75 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0140.027 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63620.0914.68−1.000.412.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0110.004 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 63660.7114.94−0.590.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0100.011 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 63970.1812.37−2.000.413.00 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0090.008 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 64410.4716.78−0.460.212.25 ± 0.750.029 ± 0.0060.081 ± 0.022M3-like
NGC 64960.1515.74−0.460.212.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.021 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 65350.3415.34−1.790.413.25 ± 0.500.003 ± 0.0210.003 ± 0.022M13-like
NGC 65410.1414.82−1.810.413.00 ± 0.500.024 ± 0.0050.045 ± 0.006M13-like
NGC 65840.1015.96−1.500.412.25 ± 0.750.000 ± 0.0070.015 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 66240.2815.36−0.440.212.50 ± 0.500.010 ± 0.0040.022 ± 0.003M3-like
NGC 66370.1815.28−0.640.212.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0060.011 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 66520.0915.28−0.810.413.25 ± 0.250.008 ± 0.0070.017 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 6681, M 700.0714.99−1.620.413.25 ± 0.750.009 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6717, Pal 90.2214.94−1.280.413.00 ± 0.250.003 ± 0.0060.003 ± 0.009M13-like
NGC 67230.0514.84−1.100.413.00 ± 0.750.005 ± 0.0060.024 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 67520.0413.13−1.540.413.00 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0050.042 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6779, M 560.2615.68−1.990.413.50 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0070.031 ± 0.008M13-like
NGC 6809, M 550.0813.89−1.940.413.25 ± 0.500.014 ± 0.0080.026 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6838, M 710.2513.80−0.780.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0090.024 ± 0.010M3-like
NGC 6981, M 720.0516.31−1.420.412.25 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0060.017 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7078, M 150.1015.39−2.370.413.00 ± 0.750.021 ± 0.0090.069 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7099, M 300.0314.64−2.270.413.50 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.022 ± 0.010M13-like
Cluster namesE(BV) (mag)|$(m-M)_V \,\mathrm{ (mag)}$|[Fe/H]|$\rm [\alpha /Fe]$|Age (Gyr)|$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{2G,1G}$||$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{max}$|Group
NGC 0104, 47 Tuc0.0413.37−0.720.413.00 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0050.049 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 02880.0314.84−1.320.412.75 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.016 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 22980.1415.60−1.920.413.25 ± 0.50−0.003 ± 0.0080.011 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 28080.2215.59−1.140.412.00 ± 0.750.048 ± 0.0050.124 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 32010.2414.20−1.590.412.00 ± 0.50−0.001 ± 0.0130.028 ± 0.032M3-like
NGC 4590, M 680.0515.21−2.230.412.75 ± 0.750.007 ± 0.0090.012 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 48330.3215.08−1.850.413.25 ± 0.500.016 ± 0.0080.051 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 5024, M 530.0216.32−2.100.413.25 ± 0.750.013 ± 0.0070.044 ± 0.008M3-like
NGC 50530.0116.23−2.270.413.00 ± 0.50−0.002 ± 0.0130.004 ± 0.025M3-like
NGC 54660.0016.02−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.002 ± 0.0130.007 ± 0.024M3-like
NGC 5904, M 50.0314.46−1.290.412.25 ± 0.750.012 ± 0.0040.037 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 59270.4515.82−0.490.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0040.055 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 59860.2815.96−1.590.413.25 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0060.031 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 6093, M 800.1815.56−1.750.413.50 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0080.027 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 61010.0516.10−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0100.017 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 61440.3615.86−1.760.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.017 ± 0.013M13-like
