Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) are the most common fatal non-communicable diseases globally, responsible for an estimated 18.6 million deaths in 2019.1 Despite the decline in its incidence and mortality rates in several countries and despite the current pandemic situation, CVD remains the major cause of morbidity and mortality in Europe.2 Therefore, risk stratification of future CVD is highly relevant for public health as well as in daily clinical routine.

Various risk prediction algorithms including the currently recommended SCORE23 model offer guidance for cardiovascular risk prediction. These are solely based on classical risk factors, including age, arterial hypertension, lipid concentrations, and smoking. However, these conventional factors were found to explain only approximately 65% of incident CVD events (Figure 1).4

Overview of the ‘Population Risk Prediction’ project. Boxes show the project hypothesis, resources and methods, and aims to tackle cardiovascular disease burden. CVD, cardiovascular disease; GCVRC,Global Cardiovascular Risk Consortium; NT-proBNP, B-type natriuretic peptide.
Figure 1

Overview of the ‘Population Risk Prediction’ project. Boxes show the project hypothesis, resources and methods, and aims to tackle cardiovascular disease burden. CVD, cardiovascular disease; GCVRC,Global Cardiovascular Risk Consortium; NT-proBNP, B-type natriuretic peptide.

The inclusion of objectively quantifiable circulating biomolecules to existing prediction models might offer an additional tool to dissect individuals at risk for incident CVD beyond classical risk factors.

Out of 30 biomarkers assessed in a previous study, three have shown to add significant information on risk prediction.5 Next to the inflammatory biomarker high-sensitive C-reactive protein, cardiac-specific circulating biomarkers like B-type natriuretic peptides (e.g. NT-proBNP) and troponin assessed by highly sensitive methods are able to quantify silent myocardial injury and are strongly associated with incident CVD in apparently healthy individuals. Despite persuasive evidence that inclusion of high-sensitivity cardiac troponin and/or NT-proBNP might add predictive accuracy6 it still remains unclear, whether a clinical routine screening application of biomarkers in a general population might improve cardiovascular prevention.

Several aspects need to be clarified:

  1. To identify whether single or combined biomarkers add predictive information in the general population.

  2. To apply a new biomarker enriched SCORE2 prediction algorithm to European and Global population-based cohorts. Building up on existing gold standard measurements in already harmonized cohort data, the results will unravel the incremental predictive value of the cardiac biomarkers on a European and global level, and establish the enriched SCORE2 biomarker risk prediction model for short, intermediate, and long-term risk assessment.

  3. To apply a prospective clinical trial protocol to personalize cardiac prevention treatment based on the individualized biomarker-enriched SCORE2 risk assessment.

In summary, an improved cardiovascular risk prediction on national, European and global level strengthened by biomarker inclusion and long-term data constitutes an unmet clinical need. Findings should enable the medical community to tailor personalized preventive action and significantly improve the CVD burden in the general population.

Acknowledgements

N.L.M. is supported by a Research Excellence Award (RE/18/5/34216) and a Chair Award (CH/F/21/90010) from the British Heart Foundation.

Conflict of interest: SB reports institution funding from Bayer, Siemens, Novartis and the City of Hamburg. SB is listed as co-inventor of an international patent on the use of a computing device to estimate the probability of myocardial infarction (International Publication Number WO2022043229A1) filed by the University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany and Cardio Care AG, Davos, Switzerland, and as co-inventor and co-applicant of a Taiwanese patent on the use of a computing device to estimate the probability of myocardial infarction (Taiwanese Publication Number 202219980).

Other members of the Study Group on Biomarkers of the ESC Association for Acute Cardiovascular Care include:

Evangelos Giannitsis, MD1, Allan S. Jaffe, MD2, Kurt Huber, MD3, Johannes Mair, MD4, Louise Cullen, MD, PhD5, Ola Hammarsten, MD, PhD6, Martin Möckel, MD7, Konstantin Krychtiuk, MD8, Kristian Thygesen, MD9

1Department of Cardiology, University Heidelberg, Germany

2Mayo Clinic and Medical School, Rochester, Minnesota, USA

3Department of Medicine, Cardiology and Intensive Care Medicine, Wilhelminenhospital, and Sigmund Freud University, Medical School, Vienna, Austria

