-
PDF
- Split View
-
Views
-
Cite
Cite
David R Haviland, Stephanie M Rill, Youngsoo Son, Evaluation of Flupyradifurone Against Glassy-Winged Sharpshooter on Ornamentals, 2018, Arthropod Management Tests, Volume 44, Issue 1, 2019, tsz086, https://doi.org/10.1093/amt/tsz086
- Share Icon Share
This study was conducted to evaluate two rates of flupyradifurone (Altus, Bayer CropSciences) for its efficacy against GWSS on three ornamental hosts that are common in urban regions of California’s central valley. Twelve plants of each Xylosma sp., Photinia sp., and Euonymous sp. growing in 1-gal pots were used to compare three treatments: Altus 14 fl oz, Altus 7 fl oz, and a water-only check. Assignments were made such that the data could be evaluated as a completely randomized design of nine treatments by four replications (3 hosts × 3 treatments × 4 replicates). On 23 Aug, a spray bottle was used to treat each shrub using 160 ml of insecticide solution (to runoff) equivalent to 200 gal of water per acre. The effects of insecticide residues on GWSS mortality were evaluated at weekly intervals by caging adult GWSS onto the treated foliage using 5-gal paint strainer bags. Adult GWSS were collected each week from a local organic citrus orchard; ten mixed-gender adults were placed into a bag (1 cage per tree). On the day of treatment, the spray residues were allowed to dry for approximately 1 h and then one bag per plant containing the adults was placed onto each of the 36 plants. Mortality of GWSS within the bags was recorded 7 d later (1 WAT) by removing the bag and counting the dead and live adults. A new cage with new adults was placed onto the plant weekly for 6 wk after the initial application. Percentage mortality among treatments was compared by ANOVA with means separated by Fisher’s Protected LSD (P ≤ 0.05) after arcsine transformation.
Both rates of Altus had significant effects on GWSS mortality (Table 1). During the first WAT, both rates of Altus on all three ornamental hosts provided 100% GWSS control, compared with 18.8 to 78.6% mortality in the check. Both rates of Altus continued to provide >90% GWSS mortality in all rate and host combinations 2 and 3 WAT compared with 0 to 22.5% mortality in the check. This trend continued 4–6 WAT with highly significant GWSS mortality for all rates and host combinations where Altus was applied.
Plant variety . | Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Euonymous | Water check | – | 18.8c | 10.0c | 22.5c | 5.3c | 0.0d | 6.3c |
Photinia | Water check | – | 78.6b | 10.0c | 17.0c | 10.0c | 0.0d | 9.4c |
Xylosma | Water check | – | 22.3c | 10.0c | 0.0c | 7.5c | 6.7d | 5.0c |
Euonymous | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0ab | 100.0a | 97.5a | 91.7ab | 100.0a |
Photinia | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 97.5a | 94.4a | 84.3ab |
Xylosma | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 90.0b | 100.0a | 84.0ab | 68.0c | 83.2ab |
Euonymous | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 100.0a | 92.5ab | 94.7ab | 68.9b |
Photinia | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 78.1b | 69.6bc | 82.6b |
Xylosma | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 92.5b | 72.5b | 79.7abc | 63.5b |
F | 160.25 | 43.37 | 67.07 | 15.41 | 13.03 | 9.07 | ||
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Plant variety . | Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Euonymous | Water check | – | 18.8c | 10.0c | 22.5c | 5.3c | 0.0d | 6.3c |
Photinia | Water check | – | 78.6b | 10.0c | 17.0c | 10.0c | 0.0d | 9.4c |
Xylosma | Water check | – | 22.3c | 10.0c | 0.0c | 7.5c | 6.7d | 5.0c |
Euonymous | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0ab | 100.0a | 97.5a | 91.7ab | 100.0a |
Photinia | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 97.5a | 94.4a | 84.3ab |
Xylosma | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 90.0b | 100.0a | 84.0ab | 68.0c | 83.2ab |
Euonymous | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 100.0a | 92.5ab | 94.7ab | 68.9b |
Photinia | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 78.1b | 69.6bc | 82.6b |
Xylosma | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 92.5b | 72.5b | 79.7abc | 63.5b |
F | 160.25 | 43.37 | 67.07 | 15.41 | 13.03 | 9.07 | ||
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different, P ≤ 0.05, FPLSD after arcsin transformation of the percentage mortality. Original means are shown.
aRate of formulated product per 200 gal of water, sprayed to runoff.
bPercentage mortality of GWSS exposed to pesticide residues for 7-d periods from 1 to 6 weeks after treatment (WAT).