NGC 6171, M 1070.3315.05−1.000.412.50 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0110.024 ± 0.014M3-like
NGC 6205, M 130.0214.33−1.520.412.25 ± 0.750.020 ± 0.0040.052 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6218, M 120.1914.01−1.370.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0070.011 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 6254, M 100.2814.08−1.560.412.75 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 63040.5415.52−0.450.212.50 ± 0.500.008 ± 0.0050.025 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 6341, M 920.0214.65−2.310.413.50 ± 0.750.022 ± 0.0040.039 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63520.2214.43−0.640.212.75 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0140.027 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63620.0914.68−1.000.412.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0110.004 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 63660.7114.94−0.590.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0100.011 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 63970.1812.37−2.000.413.00 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0090.008 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 64410.4716.78−0.460.212.25 ± 0.750.029 ± 0.0060.081 ± 0.022M3-like
NGC 64960.1515.74−0.460.212.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.021 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 65350.3415.34−1.790.413.25 ± 0.500.003 ± 0.0210.003 ± 0.022M13-like
NGC 65410.1414.82−1.810.413.00 ± 0.500.024 ± 0.0050.045 ± 0.006M13-like
NGC 65840.1015.96−1.500.412.25 ± 0.750.000 ± 0.0070.015 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 66240.2815.36−0.440.212.50 ± 0.500.010 ± 0.0040.022 ± 0.003M3-like
NGC 66370.1815.28−0.640.212.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0060.011 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 66520.0915.28−0.810.413.25 ± 0.250.008 ± 0.0070.017 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 6681, M 700.0714.99−1.620.413.25 ± 0.750.009 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6717, Pal 90.2214.94−1.280.413.00 ± 0.250.003 ± 0.0060.003 ± 0.009M13-like
NGC 67230.0514.84−1.100.413.00 ± 0.750.005 ± 0.0060.024 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 67520.0413.13−1.540.413.00 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0050.042 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6779, M 560.2615.68−1.990.413.50 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0070.031 ± 0.008M13-like
NGC 6809, M 550.0813.89−1.940.413.25 ± 0.500.014 ± 0.0080.026 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6838, M 710.2513.80−0.780.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0090.024 ± 0.010M3-like
NGC 6981, M 720.0516.31−1.420.412.25 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0060.017 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7078, M 150.1015.39−2.370.413.00 ± 0.750.021 ± 0.0090.069 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7099, M 300.0314.64−2.270.413.50 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.022 ± 0.010M13-like
Table 1.

Main GC parameters used in this work. For each cluster we provide: ID, average reddening, E(BV), distance module [|$(m-M)_V$|] and [Fe/H] (from the 2010 version of the Harris 1996, catalogue), cluster ages (this work), helium difference between 2G and 1G stars (⁠|$\rm \Delta \mathit{ Y}_{2G,1G}$|⁠), and maximum helium abundance variation (from Milone et al. 2018) and GC group (adapted from Milone et al. 2014, see Section 4.1).

Cluster namesE(BV) (mag)|$(m-M)_V \,\mathrm{ (mag)}$|[Fe/H]|$\rm [\alpha /Fe]$|Age (Gyr)|$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{2G,1G}$||$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{max}$|Group
NGC 0104, 47 Tuc0.0413.37−0.720.413.00 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0050.049 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 02880.0314.84−1.320.412.75 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.016 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 22980.1415.60−1.920.413.25 ± 0.50−0.003 ± 0.0080.011 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 28080.2215.59−1.140.412.00 ± 0.750.048 ± 0.0050.124 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 32010.2414.20−1.590.412.00 ± 0.50−0.001 ± 0.0130.028 ± 0.032M3-like
