Table 1.

HI Antibody Responses Against Influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 Viruses in Adults After Vaccination

SeasonVaccinees, No.VirusHA
Group
Amino Acid GMTHI Titer ≥40, %Seroconversion, %aLRs, No. (%)b
163223PrePost (Range)PrePost
2010–201150X-179ANAKR17394 (40–1280)3610090NA
RG-K163NAKQ17260c (20–1280)4098867 (14)
RG-K163QNAQQ13143c,d (5–1280)24868018 (36)d
MI/15e6B.1QR12229c (5–1280)2294829 (18)
MI/15c6B.1QQ11125c,e (5–1280)20848220 (40)e
IW/15e6B.2QR11181c (5–1280)14928810 (20)
IW/15c6B.2QQ10112c,e (5–1280)12808419 (38)
2011–201254X-179ANAKR27281 (40–1280)4610072NA
RG-K163NAKQ20156c (40–640)35100699 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ16106c,d (5–640)31876919 (35)d
MI/15e6B.1QR21207c (5–1280)3598727 (13)
MI/15c6B.1QQ22166c (5–1280)35896915 (28)
IW/15e6B.2QR19139c (5–1280)3794728 (15)
IW/15c6B.2QQ19110c (5–640)33807220 (37)e
2013–201442X-179ANAKR17242 (40–1280)2910083NA
RG-K163NAKQ16189c (20–1280)3198797 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ12108c,d (10–640)21867412 (29)
MI/15e6B.1QR20242 (10–1280)4398764 (10)
MI/15c6B.1QQ14119c,e (5–1280)24836912 (29)e
IW/15e6B.2QR13125c (5–640)2490745 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ1172c,e (5–640)17766217 (40)e
2014–201561X-179ANAKR30286 (40–1280)4910077NA
RG-K163NAKQ30220c (5–1280)5798744 (7)
RG-K163QNAQQ25164c,d (5–1280)4993709 (15)
MI/15e6B.1QR31264 (10–1280)5198752 (3)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24188c,e (5–1280)46927410 (16)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20173c (5–1280)3995724 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20140c (5–1280)41896716 (25)e
2015–201660X-179ANAKR50214 (40–1280)6810042NA
RG-K163NAKQ53188c (40–1280)72100401 (2)
RG-K163QNAQQ46156c,d (5–1280)7097382 (3)
MI/15e6B.1QR55221 (10–1280)6898431 (2)
MI/15c6B.1QQ50192 (5–1280)6897422 (3)
IW/15e6B.2QR33117c (5–1280)6098384 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ34117c (5–1280)5797409 (15)
2016–201733X-179ANAKR77244 (40–1280)8510030NA
RG-K163NAKQ58224 (40–1280)73100360
RG-K163QNAQQ46144c,d (5–1280)7097334 (12)
MI/15e6B.1QR56181c (5–1280)7697394 (12)
MI/15c6B.1QQ43138c,e (5–1280)6482366 (18)
IW/15e6B.2QR48160c (5–1280)7394334 (13)
IW/15c6B.2QQ47160c (5–1280)6797365 (15)
Total300X-179ANAKR30272 (40–1280)5110067NA
RG-K163NAKQ28202c (5–1280)51996428 (9)
RG-K163QNAQQ23136c,d (5–1280)44916264 (21)d
MI/15e6B.1QR28226c (5–1280)48986627 (9)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24156c,e (5–1280)43896365 (22)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20147c (5–1280)40946435 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20115c,e (5–1280)37876176 (25%)e
SeasonVaccinees, No.VirusHA
Group
Amino Acid GMTHI Titer ≥40, %Seroconversion, %aLRs, No. (%)b
163223PrePost (Range)PrePost
2010–201150X-179ANAKR17394 (40–1280)3610090NA
RG-K163NAKQ17260c (20–1280)4098867 (14)
RG-K163QNAQQ13143c,d (5–1280)24868018 (36)d
MI/15e6B.1QR12229c (5–1280)2294829 (18)
MI/15c6B.1QQ11125c,e (5–1280)20848220 (40)e
IW/15e6B.2QR11181c (5–1280)14928810 (20)
IW/15c6B.2QQ10112c,e (5–1280)12808419 (38)
2011–201254X-179ANAKR27281 (40–1280)4610072NA
RG-K163NAKQ20156c (40–640)35100699 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ16106c,d (5–640)31876919 (35)d
MI/15e6B.1QR21207c (5–1280)3598727 (13)
MI/15c6B.1QQ22166c (5–1280)35896915 (28)
IW/15e6B.2QR19139c (5–1280)3794728 (15)
IW/15c6B.2QQ19110c (5–640)33807220 (37)e
2013–201442X-179ANAKR17242 (40–1280)2910083NA
RG-K163NAKQ16189c (20–1280)3198797 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ12108c,d (10–640)21867412 (29)
MI/15e6B.1QR20242 (10–1280)4398764 (10)
MI/15c6B.1QQ14119c,e (5–1280)24836912 (29)e
IW/15e6B.2QR13125c (5–640)2490745 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ1172c,e (5–640)17766217 (40)e
2014–201561X-179ANAKR30286 (40–1280)4910077NA
RG-K163NAKQ30220c (5–1280)5798744 (7)
RG-K163QNAQQ25164c,d (5–1280)4993709 (15)
MI/15e6B.1QR31264 (10–1280)5198752 (3)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24188c,e (5–1280)46927410 (16)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20173c (5–1280)3995724 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20140c (5–1280)41896716 (25)e
2015–201660X-179ANAKR50214 (40–1280)6810042NA
RG-K163NAKQ53188c (40–1280)72100401 (2)
RG-K163QNAQQ46156c,d (5–1280)7097382 (3)
MI/15e6B.1QR55221 (10–1280)6898431 (2)
MI/15c6B.1QQ50192 (5–1280)6897422 (3)
IW/15e6B.2QR33117c (5–1280)6098384 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ34117c (5–1280)5797409 (15)
2016–201733X-179ANAKR77244 (40–1280)8510030NA
RG-K163NAKQ58224 (40–1280)73100360
RG-K163QNAQQ46144c,d (5–1280)7097334 (12)
MI/15e6B.1QR56181c (5–1280)7697394 (12)
MI/15c6B.1QQ43138c,e (5–1280)6482366 (18)
IW/15e6B.2QR48160c (5–1280)7394334 (13)
IW/15c6B.2QQ47160c (5–1280)6797365 (15)
Total300X-179ANAKR30272 (40–1280)5110067NA
RG-K163NAKQ28202c (5–1280)51996428 (9)
RG-K163QNAQQ23136c,d (5–1280)44916264 (21)d
MI/15e6B.1QR28226c (5–1280)48986627 (9)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24156c,e (5–1280)43896365 (22)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20147c (5–1280)40946435 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20115c,e (5–1280)37876176 (25%)e

