Skip to Main Content

Capacity, Participation and Values in Comparative Legal Perspective

Online ISBN:
9781529224481
Print ISBN:
9781529224450
Publisher:
Policy Press
Book

Capacity, Participation and Values in Comparative Legal Perspective

Camillia Kong (ed.),
Camillia Kong
(ed.)
Birkbeck College
Find on
John Coggon (ed.),
John Coggon
(ed.)
University of Bristol
Find on
Penny Cooper (ed.),
Penny Cooper
(ed.)
Birkbeck College
Find on
Michael Dunn (ed.),
Michael Dunn
(ed.)
University of Oxford
Find on
Alex Ruck Keene (ed.)
Alex Ruck Keene
(ed.)
King's College London
Find on
Published online:
18 January 2024
Published in print:
31 May 2023
Online ISBN:
9781529224481
Print ISBN:
9781529224450
Publisher:
Policy Press

Abstract

The equality and rights of persons with mental impairments have become an important focal point of reference for policy developments and legal reform. In the 21st century, the normative shifts in law and policy are often said to be driven by the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. However, comparative analyses of the different legal approaches to mental capacity law reveal a far more complex picture of historical, sociocultural and political influences. Such influences substantively impact the shape and constitutive values of even superficially similar legal frameworks, as well as their practical instantiation in terms of whether persons with impairments may be empowered and encouraged to participate in decision making that affects their lives. This book takes an international comparative perspective to probe different legal approaches to mental capacity or guardianship, drawing insights from common law, civil law and hybrid law systems. It provides insights into the commonalities and divergences in normative orientation and practical application within different legal frameworks, probing the values that are embedded within different legal systems, as well as their imperfect realisation in practice. These cross-jurisdictional comparisons will be vital to emphasise the contextual framing of mental capacity law. This contextual framing will help bring to light a shared language about capacity law, such that constructive dialogue and learning across different legal approaches might advance our understanding of this area of law and foster respect for persons with mental impairments.

Contents
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close