NGC 4590, M 680.0515.21−2.230.412.75 ± 0.750.007 ± 0.0090.012 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 48330.3215.08−1.850.413.25 ± 0.500.016 ± 0.0080.051 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 5024, M 530.0216.32−2.100.413.25 ± 0.750.013 ± 0.0070.044 ± 0.008M3-like
NGC 50530.0116.23−2.270.413.00 ± 0.50−0.002 ± 0.0130.004 ± 0.025M3-like
NGC 54660.0016.02−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.002 ± 0.0130.007 ± 0.024M3-like
NGC 5904, M 50.0314.46−1.290.412.25 ± 0.750.012 ± 0.0040.037 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 59270.4515.82−0.490.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0040.055 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 59860.2815.96−1.590.413.25 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0060.031 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 6093, M 800.1815.56−1.750.413.50 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0080.027 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 61010.0516.10−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0100.017 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 61440.3615.86−1.760.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.017 ± 0.013M13-like
NGC 6171, M 1070.3315.05−1.000.412.50 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0110.024 ± 0.014M3-like
NGC 6205, M 130.0214.33−1.520.412.25 ± 0.750.020 ± 0.0040.052 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6218, M 120.1914.01−1.370.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0070.011 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 6254, M 100.2814.08−1.560.412.75 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 63040.5415.52−0.450.212.50 ± 0.500.008 ± 0.0050.025 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 6341, M 920.0214.65−2.310.413.50 ± 0.750.022 ± 0.0040.039 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63520.2214.43−0.640.212.75 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0140.027 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63620.0914.68−1.000.412.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0110.004 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 63660.7114.94−0.590.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0100.011 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 63970.1812.37−2.000.413.00 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0090.008 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 64410.4716.78−0.460.212.25 ± 0.750.029 ± 0.0060.081 ± 0.022M3-like
NGC 64960.1515.74−0.460.212.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.021 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 65350.3415.34−1.790.413.25 ± 0.500.003 ± 0.0210.003 ± 0.022M13-like
NGC 65410.1414.82−1.810.413.00 ± 0.500.024 ± 0.0050.045 ± 0.006M13-like
NGC 65840.1015.96−1.500.412.25 ± 0.750.000 ± 0.0070.015 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 66240.2815.36−0.440.212.50 ± 0.500.010 ± 0.0040.022 ± 0.003M3-like
NGC 66370.1815.28−0.640.212.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0060.011 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 66520.0915.28−0.810.413.25 ± 0.250.008 ± 0.0070.017 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 6681, M 700.0714.99−1.620.413.25 ± 0.750.009 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6717, Pal 90.2214.94−1.280.413.00 ± 0.250.003 ± 0.0060.003 ± 0.009M13-like
NGC 67230.0514.84−1.100.413.00 ± 0.750.005 ± 0.0060.024 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 67520.0413.13−1.540.413.00 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0050.042 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6779, M 560.2615.68−1.990.413.50 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0070.031 ± 0.008M13-like
NGC 6809, M 550.0813.89−1.940.413.25 ± 0.500.014 ± 0.0080.026 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6838, M 710.2513.80−0.780.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0090.024 ± 0.010M3-like
NGC 6981, M 720.0516.31−1.420.412.25 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0060.017 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7078, M 150.1015.39−2.370.413.00 ± 0.750.021 ± 0.0090.069 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7099, M 300.0314.64−2.270.413.50 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.022 ± 0.010M13-like
Cluster namesE(BV) (mag)|$(m-M)_V \,\mathrm{ (mag)}$|[Fe/H]|$\rm [\alpha /Fe]$|Age (Gyr)|$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{2G,1G}$||$\rm \delta \mathit{ Y}_{max}$|Group