Abbreviations: GMTs, geometric mean titers; HA, hemagglutinin; HI, hemagglutination inhibition; IW/15, A/Iowa/53/2015 field strain grown in egg (IW/15e) or Madin-Darby canine kidney cells (IW/15c); LRs, low responders; MI/15, A/Michigan/45/2015 field strain grown in egg (MI/15e) or Madin-Darby canine kidney cells (MI/15c); NA, not applicable; Post, postvaccination; Pre, prevaccination; RG-K163, A/California/8/2009-PR8 egg-grown virus possessing HA-K163; RG-K163Q, RG-CA egg-grown virus engineered to possess HA-K163Q mutation; X-179A, A/California/7/2009-PR8 egg-grown vaccine virus. Response to vaccine virus X-179A are in bold.

aPercentage of seroconversion, defined as ≥4-fold increase from prevaccination to postvaccination titers, where the postvaccination titer is ≥40.

bLow responders defined as those with ≥4-fold reduced postvaccination HI antibody titers to the corresponding virus compared with X-179A.

cP < .05 for RG-CA viruses and 2015 field strains vs X-179A vaccine strain.

dP < .05 for RG-K163Q vs RG-K163 virus.

eP < .05 for MI/15 and IW/15 cell-grown viruses vs their paired egg-grown viruses with an egg-adapted mutation (Q223R).

Table 1.

