We evaluated the effects of three to five applications of individual insecticides, or insecticides used in rotation, against Spotted Wing Drosophila (SWD) in Tart Cherry. Single-tree plots were established in a 24-yr-old ‘Montmorency’ cherry planting (15 × 20 ft spacing) at the Trevor Nichols Research Center in Fennville, MI (Tart Cherry 4). The trial was organized as an RCB with four replications. Applications began 20 June at initial infestation with ripe fruit and were reapplied on 7-day intervals until 19 July (Table 1). Test materials were applied with a FMC 1029 airblast sprayer calibrated to deliver 100 GPA at 2.5 mph.

Treatment/formulationRate form product/acre or v:vApplication timingaMean SWD per pound of fruit
10 Jul17 Jul24 Jul
Untreated43.8a166a73.3a
Pyrifluquinazon L3.2 fl oz/aABCDE29.3ab43.5ab47.3ab
Apta 15 SC27 fl oz/aAB1.3b42.5ab49.3ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCD
Mustang Maxx 0.8 EC4 fl oz/aE
Delegate 25 WG7 oz/aABCDE22ab50.5ab17.5ab
Imidan 70 WP +1.33 lb/aA5ab36.3ab61.5ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galA
Lannate L3 pt/aB
Hero 1.24 EC10.3 oz/aC
Cormoran L20 oz/aD
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aE
 NuFilm P L0.125%E
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aABCD16.3ab25ab60.5ab
 NuFilm P L0.125%ABCD
Movento SC +7.6 oz/aAB2.3b67.8ab51ab
 R-11 90 EC0.5%AB
Baythroid XL 120 EC2.8 oz/aCDE
Imidan 70 WP +2.125 lb/aABCDE2.5b33ab11.8ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galABCDE
IKI-3131 SL8.2 fl oz/aABCDE1.8b54.8ab20.5ab
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE0b12.5b31.3ab
 Preference L0.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7.8ab33b8.8b
 AG161340.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE2.5b25b27.3ab
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7ab31ab29.3ab
 AG16134 +0.25%ABCDE
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aABCDE5.8ab13.8b41ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aBCDE4.3ab28.5b9.5b
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCDE3.8b28.5ab51.8ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aDE3.8ab53.3ab32.8ab
Spider Venom LC1472.94 fl oz/aABCDE4ab51ab69.5a
JetAg L1%ABCDE0b84.5ab33.8ab
JetAg L1%ABCDE2.5b10.8b46.8ab
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ7ab17b25.3ab
Treatment/formulationRate form product/acre or v:vApplication timingaMean SWD per pound of fruit
10 Jul17 Jul24 Jul
Untreated43.8a166a73.3a
Pyrifluquinazon L3.2 fl oz/aABCDE29.3ab43.5ab47.3ab
Apta 15 SC27 fl oz/aAB1.3b42.5ab49.3ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCD
Mustang Maxx 0.8 EC4 fl oz/aE
Delegate 25 WG7 oz/aABCDE22ab50.5ab17.5ab
Imidan 70 WP +1.33 lb/aA5ab36.3ab61.5ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galA
Lannate L3 pt/aB
Hero 1.24 EC10.3 oz/aC
Cormoran L20 oz/aD
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aE
 NuFilm P L0.125%E
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aABCD16.3ab25ab60.5ab
 NuFilm P L0.125%ABCD
Movento SC +7.6 oz/aAB2.3b67.8ab51ab
 R-11 90 EC0.5%AB
Baythroid XL 120 EC2.8 oz/aCDE
Imidan 70 WP +2.125 lb/aABCDE2.5b33ab11.8ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galABCDE
IKI-3131 SL8.2 fl oz/aABCDE1.8b54.8ab20.5ab
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE0b12.5b31.3ab
 Preference L0.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7.8ab33b8.8b
 AG161340.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE2.5b25b27.3ab
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7ab31ab29.3ab
 AG16134 +0.25%ABCDE
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aABCDE5.8ab13.8b41ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aBCDE4.3ab28.5b9.5b
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCDE3.8b28.5ab51.8ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aDE3.8ab53.3ab32.8ab
Spider Venom LC1472.94 fl oz/aABCDE4ab51ab69.5a
JetAg L1%ABCDE0b84.5ab33.8ab
JetAg L1%ABCDE2.5b10.8b46.8ab
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ7ab17b25.3ab

Means within columns followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). ANOVA performed on sqrt transformed data; original means are shown.

aA = 20 Jun (First trap catch with ripe fruit), B = 28 Jun (A + 7 days), C = 4 Jul (B + 7 days), D = 11 Jul (C + 7 days), E = 18 Jul (D + 7 days), F = 21 Jun (1 day after A), G = 29 Jun (1 day after B), H = 5 Jul (1 day after C), I = 12 Jul (1 day after D), J = 19 Jul (1 day after E).