Plant variety . | Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Euonymous | Water check | – | 18.8c | 10.0c | 22.5c | 5.3c | 0.0d | 6.3c |
Photinia | Water check | – | 78.6b | 10.0c | 17.0c | 10.0c | 0.0d | 9.4c |
Xylosma | Water check | – | 22.3c | 10.0c | 0.0c | 7.5c | 6.7d | 5.0c |
Euonymous | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0ab | 100.0a | 97.5a | 91.7ab | 100.0a |
Photinia | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 97.5a | 94.4a | 84.3ab |
Xylosma | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 90.0b | 100.0a | 84.0ab | 68.0c | 83.2ab |
Euonymous | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 100.0a | 92.5ab | 94.7ab | 68.9b |
Photinia | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 78.1b | 69.6bc | 82.6b |
Xylosma | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 92.5b | 72.5b | 79.7abc | 63.5b |
F | 160.25 | 43.37 | 67.07 | 15.41 | 13.03 | 9.07 | ||
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Plant variety . | Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Euonymous | Water check | – | 18.8c | 10.0c | 22.5c | 5.3c | 0.0d | 6.3c |
Photinia | Water check | – | 78.6b | 10.0c | 17.0c | 10.0c | 0.0d | 9.4c |
Xylosma | Water check | – | 22.3c | 10.0c | 0.0c | 7.5c | 6.7d | 5.0c |
Euonymous | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0ab | 100.0a | 97.5a | 91.7ab | 100.0a |
Photinia | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 97.5a | 94.4a | 84.3ab |
Xylosma | Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 90.0b | 100.0a | 84.0ab | 68.0c | 83.2ab |
Euonymous | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 100.0a | 92.5ab | 94.7ab | 68.9b |
Photinia | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 78.1b | 69.6bc | 82.6b |
Xylosma | Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 97.5ab | 92.5b | 72.5b | 79.7abc | 63.5b |
F | 160.25 | 43.37 | 67.07 | 15.41 | 13.03 | 9.07 | ||
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different, P ≤ 0.05, FPLSD after arcsin transformation of the percentage mortality. Original means are shown.
aRate of formulated product per 200 gal of water, sprayed to runoff.
bPercentage mortality of GWSS exposed to pesticide residues for 7-d periods from 1 to 6 weeks after treatment (WAT).
Since there was no host by treatment interaction, numbers were pooled across plant species (Table 2). There were no significant differences between the two Altus rates through 3 WAT. By 4 WAT, the high rate of Altus provided improved mortality compared with the low rate. By 5 WAT, mortality rates of the high rate continued to be numerically, but not statically, higher than the low rate for the remainder of the trial.
Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Water check | – | 39.9b | 10.0b | 13.2b | 7.6c | 2.2b | 6.9c |
Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0a | 99.2a | 93.1a | 84.8a | 89.3a |
Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 99.2a | 96.7a | 81.1b | 81.3a | 71.8b |
F | 108.89 | 173.61 | 209.68 | 56.03 | 38.75 | 34.76 | |
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Water check | – | 39.9b | 10.0b | 13.2b | 7.6c | 2.2b | 6.9c |
Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0a | 99.2a | 93.1a | 84.8a | 89.3a |
Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 99.2a | 96.7a | 81.1b | 81.3a | 71.8b |
F | 108.89 | 173.61 | 209.68 | 56.03 | 38.75 | 34.76 | |
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different, P > 0.05, FPLSD after arcsin transformation of the percentage mortality. Original means are shown.
aRate of formulated product per 200 gal of water, sprayed to runoff.
bPercentage mortality of GWSS exposed to pesticide residues for 7-d periods from 1 to 6 weeks after treatment (WAT).
Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Water check | – | 39.9b | 10.0b | 13.2b | 7.6c | 2.2b | 6.9c |
Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0a | 99.2a | 93.1a | 84.8a | 89.3a |
Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 99.2a | 96.7a | 81.1b | 81.3a | 71.8b |
F | 108.89 | 173.61 | 209.68 | 56.03 | 38.75 | 34.76 | |
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Treatment/formulation . | Rate/acrea . | Mean GWSS mortality (%)b . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
. | . | 1 WAT . | 2 WAT . | 3 WAT . | 4 WAT . | 5 WAT . | 6 WAT . |
Water check | – | 39.9b | 10.0b | 13.2b | 7.6c | 2.2b | 6.9c |
Altus | 14 fl oz | 100.0a | 95.0a | 99.2a | 93.1a | 84.8a | 89.3a |
Altus | 7 fl oz | 100.0a | 99.2a | 96.7a | 81.1b | 81.3a | 71.8b |
F | 108.89 | 173.61 | 209.68 | 56.03 | 38.75 | 34.76 | |
P | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 | <0.0001 |
Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different, P > 0.05, FPLSD after arcsin transformation of the percentage mortality. Original means are shown.
aRate of formulated product per 200 gal of water, sprayed to runoff.
bPercentage mortality of GWSS exposed to pesticide residues for 7-d periods from 1 to 6 weeks after treatment (WAT).
This research was supported by the Consolidated Central Valley Table Grape Pest and Disease Control District.