HI Antibody Responses Against Influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 Viruses in Adults After Vaccination

SeasonVaccinees, No.VirusHA
Group
Amino Acid GMTHI Titer ≥40, %Seroconversion, %aLRs, No. (%)b
163223PrePost (Range)PrePost
2010–201150X-179ANAKR17394 (40–1280)3610090NA
RG-K163NAKQ17260c (20–1280)4098867 (14)
RG-K163QNAQQ13143c,d (5–1280)24868018 (36)d
MI/15e6B.1QR12229c (5–1280)2294829 (18)
MI/15c6B.1QQ11125c,e (5–1280)20848220 (40)e
IW/15e6B.2QR11181c (5–1280)14928810 (20)
IW/15c6B.2QQ10112c,e (5–1280)12808419 (38)
2011–201254X-179ANAKR27281 (40–1280)4610072NA
RG-K163NAKQ20156c (40–640)35100699 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ16106c,d (5–640)31876919 (35)d
MI/15e6B.1QR21207c (5–1280)3598727 (13)
MI/15c6B.1QQ22166c (5–1280)35896915 (28)
IW/15e6B.2QR19139c (5–1280)3794728 (15)
IW/15c6B.2QQ19110c (5–640)33807220 (37)e
2013–201442X-179ANAKR17242 (40–1280)2910083NA
RG-K163NAKQ16189c (20–1280)3198797 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ12108c,d (10–640)21867412 (29)
MI/15e6B.1QR20242 (10–1280)4398764 (10)
MI/15c6B.1QQ14119c,e (5–1280)24836912 (29)e
IW/15e6B.2QR13125c (5–640)2490745 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ1172c,e (5–640)17766217 (40)e
2014–201561X-179ANAKR30286 (40–1280)4910077NA
RG-K163NAKQ30220c (5–1280)5798744 (7)
RG-K163QNAQQ25164c,d (5–1280)4993709 (15)
MI/15e6B.1QR31264 (10–1280)5198752 (3)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24188c,e (5–1280)46927410 (16)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20173c (5–1280)3995724 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20140c (5–1280)41896716 (25)e
2015–201660X-179ANAKR50214 (40–1280)6810042NA
RG-K163NAKQ53188c (40–1280)72100401 (2)
RG-K163QNAQQ46156c,d (5–1280)7097382 (3)
MI/15e6B.1QR55221 (10–1280)6898431 (2)
MI/15c6B.1QQ50192 (5–1280)6897422 (3)
IW/15e6B.2QR33117c (5–1280)6098384 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ34117c (5–1280)5797409 (15)
2016–201733X-179ANAKR77244 (40–1280)8510030NA
RG-K163NAKQ58224 (40–1280)73100360
RG-K163QNAQQ46144c,d (5–1280)7097334 (12)
MI/15e6B.1QR56181c (5–1280)7697394 (12)
MI/15c6B.1QQ43138c,e (5–1280)6482366 (18)
IW/15e6B.2QR48160c (5–1280)7394334 (13)
IW/15c6B.2QQ47160c (5–1280)6797365 (15)
Total300X-179ANAKR30272 (40–1280)5110067NA
RG-K163NAKQ28202c (5–1280)51996428 (9)
RG-K163QNAQQ23136c,d (5–1280)44916264 (21)d
MI/15e6B.1QR28226c (5–1280)48986627 (9)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24156c,e (5–1280)43896365 (22)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20147c (5–1280)40946435 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20115c,e (5–1280)37876176 (25%)e
SeasonVaccinees, No.VirusHA
Group
Amino Acid GMTHI Titer ≥40, %Seroconversion, %aLRs, No. (%)b
163223PrePost (Range)PrePost
2010–201150X-179ANAKR17394 (40–1280)3610090NA
RG-K163NAKQ17260c (20–1280)4098867 (14)
RG-K163QNAQQ13143c,d (5–1280)24868018 (36)d
MI/15e6B.1QR12229c (5–1280)2294829 (18)
MI/15c6B.1QQ11125c,e (5–1280)20848220 (40)e
IW/15e6B.2QR11181c (5–1280)14928810 (20)
IW/15c6B.2QQ10112c,e (5–1280)12808419 (38)
2011–201254X-179ANAKR27281 (40–1280)4610072NA
RG-K163NAKQ20156c (40–640)35100699 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ16106c,d (5–640)31876919 (35)d
MI/15e6B.1QR21207c (5–1280)3598727 (13)
MI/15c6B.1QQ22166c (5–1280)35896915 (28)
IW/15e6B.2QR19139c (5–1280)3794728 (15)
IW/15c6B.2QQ19110c (5–640)33807220 (37)e
2013–201442X-179ANAKR17242 (40–1280)2910083NA
RG-K163NAKQ16189c (20–1280)3198797 (17)
RG-K163QNAQQ12108c,d (10–640)21867412 (29)
MI/15e6B.1QR20242 (10–1280)4398764 (10)
MI/15c6B.1QQ14119c,e (5–1280)24836912 (29)e
IW/15e6B.2QR13125c (5–640)2490745 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ1172c,e (5–640)17766217 (40)e
2014–201561X-179ANAKR30286 (40–1280)4910077NA
RG-K163NAKQ30220c (5–1280)5798744 (7)
RG-K163QNAQQ25164c,d (5–1280)4993709 (15)
MI/15e6B.1QR31264 (10–1280)5198752 (3)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24188c,e (5–1280)46927410 (16)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20173c (5–1280)3995724 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20140c (5–1280)41896716 (25)e
2015–201660X-179ANAKR50214 (40–1280)6810042NA
RG-K163NAKQ53188c (40–1280)72100401 (2)
RG-K163QNAQQ46156c,d (5–1280)7097382 (3)
MI/15e6B.1QR55221 (10–1280)6898431 (2)
MI/15c6B.1QQ50192 (5–1280)6897422 (3)
IW/15e6B.2QR33117c (5–1280)6098384 (7)
IW/15c6B.2QQ34117c (5–1280)5797409 (15)
2016–201733X-179ANAKR77244 (40–1280)8510030NA
RG-K163NAKQ58224 (40–1280)73100360
RG-K163QNAQQ46144c,d (5–1280)7097334 (12)
MI/15e6B.1QR56181c (5–1280)7697394 (12)
MI/15c6B.1QQ43138c,e (5–1280)6482366 (18)
IW/15e6B.2QR48160c (5–1280)7394334 (13)
IW/15c6B.2QQ47160c (5–1280)6797365 (15)
Total300X-179ANAKR30272 (40–1280)5110067NA
RG-K163NAKQ28202c (5–1280)51996428 (9)
RG-K163QNAQQ23136c,d (5–1280)44916264 (21)d
MI/15e6B.1QR28226c (5–1280)48986627 (9)
MI/15c6B.1QQ24156c,e (5–1280)43896365 (22)e
IW/15e6B.2QR20147c (5–1280)40946435 (12)
IW/15c6B.2QQ20115c,e (5–1280)37876176 (25%)e