Treatment/formulationRate form product/acre or v:vApplication timingaMean SWD per pound of fruit
10 Jul17 Jul24 Jul
Untreated43.8a166a73.3a
Pyrifluquinazon L3.2 fl oz/aABCDE29.3ab43.5ab47.3ab
Apta 15 SC27 fl oz/aAB1.3b42.5ab49.3ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCD
Mustang Maxx 0.8 EC4 fl oz/aE
Delegate 25 WG7 oz/aABCDE22ab50.5ab17.5ab
Imidan 70 WP +1.33 lb/aA5ab36.3ab61.5ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galA
Lannate L3 pt/aB
Hero 1.24 EC10.3 oz/aC
Cormoran L20 oz/aD
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aE
 NuFilm P L0.125%E
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aABCD16.3ab25ab60.5ab
 NuFilm P L0.125%ABCD
Movento SC +7.6 oz/aAB2.3b67.8ab51ab
 R-11 90 EC0.5%AB
Baythroid XL 120 EC2.8 oz/aCDE
Imidan 70 WP +2.125 lb/aABCDE2.5b33ab11.8ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galABCDE
IKI-3131 SL8.2 fl oz/aABCDE1.8b54.8ab20.5ab
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE0b12.5b31.3ab
 Preference L0.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7.8ab33b8.8b
 AG161340.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE2.5b25b27.3ab
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7ab31ab29.3ab
 AG16134 +0.25%ABCDE
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aABCDE5.8ab13.8b41ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aBCDE4.3ab28.5b9.5b
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCDE3.8b28.5ab51.8ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aDE3.8ab53.3ab32.8ab
Spider Venom LC1472.94 fl oz/aABCDE4ab51ab69.5a
JetAg L1%ABCDE0b84.5ab33.8ab
JetAg L1%ABCDE2.5b10.8b46.8ab
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ7ab17b25.3ab
Treatment/formulationRate form product/acre or v:vApplication timingaMean SWD per pound of fruit
10 Jul17 Jul24 Jul
Untreated43.8a166a73.3a
Pyrifluquinazon L3.2 fl oz/aABCDE29.3ab43.5ab47.3ab
Apta 15 SC27 fl oz/aAB1.3b42.5ab49.3ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCD
Mustang Maxx 0.8 EC4 fl oz/aE
Delegate 25 WG7 oz/aABCDE22ab50.5ab17.5ab
Imidan 70 WP +1.33 lb/aA5ab36.3ab61.5ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galA
Lannate L3 pt/aB
Hero 1.24 EC10.3 oz/aC
Cormoran L20 oz/aD
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aE
 NuFilm P L0.125%E
Grandevo WDG +3 lb/aABCD16.3ab25ab60.5ab
 NuFilm P L0.125%ABCD
Movento SC +7.6 oz/aAB2.3b67.8ab51ab
 R-11 90 EC0.5%AB
Baythroid XL 120 EC2.8 oz/aCDE
Imidan 70 WP +2.125 lb/aABCDE2.5b33ab11.8ab
 TriFol L0.5 pt/100 galABCDE
IKI-3131 SL8.2 fl oz/aABCDE1.8b54.8ab20.5ab
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE0b12.5b31.3ab
 Preference L0.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7.8ab33b8.8b
 AG161340.25%ABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE2.5b25b27.3ab
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Delegate 25 WG +7 oz/aABCDE7ab31ab29.3ab
 AG16134 +0.25%ABCDE
 Accudrop L3 fl oz/aABCDE
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aABCDE5.8ab13.8b41ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aBCDE4.3ab28.5b9.5b
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aCDE3.8b28.5ab51.8ab
Verdepryn L8.2 fl oz/aDE3.8ab53.3ab32.8ab
Spider Venom LC1472.94 fl oz/aABCDE4ab51ab69.5a
JetAg L1%ABCDE0b84.5ab33.8ab
JetAg L1%ABCDE2.5b10.8b46.8ab
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ
Delegate 25 WG5.2 oz/aFGHIJ7ab17b25.3ab

Means within columns followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). ANOVA performed on sqrt transformed data; original means are shown.

aA = 20 Jun (First trap catch with ripe fruit), B = 28 Jun (A + 7 days), C = 4 Jul (B + 7 days), D = 11 Jul (C + 7 days), E = 18 Jul (D + 7 days), F = 21 Jun (1 day after A), G = 29 Jun (1 day after B), H = 5 Jul (1 day after C), I = 12 Jul (1 day after D), J = 19 Jul (1 day after E).

Two-pound samples of random ripe fruit were hand-picked from each plot on 10 July, 17 July, and 24 July. The fruit were evaluated using the Washington State Department of Agriculture brown sugar method by crushing them in a sugar solution (7 pounds brown sugar to 5 gallons water). The larvae were allowed to float and were subsequently counted. Counts of the total larvae per pound of fruit were analyzed using ANOVA with means separation by Tukey’s HSD (P = 0.05) after square root transformation of the data.

In the 10 July evaluation, after most plots had received the first three insecticide applications, nine treatments reduced SWD compared to the untreated check. These included Apta followed by Verdepryn, Movento followed by Baythroid, Imidan, IKI-3131, Delegate with Preference, Delegate with Accudrop, one application of Verdepryn on 4 July, JetAg, and JetAg followed by Delegate (Table 1). However, it should be noted that none of the treatments were statistically improved compared to Verdepryn (application timings DE) that had still not received its first treatment, and therefore served as a second untreated check through the 10 July evaluation date.

In the 17 July evaluation, seven treatments reduced SWD to 10.8–33 SWD per pound of fruit compared to the untreated check (166 per pound). These plots received three applications of Verdepryn (starting at 28 June), or four applications of Delegate with Preference, Delegate with AG16134, Delegate with Accudrop, Verdepryn (beginning on 20 June), JetAg followed by Delegate, or Delegate (Table 1).

In the 24 July evaluation, two treatments reduced SWD to <10 per pound of fruit compared to 73.3 in the untreated check. These treatments include five applications of Delegate with AG16134 and four applications of Verdepryn (starting 28 June) (Table 1). Across all evaluation dates there were no significant differences among plots receiving two to five applications of Verdepryn.1

Footnotes

1

This research was supported by industry gifts of pesticides and research funding.

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]
Section Editor: David Haviland
David Haviland
Section Editor
Search for other works by this author on: