The objective of this trial was to test the efficacy of various insecticides against PP. Mature “Bartlett” pear trees at the Trevor Nichols Research Center in Fennville, MI (Pear 3 Block) were sprayed with an FMC 1029 airblast sprayer at the rate of 100 gpa. One-tree plots were arranged in an RCB design with four replications. Tree spacing was 18 × 20 ft, with at least one buffer row separating all plots. Regular maintenance foliar applications of Kasumin 2, Penncozeb 75, Vangard 75, Agri-Mycin, Fireline, Apogee 27.5, Asana XL, Lannate LV, Captan, and Alion were applied across the block. In addition, glyphosate was banded below the trees for weed control. Test materials were applied on 13 May, 3 Jun, and 22 Jul at nymph threshold (1 nymph per 3 leaves). PP and egg evaluations were made on 21 Jul (pretreatment count), 28 Jul, and 4 and 12 Aug. Fifty leaves per plot were examined with the aid of a stereomicroscope, and the number of psylla eggs and nymphs were recorded. Transformed treatment means were analyzed using ANOVA and means separation by Tukey’s HSD at P = 0.05.

All treatments significantly reduced the incidence of PP nymphs and/or eggs within 7 days of application, compared to the untreated check (Tables 1, 2). All treatments continued to provide significant plant protection through the 4 Aug evaluation, with Rimon having lowest PP nymph levels.

Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla eggs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check846.3a1477.8a1010.8a1003.3a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC882.5a641.3 b471.8bc502.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC737a670b512 bc418.3b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC756.5a743b452.5 bc499.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC793a871.8ab415c482.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC649.8a677.5b651abc616.8ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC643.8a601.8b727.3abc669.3ab
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC768.3a812.5b839.8ab605.3ab
Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla eggs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check846.3a1477.8a1010.8a1003.3a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC882.5a641.3 b471.8bc502.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC737a670b512 bc418.3b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC756.5a743b452.5 bc499.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC793a871.8ab415c482.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC649.8a677.5b651abc616.8ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC643.8a601.8b727.3abc669.3ab
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC768.3a812.5b839.8ab605.3ab

Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD).

ANOVA performed on square-root transformed data; data presented are actual counts.

A = 13 May (Petal fall), B = 3 Jun (A + 21 days), C = 22 Jul (threshold, 1 nymph per 3 leaves).

Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla eggs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check846.3a1477.8a1010.8a1003.3a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC882.5a641.3 b471.8bc502.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC737a670b512 bc418.3b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC756.5a743b452.5 bc499.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC793a871.8ab415c482.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC649.8a677.5b651abc616.8ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC643.8a601.8b727.3abc669.3ab
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC768.3a812.5b839.8ab605.3ab
Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla eggs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check846.3a1477.8a1010.8a1003.3a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC882.5a641.3 b471.8bc502.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC737a670b512 bc418.3b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC756.5a743b452.5 bc499.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC793a871.8ab415c482.5b
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC649.8a677.5b651abc616.8ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC643.8a601.8b727.3abc669.3ab
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC768.3a812.5b839.8ab605.3ab

Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD).

ANOVA performed on square-root transformed data; data presented are actual counts.

A = 13 May (Petal fall), B = 3 Jun (A + 21 days), C = 22 Jul (threshold, 1 nymph per 3 leaves).

Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla nymphs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check53.5ab538.3a695.8a508a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC41b112.3b124bc162bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC57.8ab115.3b177.3b229.5abc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC71.3ab87b176.5b161.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC74.3ab118.5b104.5bc246.3ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC94.3a158.3b114.5bc119.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC68.3ab48.8b130bc159bc
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC64ab37.5b34.8c30.3c
Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla nymphs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check53.5ab538.3a695.8a508a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC41b112.3b124bc162bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC57.8ab115.3b177.3b229.5abc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC71.3ab87b176.5b161.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC74.3ab118.5b104.5bc246.3ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC94.3a158.3b114.5bc119.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC68.3ab48.8b130bc159bc
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC64ab37.5b34.8c30.3c

Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). ANOVA performed on square-root transformed data; data presented are actual counts.

A = 13 May (Petal fall), B = 3 Jun (A + 21 days), C = 22 Jul (threshold at 1 nymph per 3 leaves).

Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla nymphs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check53.5ab538.3a695.8a508a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC41b112.3b124bc162bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC57.8ab115.3b177.3b229.5abc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC71.3ab87b176.5b161.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC74.3ab118.5b104.5bc246.3ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC94.3a158.3b114.5bc119.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC68.3ab48.8b130bc159bc
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC64ab37.5b34.8c30.3c
Treatment/formulationRate product/acreAppl. TimingPsylla nymphs per 50 leaves
21 Jul28 Jul4 Aug12 Aug
Untreated check53.5ab538.3a695.8a508a
Minecto Pro SC + 8 fl ozABC41b112.3b124bc162bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 10 fl ozABC57.8ab115.3b177.3b229.5abc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Minecto Pro SC + 12 fl ozABC71.3ab87b176.5b161.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Exirel 0.83SC +13.5 fl ozABC74.3ab118.5b104.5bc246.3ab
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Agri-Mek 0.7SC +3.46 fl ozABC94.3a158.3b114.5bc119.8bc
Damoil 90EC0.25% v: vABC
Dimilin 2L16 fl ozABC68.3ab48.8b130bc159bc
Rimon 0.83EC20 fl ozABC64ab37.5b34.8c30.3c

Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). ANOVA performed on square-root transformed data; data presented are actual counts.

A = 13 May (Petal fall), B = 3 Jun (A + 21 days), C = 22 Jul (threshold at 1 nymph per 3 leaves).

Author notes

*

This research was supported by industry gifts of pesticides and research funding.

Subject Editor: Elizabeth Beers

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]