4Department of Internal Medicine III – Cardiology and Angiology, Medical University Innsbruck, Austria

5Emergency and Trauma Centre, Royal Brisbane and Women`s Hospital, University of Queensland, Australia

6Department of Clinical Chemistry and Transfusion Medicine, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden

7Division of Emergency Medicine, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Germany

8Department of Internal Medicine II, Division of Cardiology, Medical University of Vienna, Austria

9Department of Cardiology, Aarhus University Hospital, Denmark

References

1

Roth
GA
,
Mensah
GA
,
Johnson
CO
,
Addolorato
G
,
Ammirati
E
,
Baddour
LM
,
Barengo
NC
,
Beaton
AZ
,
Benjamin
EJ
,
Benziger
CP
,
Bonny
A
,
Brauer
M
,
Brodmann
M
,
Cahill
TJ
,
Carapetis
J
,
Catapano
AL
,
Chugh
SS
,
Cooper
LT
,
Coresh
J
,
Criqui
M
,
DeCleene
N
,
Eagle
KA
,
Emmons-Bell
S
,
Feigin
VL
,
Fernández-Solà
J
,
Fowkes
G
,
Gakidou
E
,
Grundy
SM
,
He
FJ
,
Howard
G
,
Hu
F
,
Inker
L
,
Karthikeyan
G
,
Kassebaum
N
,
Koroshetz
W
,
Lavie
C
,
Lloyd-Jones
D
,
Lu
HS
,
Mirijello
A
,
Temesgen
AM
,
Mokdad
A
,
Moran
AE
,
Muntner
P
,
Narula
J
,
Neal
B
,
Ntsekhe
M
,
Moraes de Oliveira
G
,
Otto
C
,
Owolabi
M
,
Pratt
M
,
Rajagopalan
S
,
Reitsma
M
,
Ribeiro
ALP
,
Rigotti
N
,
Rodgers
A
,
Sable
C
,
Shakil
S
,
Sliwa-Hahnle
K
,
Stark
B
,
Sundström
J
,
Timpel
P
,
Tleyjeh
IM
,
Valgimigli
M
,
Vos
T
,
Whelton
PK
,
Yacoub
M
,
Zuhlke
L
,
Murray
C
,
Fuster
V
,
Roth
GA
,
Mensah
GA
,
Johnson
CO
,
Addolorato
G
,
Ammirati
E
,
Baddour
LM
,
Barengo
NC
,
Beaton
A
,
Benjamin
EJ
,
Benziger
CP
,
Bonny
A
,
Brauer
M
,
Brodmann
M
,
Cahill
TJ
,
Carapetis
JR
,
Catapano
AL
,
Chugh
S
,
Cooper
LT
,
Coresh
J
,
Criqui
MH
,
DeCleene
NK
,
Eagle
KA
,
Emmons-Bell
S
,
Feigin
VL
,
Fernández-Sola
J
,
Fowkes
FGR
,
Gakidou
E
,
Grundy
SM
,
He
FJ
,
Howard
G
,
Hu
F
,
Inker
L
,
Karthikeyan
G
,
Kassebaum
NJ
,
Koroshetz
WJ
,
Lavie
C
,
Lloyd-Jones
D
,
Lu
HS
,
Mirijello
A
,
Misganaw
AT
,
Mokdad
AH
,
Moran
AE
,
Muntner
P
,
Narula
J
,
Neal
B
,
Ntsekhe
M
,
Oliveira
GMM
,
Otto
CM
,
Owolabi
MO
,
Pratt
M
,
Rajagopalan
S
,
Reitsma
MB
,
Ribeiro
ALP
,
Rigotti
NA
,
Rodgers
A
,
Sable
CA
,
Shakil
SS
,
Sliwa
K
,
Stark
BA
,
Sundström
J
,
Timpel
P
,
Tleyjeh
II
,
Valgimigli
M
,
Vos
T
,
Whelton
PK
,
Yacoub
M
,
Zuhlke
LJ
,
Abbasi-Kangevari
M
,
Abdi
A
,
Abedi