NGC 0104, 47 Tuc0.0413.37−0.720.413.00 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0050.049 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 02880.0314.84−1.320.412.75 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.016 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 22980.1415.60−1.920.413.25 ± 0.50−0.003 ± 0.0080.011 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 28080.2215.59−1.140.412.00 ± 0.750.048 ± 0.0050.124 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 32010.2414.20−1.590.412.00 ± 0.50−0.001 ± 0.0130.028 ± 0.032M3-like
NGC 4590, M 680.0515.21−2.230.412.75 ± 0.750.007 ± 0.0090.012 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 48330.3215.08−1.850.413.25 ± 0.500.016 ± 0.0080.051 ± 0.009M3-like
NGC 5024, M 530.0216.32−2.100.413.25 ± 0.750.013 ± 0.0070.044 ± 0.008M3-like
NGC 50530.0116.23−2.270.413.00 ± 0.50−0.002 ± 0.0130.004 ± 0.025M3-like
NGC 54660.0016.02−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.002 ± 0.0130.007 ± 0.024M3-like
NGC 5904, M 50.0314.46−1.290.412.25 ± 0.750.012 ± 0.0040.037 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 59270.4515.82−0.490.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0040.055 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 59860.2815.96−1.590.413.25 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0060.031 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 6093, M 800.1815.56−1.750.413.50 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0080.027 ± 0.012M13-like
NGC 61010.0516.10−1.980.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0100.017 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 61440.3615.86−1.760.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.017 ± 0.013M13-like
NGC 6171, M 1070.3315.05−1.000.412.50 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0110.024 ± 0.014M3-like
NGC 6205, M 130.0214.33−1.520.412.25 ± 0.750.020 ± 0.0040.052 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6218, M 120.1914.01−1.370.413.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0070.011 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 6254, M 100.2814.08−1.560.412.75 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 63040.5415.52−0.450.212.50 ± 0.500.008 ± 0.0050.025 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 6341, M 920.0214.65−2.310.413.50 ± 0.750.022 ± 0.0040.039 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63520.2214.43−0.640.212.75 ± 0.250.019 ± 0.0140.027 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 63620.0914.68−1.000.412.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0110.004 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 63660.7114.94−0.590.212.25 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0100.011 ± 0.015M3-like
NGC 63970.1812.37−2.000.413.00 ± 0.500.006 ± 0.0090.008 ± 0.011M13-like
NGC 64410.4716.78−0.460.212.25 ± 0.750.029 ± 0.0060.081 ± 0.022M3-like
NGC 64960.1515.74−0.460.212.00 ± 0.500.009 ± 0.0110.021 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 65350.3415.34−1.790.413.25 ± 0.500.003 ± 0.0210.003 ± 0.022M13-like
NGC 65410.1414.82−1.810.413.00 ± 0.500.024 ± 0.0050.045 ± 0.006M13-like
NGC 65840.1015.96−1.500.412.25 ± 0.750.000 ± 0.0070.015 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 66240.2815.36−0.440.212.50 ± 0.500.010 ± 0.0040.022 ± 0.003M3-like
NGC 66370.1815.28−0.640.212.25 ± 0.500.004 ± 0.0060.011 ± 0.005M3-like
NGC 66520.0915.28−0.810.413.25 ± 0.250.008 ± 0.0070.017 ± 0.011M3-like
NGC 6681, M 700.0714.99−1.620.413.25 ± 0.750.009 ± 0.0080.029 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6717, Pal 90.2214.94−1.280.413.00 ± 0.250.003 ± 0.0060.003 ± 0.009M13-like
NGC 67230.0514.84−1.100.413.00 ± 0.750.005 ± 0.0060.024 ± 0.007M3-like
NGC 67520.0413.13−1.540.413.00 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0050.042 ± 0.004M13-like
NGC 6779, M 560.2615.68−1.990.413.50 ± 0.500.011 ± 0.0070.031 ± 0.008M13-like
NGC 6809, M 550.0813.89−1.940.413.25 ± 0.500.014 ± 0.0080.026 ± 0.015M13-like
NGC 6838, M 710.2513.80−0.780.412.75 ± 0.500.005 ± 0.0090.024 ± 0.010M3-like
NGC 6981, M 720.0516.31−1.420.412.25 ± 0.750.011 ± 0.0060.017 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7078, M 150.1015.39−2.370.413.00 ± 0.750.021 ± 0.0090.069 ± 0.006M3-like
NGC 7099, M 300.0314.64−2.270.413.50 ± 0.500.015 ± 0.0100.022 ± 0.010M13-like
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close