Abbreviations: GMTs, geometric mean titers; HA, hemagglutinin; HI, hemagglutination inhibition; IW/15, A/Iowa/53/2015 field strain grown in egg (IW/15e) or Madin-Darby canine kidney cells (IW/15c); LRs, low responders; MI/15, A/Michigan/45/2015 field strain grown in egg (MI/15e) or Madin-Darby canine kidney cells (MI/15c); NA, not applicable; Post, postvaccination; Pre, prevaccination; RG-K163, A/California/8/2009-PR8 egg-grown virus possessing HA-K163; RG-K163Q, RG-CA egg-grown virus engineered to possess HA-K163Q mutation; X-179A, A/California/7/2009-PR8 egg-grown vaccine virus. Response to vaccine virus X-179A are in bold.

aPercentage of seroconversion, defined as ≥4-fold increase from prevaccination to postvaccination titers, where the postvaccination titer is ≥40.

bLow responders defined as those with ≥4-fold reduced postvaccination HI antibody titers to the corresponding virus compared with X-179A.

cP < .05 for RG-CA viruses and 2015 field strains vs X-179A vaccine strain.

dP < .05 for RG-K163Q vs RG-K163 virus.

eP < .05 for MI/15 and IW/15 cell-grown viruses vs their paired egg-grown viruses with an egg-adapted mutation (Q223R).

Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close