..., then, all else being equal, the normativity objection developed in Section  II loses its force as an argument against logical pluralism (see also Blake-Turner & Russell 2018 ). I argue that this is not enough. Even if logic is not normative in the way Beall and Restall and others—pluralists...

...This chapter discusses fundamental problems and prospects for ethical naturalism. Section 1 explains what is meant by “ethical naturalism” and surveys different versions of the view. Section 2 discusses the central philosophical challenge to ethical naturalism, viz., the “Normativity Objection...

..., but is the most vulnerable to the normativity objection. naturalism normativity objection fact identity of normativity motivational internalism Eklund Matti reason reasons fundamentalism belief concept essence morality Hubin Donald Parfit Derek Tiffany Evan error theory Berker Selim King Jeff...

... this characterization of robust normativity is vague, but it is only intended to point us toward the issue. Ethical antirealists have argued that ethical realism cannot explain or account for the robust normativity of ethics. ² This is the normativity objection. If it is correct...

...This chapter considers arguments for and against normative naturalism. According to the normativity objection, irreducibly normative, reason-implying claims could not, if they were true, state normative facts that were also natural facts. When some naturalists reply to the normativity objection...