A
,
Aboyans
V
,
Abrha
WA
,
Abu-Gharbieh
E
,
Abushouk
AI
,
Acharya
D
,
Adair
T
,
Adebayo
OM
,
Ademi
Z
,
Advani
SM
,
Afshari
K
,
Afshin
A
,
Agarwal
G
,
Agasthi
P
,
Ahmad
S
,
Ahmadi
S
,
Ahmed
MB
,
Aji
B
,
Akalu
Y
,
Akande-Sholabi
W
,
Aklilu
A
,
Akunna
CJ
,
Alahdab
F
,
Al-Eyadhy
A
,
Alhabib
KF
,
Alif
SM
,
Alipour
V
,
Aljunid
SM
,
Alla
F
,
Almasi-Hashiani
A
,
Almustanyir
S
,
Al-Raddadi
RM
,
Amegah
AK
,
Amini
S
,
Aminorroaya
A
,
Amu
H
,
Amugsi
DA
,
Ancuceanu
R
,
Anderlini
D
,
Andrei
T
,
Andrei
CL
,
Ansari-Moghaddam
A
,
Anteneh
ZA
,
Antonazzo
IC
,
Antony
B
,
Anwer
R
,
Appiah
LT
,
Arabloo
J
,
Ärnlöv
J
,
Artanti
KD
,
Ataro
Z
,
Ausloos
M
,
Avila-Burgos
L
,
Awan
AT
,
Awoke
MA
,
Ayele
HT
,
Ayza
MA
,
Azari
S
,
B
DB
,
Baheiraei
N
,
Baig
AA
,
Bakhtiari
A
,
Banach
M
,
Banik
PC
,
Baptista
EA
,
Barboza
MA
,
Barua
L
,
Basu
S
,
Bedi
N
,
Béjot
Y
,
Bennett
DA
,
Bensenor
IM
,
Berman
AE
,
Bezabih
YM
,
Bhagavathula
AS
,
Bhaskar
S
,
Bhattacharyya
K
,
Bijani
A
,
Bikbov
B
,
Birhanu
MM
,
Boloor
A
,
Brant
LC
,
Brenner
H
,
Briko
NI
,
Butt
ZA
,
Caetano dos Santos
FL
,
Cahill
LE
,
Cahuana-Hurtado
L
,
Cámera
LA
,
Campos-Nonato
IR
,
Cantu-Brito
C
,
Car
J
,
Carrero
JJ
,
Carvalho
F
,
Castañeda-Orjuela
CA
,
Catalá-López
F
,
Cerin
E
,
Charan
J
,
Chattu
VK
,
Chen
S
,
Chin
KL
,
Choi
J-YJ
,
Chu
D-T
,
Chung
S-C
,
Cirillo
M
,
Coffey
S
,
Conti
S
,
Costa
VM
,
Cundiff
DK
,
Dadras
O
,
Dagnew
B
,
Dai
X
,
Damasceno
AAM
,
Dandona
L
,
Dandona
R
,
Davletov
K
,
De la Cruz-Góngora
V
,
De la Hoz
FP
,
De Neve
J-W
,
Denova-Gutiérrez
E
,
Derbew Molla
M
,
Derseh
BT
,
Desai
R
,
Deuschl
G
,
Dharmaratne
SD
,
Dhimal
M
,
Dhungana
RR
,
Dianatinasab
M
,
Diaz
D
,
Djalalinia
S
,
Dokova
K
,
Douiri
A
,
Duncan
BB
,
Duraes
AR
,
Eagan
AW
,
Ebtehaj
S
,
Eftekhari
A
,
Eftekharzadeh
S
,
Ekholuenetale
M
,
El Nahas
N
,
Elgendy
IY
,
Elhadi
M
,
El-Jaafary
SI
,
Esteghamati
S
,
Etisso
AE
,
Eyawo
O
,
Fadhil
I
,
Faraon
EJA
,
Faris
PS
,
Farwati
M
,
Farzadfar
F
,
Fernandes
E
,
Fernandez Prendes
C
,
Ferrara
P
,
Filip
I
,
Fischer
F
,
Flood
D
,
Fukumoto
T
,
Gad
MM
,
Gaidhane
S
,
Ganji
M
,
Garg
J
,
Gebre
AK
,
Gebregiorgis
BG
,
Gebregzabiher
KZ
,
Gebremeskel
GG
,
Getacher
L
,
Obsa
AG
,
Ghajar
A
,
Ghashghaee
A
,
Ghith
N
,
Giampaoli
S
,
Gilani
SA
,
Gill
PS
,
Gillum
RF
,
Glushkova
EV
,
Gnedovskaya
EV
,
Golechha
M
,
Gonfa
KB
,
Goudarzian
AH
,
Goulart
AC
,
Guadamuz
JS
,
Guha
A
,
Guo
Y
,
Gupta
R
,
Hachinski
V
,
Hafezi-Nejad
N
,
Haile
TG
,
Hamadeh
RR
,
Hamidi
S
,
Hankey
GJ
,
Hargono
A
,
Hartono
RK
,
Hashemian
M
,
Hashi
A
,
Hassan
S
,
Hassen
HY
,
Havmoeller
RJ
,
Hay
SI
,
Hayat
K
,
Heidari
G
,
Herteliu
C
,
Holla
R
,
Hosseini
M
,
Hosseinzadeh
M
,
Hostiuc
M
,
Hostiuc
S
,
Househ
M
,
Huang
J
,
Humayun
A
,
Iavicoli
I
,
Ibeneme
CU
,
Ibitoye
SE
,
Ilesanmi
OS
,
Ilic
IM
,
Ilic
MD
,
Iqbal
U
,
Irvani
SSN
,
Islam
SMS
,
Islam
RM
,
Iso
H
,
Iwagami
M
,
Jain
V
,
Javaheri
T
,
Jayapal
SK
,
Jayaram
S
,
Jayawardena
R
,
Jeemon
P
,
Jha
RP
,
Jonas
JB
,
Jonnagaddala
J
,
Joukar
F
,
Jozwiak
JJ
,
Jürisson
M
,
Kabir
A
,
Kahlon
T
,
Kalani
R
,
Kalhor
R
,
Kamath
A
,
Kamel
I
,
Kandel
H
,
Kandel
A
,
Karch
A
,
Kasa
AS
,
Katoto
PDMC
,
Kayode
GA
,
Khader
YS
,
Khammarnia
M
,
Khan
MS
,
Khan
MN
,
Khan
M
,
Khan
EA
,
Khatab
K
,
Kibria
GMA
,
Kim
YJ
,
Kim
GR
,
Kimokoti
RW
,
Kisa
S
,
Kisa
A
,
Kivimäki
M
,
Kolte
D
,
Koolivand
A
,
Korshunov
VA
,
Koulmane Laxminarayana
SL
,
Koyanagi
A
,
Krishan
K
,
Krishnamoorthy
V
,
Kuate Defo
B
,
Kucuk Bicer
B
,
Kulkarni
V
,
Kumar
GA
,
Kumar
N
,
Kurmi
OP
,
Kusuma
D
,
Kwan
GF
,
La Vecchia
C
,
Lacey
B
,
Lallukka
T
,
Lan
Q
,
Lasrado
S
,
Lassi
ZS
,
Lauriola
P
,
Lawrence
WR
,
Laxmaiah
A
,
LeGrand
KE
,
Li
M-C
,
Li
B
,
Li
S
,
Lim
SS
,
Lim
L-L
,
Lin
H
,
Lin
Z
,
Lin
R-T
,
Liu
X
,
Lopez
AD
,
Lorkowski
S
,
Lotufo
PA
,
Lugo
A
,
M
NK
,
Madotto
F
,
Mahmoudi
M
,
Majeed
A
,
Malekzadeh
R
,
Malik
AA
,
Mamun
AA
,
Manafi
N
,
Mansournia
MA
,
Mantovani
LG
,
Martini
S
,
Mathur
MR
,
Mazzaglia
G
,
Mehata
S
,
Mehndiratta
MM
,
Meier
T
,
Menezes
RG
,
Meretoja
A
,
Mestrovic
T
,
Miazgowski
B
,
Miazgowski
T
,
Michalek
IM
,
Miller
TR
,
Mirrakhimov
EM
,
Mirzaei
H
,
Moazen
B
,
Moghadaszadeh
M
,
Mohammad
Y
,
Mohammad
DK
,
Mohammed
S
,
Mohammed
MA
,
Mokhayeri
Y
,
Molokhia
M
,
Montasir
AA
,
Moradi
G
,
Moradzadeh
R
,
Moraga
P
,
Morawska
L
,
Moreno Velásquez
I
,
Morze
J
,
Mubarik
S
,
Muruet
W
,
Musa
KI
,
Nagarajan
AJ
,
Nalini
M
,
Nangia
V
,
Naqvi
AA
,
Narasimha Swamy
S
,
Nascimento
BR
,
Nayak
VC
,
Nazari
J
,
Nazarzadeh
M
,
Negoi
RI
,
Neupane Kandel
S
,
Nguyen
HLT
,
Nixon
MR
,
Norrving
B
,
Noubiap
JJ
,
Nouthe
BE
,
Nowak
C
,
Odukoya
OO
,
Ogbo
FA
,
Olagunju
AT
,
Orru
H
,
Ortiz
A
,
Ostroff
SM
,
Padubidri
JR
,
Palladino
R
,
Pana
A
,
Panda-Jonas
S
,
Parekh
U
,
Park
E-C
,
Parvizi
M
,
