Citricola scale causes loss of tree vigor, yield reduction, and downgrading of fruit in the packing house due to sooty mold growth on honeydew deposited by the insect. A field trial was conducted in a 36-yr-old ‘Washington’ navel orange orchard at the Lindcove Research and Extension Center, Exeter, California, to compare various rates of insecticides for efficacy against citricola scale. Insecticides were applied using 200 PSI and 500 gpa to 10 trees per treatment using a 100 gal high-pressure D30 diaphragm pump sprayer with mechanical agitation. Treatments were assigned to trees on 15 May 2018 in an RCB design based on pretreatment counts of mature female citricola found on five twigs (~40 cm in length) randomly selected from the northeast corner of the tree. All insecticide treatments were applied with 0.5% Summer IAP oil on 31 Jul or 1 Aug, when the population consisted of first-instar nymphs infesting leaves. Posttreatment sampling consisted of counts of first-instar citricola nymphs infesting five leaves collected from the NE corner of each sample tree during Sep and Oct 2018. An additional sample of mature female citricola on five twigs per tree was collected in spring on 22 Apr 2019. Data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA after testing for NS block effect. Differences in the mean numbers of nymphs per leaf or adult female scale per twig were determined using Fisher’s protected least significant difference test (P ≤ 0.05) after log10(x + 1) transformation of numbers.

During the fall of 2018, all treatments applied significantly reduced the number of nymphs below the economic threshold of 0.5 nymphs/leaf (Table 1). In the spring of 2019, all treatments had significantly reduced the number of adult females below the threshold of 1.0 adult/twig when compared to the untreated check.1

Treatment/formulationRate-amt form/acre or volTreatment DateMean no. of citricola scale per leaf or twig
15 May 2018a10 Sepb9 Octb22 Apr 2019a
Untreated check1.76a2.46a2.96a5.08a
Sivanto HL Sc + Summer IAP oil7.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.72a0.16b0.44b0.70b
Sivanto Prime SC + Summer IAP oil14.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.64a0.70b0.13b0.16b
Sequoia SC + Summer IAP oil5.75c + 0.5%31 Jul1.62a0.88b0.20b0.20b
Actara 25 WG + Summer IAP oil5.5d + 0.5%41 Jul1.60a0.80b0.28b0.90b
P > F0.9960.016<0.001<0.001
F0.062.3611.517.66
df4, 454, 454, 454, 45
Treatment/formulationRate-amt form/acre or volTreatment DateMean no. of citricola scale per leaf or twig
15 May 2018a10 Sepb9 Octb22 Apr 2019a
Untreated check1.76a2.46a2.96a5.08a
Sivanto HL Sc + Summer IAP oil7.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.72a0.16b0.44b0.70b
Sivanto Prime SC + Summer IAP oil14.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.64a0.70b0.13b0.16b
Sequoia SC + Summer IAP oil5.75c + 0.5%31 Jul1.62a0.88b0.20b0.20b
Actara 25 WG + Summer IAP oil5.5d + 0.5%41 Jul1.60a0.80b0.28b0.90b
P > F0.9960.016<0.001<0.001
F0.062.3611.517.66
df4, 454, 454, 454, 45

Means within a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (FPLSD, P > 0.05) after log10(x + 1) transformation. Untransformed means are shown.

aCitricola adult females sampled.

bCitricola nymphs sampled.

coz (fl) product per acre.

doz (wt) product per acre.

Treatment/formulationRate-amt form/acre or volTreatment DateMean no. of citricola scale per leaf or twig
15 May 2018a10 Sepb9 Octb22 Apr 2019a
Untreated check1.76a2.46a2.96a5.08a
Sivanto HL Sc + Summer IAP oil7.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.72a0.16b0.44b0.70b
Sivanto Prime SC + Summer IAP oil14.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.64a0.70b0.13b0.16b
Sequoia SC + Summer IAP oil5.75c + 0.5%31 Jul1.62a0.88b0.20b0.20b
Actara 25 WG + Summer IAP oil5.5d + 0.5%41 Jul1.60a0.80b0.28b0.90b
P > F0.9960.016<0.001<0.001
F0.062.3611.517.66
df4, 454, 454, 454, 45
Treatment/formulationRate-amt form/acre or volTreatment DateMean no. of citricola scale per leaf or twig
15 May 2018a10 Sepb9 Octb22 Apr 2019a
Untreated check1.76a2.46a2.96a5.08a
Sivanto HL Sc + Summer IAP oil7.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.72a0.16b0.44b0.70b
Sivanto Prime SC + Summer IAP oil14.0c + 0.5%1 Aug1.64a0.70b0.13b0.16b
Sequoia SC + Summer IAP oil5.75c + 0.5%31 Jul1.62a0.88b0.20b0.20b
Actara 25 WG + Summer IAP oil5.5d + 0.5%41 Jul1.60a0.80b0.28b0.90b
P > F0.9960.016<0.001<0.001
F0.062.3611.517.66
df4, 454, 454, 454, 45

Means within a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (FPLSD, P > 0.05) after log10(x + 1) transformation. Untransformed means are shown.

aCitricola adult females sampled.

bCitricola nymphs sampled.

coz (fl) product per acre.

doz (wt) product per acre.

Footnotes

1

This research was supported by the California Citrus Research Board and industry gifts.

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]
Section Editor: David Haviland
David Haviland
Section Editor
Search for other works by this author on: