Abstract

In this article I provide an account of the elimination of Women's Equality as a freestanding ministry in the government of the Canadian province of British Columbia and its reconfiguration as Women's Services and Social Programs, one of several organizational elements in the newly-created Ministry of Community, Aboriginal and Women's Services. I also present an analysis of a number of policy developments with particular significance for women that have accompanied this institutional transformation. In my discussion I argue that while many of these policy directions date from the arrival in office of the current provincial Liberal government, others did not emerge de novo after the 2001 election. Rather, they originated while the left-of-centre New Democratic Party (NDP) formed the government provincially during the 1990s. I assess the relative contributions of ideology and institutional structure to the policy changes that are detailed in the article, and conclude that the relationships between ideology, institutions and policy can best be understood as complex and recursive.

References

BC CEDAW Group
.
2003
.
British Columbia Moves Backwards on Women's Equality
. Available at www.fafia.org/Bplus5/bcCEDAWreport012103.pdf.

B.C.
 
Liberals
. A New Era for British Columbia.
2001
;
BC Liberal Party
:
Vancouver

J.
 
Brodie
. Politics on the Margins: Restructuring and the Canadian Women's Movement.
1995
;
Fernwood
:
Halifax

J.
 
Brodie
. The Great Undoing: State Formation, Gender Politics, and Social Policy in Canada.
C.
 
Kingfisher
.
Western Welfare in Decline: Globalization and Women's Poverty
.
2002
;
University of Pennsylvania Press
:
Philadelphia

P.
 
Bunkle
. New Zealand Women 1985-1995: Markets and Inequality: An Assessment of the Impact of Market Policies on the Position of Women.
1995
;
Author
:
Wellington

S.
 
Burt
. The Status of Women: Learning to Live Without the State.
A.
 
Johnson
,
A.
 
Stritch
.
Canadian Public Policy: Globalization and Political Parties
.
1997
;
Copp Clark
:
Toronto

L.
 
Chappell
. Women's Policy.
M.
 
Laffin
,
M.
 
Painter
.
Reform and Reversal: Lessons From the Coalition Government in New South Wales 1995-1988
.
1995
;
Macmillan
:
Melbourne

L.
 
Hancock
.
Women, Public Policy and the State
.
1999
;
Macmillan Education
:
South Yarra

C.
 
Kingfisher
.
Western Welfare in Decline: Globalization and Women's Poverty
.
2002
;
University of Pennsylvania Press
:
Philadelphia

W.
 
Larner
.
The New Boys: Restructuring in New Zealand, 1984-94
.
Social Politics
.
3
(
1
):
1996
;
32
56
.

W.
 
Larner
.
Neo-liberalism: Policy, Ideology, Governmentality
.
Studies in Political Economy
.
63
 
2000
;
5
25
.

M.
 
Lee
.
The Great BC Tax Cut Giveaway
.
BC Commentary
.
4
(
3
):
2001
;
1
2
.

J.
 
Malloy
.
What Makes a State Advocacy Structure Effective? Conflicts Between Bureaucratic and Social Movement Criteria
.
Governance
.
12
 
1999
;
267
288
.

Ministry of Community, Aboriginal and Women's Services [CAWS], British Columbia
.
2002a
.
2001/02 Annual Report: A New Era Update
.
Victoria
:
The Ministry
.

Ministry of Community, Aboriginal and Women's Services [CAWS] British Columbia
.Service Plan 2002/2003-2004/2005.
2002
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Community, Aboriginal and Women's Services [CAWS], British Columbia
.Service Plan 2003/04-2005/06.
2003
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Finance [Finance], British Columbia
.Estimates: Fiscal Year Ending March 31, 2002.
2001
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.Strategic Plan 1994/95.
1994
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.Business Plan 1995/96.
1995
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.Business Plan 97/98.
1997
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.
1988a
.
Annual Report 96/97 97/98
. Victoria: The Ministry.

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.Business Plan 98/99.
1998
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.
1999
.
Annual Report 98/99
. Victoria: The Ministry.

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.
2001
.
Annual Performance Report 2000-2001
. Victoria: The Ministry.

Ministry of Women's Equality [MWE], British Columbia
.A Decade of Accomplishments 1991-2001.
2001
;
The Ministry
:
Victoria

Office of the Auditor General [Auditor General], British Columbia
.
2000
.
Report on the Implementation of the Recommendations of the Budget Process Review Panel
. Victoria: Office of the Auditor General.

N.
 
Rose
. Governing “Advanced” Liberal Democracies.
A.
 
Barry
,
T.
 
Osborne
,
N.
 
Rose
.
Foucault and Political Reason: Liberalism, Neo-liberalism and Rationalities of Government
.
1996
;
University of Chicago Press
:
Chicago

N.
 
Rose
. Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought.
1999
;
Cambridge University Press
:
Cambridge

M.
 
Sawer
. Femocrats and Ecorats: Women's Policy Machinery in Australia, Canada and New Zealand.
1996
;
United Nations Research Institute for Social Development
:
Geneva

M.
 
Sawer
. The Watchers Within: Women the Australian State.
L.
 
Hancock
.
Women Public Policy, the State
.
1999
;
Macmillan Education
:
South Yarra

D.
 
Stetson
. The Oldest Women's Policy Agency: The Women's Bureau in the United States.
D.
 
Stetson
,
A.
 
Mazur
.
Comparative State Feminism
.
1995
;
Sage Publications
:
Thousand Oaks, CA

D.
 
Stetson
,
A.
 
Mazur
.
Comparative State Feminism
.
1995
;
Sage Publications
:
Thousand Oaks, CA

K.
 
Teghtsoonian
.
Gendering Policy Analysis in the Government of British Columbia: Strategies, Possibilities and Constraints
.
Studies in Political Economy
.
61
 
2000
;
105
127
.

J.
 
True
,
M.
 
Mintrom
.
Transnational Networks and Policy Diffusion: The Case of Gender Mainstreaming
.
International Studies Quarterly
.
45
 
2001
;
27
57
.

This content is only available as a PDF.
This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (https://dbpia.nl.go.kr/journals/pages/open_access/funder_policies/chorus/standard_publication_model)