Pashazadeh Kan
F
,
Patel
UK
,
Pathak
M
,
Paudel
R
,
Pepito
VCF
,
Perianayagam
A
,
Perico
N
,
Pham
HQ
,
Pilgrim
T
,
Piradov
MA
,
Pishgar
F
,
Podder
V
,
Polibin
RV
,
Pourshams
A
,
Pribadi
DRA
,
Rabiee
N
,
Rabiee
M
,
Radfar
A
,
Rafiei
A
,
Rahim
F
,
Rahimi-Movaghar
V
,
Ur Rahman
MH
,
Rahman
MA
,
Rahmani
AM
,
Rakovac
I
,
Ram
P
,
Ramalingam
S
,
Rana
J
,
Ranasinghe
P
,
Rao
SJ
,
Rathi
P
,
Rawal
L
,
Rawasia
WF
,
Rawassizadeh
R
,
Remuzzi
G
,
Renzaho
AMN
,
Rezapour
A
,
Riahi
SM
,
Roberts-Thomson
RL
,
Roever
L
,
Rohloff
P
,
Romoli
M
,
Roshandel
G
,
Rwegerera
GM
,
Saadatagah
S
,
Saber-Ayad
MM
,
Sabour
S
,
Sacco
S
,
Sadeghi
M
,
Saeedi Moghaddam
S
,
Safari
S
,
Sahebkar
A
,
Salehi
S
,
Salimzadeh
H
,
Samaei
M
,
Samy
AM
,
Santos
IS
,
Santric-Milicevic
MM
,
Sarrafzadegan
N
,
Sarveazad
A
,
Sathish
T
,
Sawhney
M
,
Saylan
M
,
Schmidt
MI
,
Schutte
AE
,
Senthilkumaran
S
,
Sepanlou
SG
,
Sha
F
,
Shahabi
S
,
Shahid
I
,
Shaikh
MA
,
Shamali
M
,
Shamsizadeh
M
,
Shawon
MSR
,
Sheikh
A
,
Shigematsu
M
,
Shin
M-J
,
Shin
JI
,
Shiri
R
,
Shiue
I
,
Shuval
K
,
Siabani
S
,
Siddiqi
TJ
,
Silva
DAS
,
Singh
JA
,
Mtech
AS
,
Skryabin
VY
,
Skryabina
AA
,
Soheili
A
,
Spurlock
EE
,
Stockfelt
L
,
Stortecky
S
,
Stranges
S
,
Suliankatchi Abdulkader
R
,
Tadbiri
H
,
Tadesse
EG
,
Tadesse
DB
,
Tajdini
M
,
Tariqujjaman
M
,
Teklehaimanot
BF
,
Temsah
M-H
,
Tesema
AK
,
Thakur
B
,
Thankappan
KR
,
Thapar
R
,
Thrift
AG
,
Timalsina
B
,
Tonelli
M
,
Touvier
M
,
Tovani-Palone
MR
,
Tripathi
A
,
Tripathy
JP
,
Truelsen
TC
,
Tsegay
GM
,
Tsegaye
GW
,
Tsilimparis
N
,
Tusa
BS
,
Tyrovolas
S
,
Umapathi
KK
,
Unim
B
,
Unnikrishnan
B
,
Usman
MS
,
Vaduganathan
M
,
Valdez
PR
,
Vasankari
TJ
,
Velazquez
DZ
,
Venketasubramanian
N
,
Vu
GT
,
Vujcic
IS
,
Waheed
Y
,
Wang
Y
,
Wang
F
,
Wei
J
,
Weintraub
RG
,
Weldemariam
AH
,
Westerman
R
,
Winkler
AS
,
Wiysonge
CS
,
Wolfe
CDA
,
Wubishet
BL
,
Xu
G
,
Yadollahpour
A
,
Yamagishi
K
,
Yan
LL
,
Yandrapalli
S
,
Yano
Y
,
Yatsuya
H
,
Yeheyis
TY
,
Yeshaw
Y
,
Yilgwan
CS
,
Yonemoto
N
,
Yu
C
,
Yusefzadeh
H
,
Zachariah
G
,
Zaman
SB
,
Zaman
MS
,
Zamanian
M
,
Zand
R
,
Zandifar
A
,
Zarghi
A
,
Zastrozhin
MS
,
Zastrozhina
A
,
Zhang
Z-J
,
Zhang
Y
,
Zhang
W
,
Zhong
C
,
Zou
Z
,
Zuniga
YMH
,
Murray
CJL
,
Fuster
V
.
Global burden of cardiovascular diseases and risk factors, 1990-2013; 2019
.
J Am Coll Cardiol
2020
;
76
:
2982
3021
.

2

Townsend
N
,
Kazakiewicz
D
,
Lucy Wright
F
,
Timmis
A
,
Huculeci
R
,
Torbica
A
,
Gale
CP
,
Achenbach
S
,
Weidinger
F
,
Vardas
P
.
Epidemiology of cardiovascular disease in Europe
.
Nat Rev Cardiol
2022
;
19
:
133
143
.

3

SCORE2, working group and E.C.r. collaboration
.
SCORE2 risk prediction algorithms: new models to estimate 10-year risk of cardiovascular disease in Europe
.
Eur Heart J
2021
.
42
:
2439
2454
.

4

Cheng
S
,
Claggett
B
,
Correia
AW
,
Shah
AM
,
Gupta
DK
,
Skali
H
,
Ni
H
,
Rosamond
WD
,
Heiss
G
,
Folsom
AR
,
Coresh
J
,
Solomon
SD
.
Temporal trends in the population attributable risk for cardiovascular disease: the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study
.
Circulation
2014
;
130
:
820
828
.

5

Blankenberg
S
,
Zeller
T
,
Saarela
O
,
Havulinna
AS
,
Kee
F
,
Tunstall-Pedoe
H
,
Kuulasmaa
K
,
Yarnell
J
,
Schnabel
RB
,
Wild
PS
,
Münzel
TF
,
Lackner
KJ
,
Tiret
L
,
Evans
A
,
Salomaa
V
.
Contribution of 30 biomarkers to 10-year cardiovascular risk estimation in 2 population cohorts: the MONICA, risk, genetics, archiving, and monograph (MORGAM) biomarker project
.
Circulation
2010
;
121
:
2388
2397
.

6

Blankenberg
S
,
Salomaa
V
,
Makarova
N
,
Ojeda
F
,
Wild
P
,
Lackner
KJ
,
Jørgensen
T
,
Thorand
B
,
Peters
A
,
Nauck
M
,
Petersmann
A
,
Vartiainen
E
,
Veronesi
G
,
Brambilla
P
,
Costanzo
S
,
Iacoviello
L
,
Linden
G
,
Yarnell
J
,
Patterson
CC
,
Everett
BM
,
Ridker
PM
,
Kontto
J
,
Schnabel
RB
,
Koenig
W
,
Kee
F
,
Zeller
T
,
Kuulasmaa
K
,.
Troponin I and cardiovascular risk prediction in the general population: the BiomarCaRE consortium
.
Eur Heart J
2016
;
37
:
2428
2437
.

This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (https://dbpia.nl.go.kr/journals/pages/open_access/funder_policies/chorus/standard_publication_model)

Comments

0 Comments
Submit a comment
You have entered an invalid code
Thank you for submitting a comment on this article. Your comment will be reviewed and published at the journal's discretion. Please check for further notifications by email.