-
PDF
- Split View
-
Views
-
Cite
Cite
Russell L. Groves, Scott Chapman, Linda K. Crubaugh, Emily Duerr, Ben Bradford, Justin Clements, Registered and Experimental Foliar Insecticides for Control of Colorado Potato Beetle and Potato Leafhopper in Potato, 2016, Arthropod Management Tests, Volume 42, Issue 1, January 2017, tsx057, https://doi.org/10.1093/amt/tsx057
- Share Icon Share
The objective of this experiment was to assess the efficacy of foliar insecticides applied for the control of select insect pests in potato. The trial consisted of 34 main effect treatments and 2 untreated checks arranged in a randomized complete block design with four experimental replicates. This experiment was conducted at the Hancock Agricultural Research Station (HARS) located 1.1 mile (1.8 km) southwest of Hancock, Wisconsin on a loamy sand soil in the spring and early summer season of 2016. Experimental plots consisted of two row plots measuring 6 ft (1.8 m) wide and 20 ft (6.1 m) in length with unplanted guard rows on each side. Rows were planted on 36 inch (0.9 m) row centers with 12 inch (30.5 cm) between plants with 12 ft (3.6 m) alleys separating replications. All foliar treatments were applied at 20 gallons per acre (gpa) using a four nozzle, 6 ft (1.8 m) boom equipped with an XRVS 8002 flat fan spray tip powered by a CO2 backpack sprayer operating at 30 psi. Up to three foliar applications were made, however most treatments were comprised of two applications on 16 Jun and 23 Jun when 75–90% of the first generation CPB was within the first and second stadia (Table 1). Weather conditions, insect counts and days after treatment dates can be found in Tables 2 and 3. All plots were maintained according to standard commercial practices including irrigation, fertility and disease management inputs. Insect life stages including CPB adults (AD), egg masses (EM), small larvae (SL), large larvae (LL) were assessed by counting the number of each on 10 randomly selected plants from the center of each plot. Potato leafhopper (PLH) control efficacy was assessed by counting the number of adults (PLH-A) in 20 standard 15 inch (38.1 cm) canopy sweeps, and nymphs (PLH-N) on 25 randomly selected leaves from the center two rows of each plot. Aphid control efficacy was assessed using the same method as for PLH nymphs. Defoliation ratings (DF) were determined by visual observation of the entire plot and ranked by an index value whereby defoliation was scored as a value of “1”, if estimated defoliation ranged between 0% and 2%; as a “2” if estimated defoliation ranged between 2% and 5%; as a “3” if estimated defoliation ranged between 5% and 10%; and as a “4” if estimated defoliation exceeded 10%. Cumulative count data were initially Log10 transformed prior to data analysis using ANOVA and means were compared using a Tukey’s HSD means separation test (P = 0.05) (Table 4). Populations of CPB were already established by the first foliar application, as defoliation estimates approached 5% in most plots. Experimental treatments were often significantly different than the untreated check in the control of CPB adult, larval, and associated defoliation, although some treatments were more effective at controlling immature CPB. No signs of phototoxicity were observed.
. | Treatments/rates . | Application dates . | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 6 Jul . | ||
1 | Untreated | ||||
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | ||
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
31 | Untreated | ||||
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | X | X | ||
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X |
. | Treatments/rates . | Application dates . | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 6 Jul . | ||
1 | Untreated | ||||
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | ||
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
31 | Untreated | ||||
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | X | X | ||
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X |
. | Treatments/rates . | Application dates . | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 6 Jul . | ||
1 | Untreated | ||||
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | ||
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
31 | Untreated | ||||
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | X | X | ||
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X |
. | Treatments/rates . | Application dates . | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 6 Jul . | ||
1 | Untreated | ||||
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | X | X | ||
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | X | X | ||
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | X | |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | X | X | ||
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | X | X | X | |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | X | X | X | |
31 | Untreated | ||||
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | X | X | ||
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X | ||
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | X | X |
Count type . | 8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 20 Jun . | 22 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 27 Jun . | 29 Jun . | 6 Jul . | 6 Jul . | 7 Jul . | 12 Jul . | 13 Jul . | 14 Jul . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CPB-A | Insecticide application | Insecticide application | X | Insecticide application | X | X | Insecticide application | X | |||||
CPB-EM | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-SL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-LL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
PLH-A | X | X | X | ||||||||||
PLH-N | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Aphid | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Defoliation | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Days after last treatment | 4 | 6 | – | 4 | 6 | 13 | – | 1 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
Count type . | 8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 20 Jun . | 22 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 27 Jun . | 29 Jun . | 6 Jul . | 6 Jul . | 7 Jul . | 12 Jul . | 13 Jul . | 14 Jul . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CPB-A | Insecticide application | Insecticide application | X | Insecticide application | X | X | Insecticide application | X | |||||
CPB-EM | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-SL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-LL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
PLH-A | X | X | X | ||||||||||
PLH-N | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Aphid | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Defoliation | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Days after last treatment | 4 | 6 | – | 4 | 6 | 13 | – | 1 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
Count type . | 8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 20 Jun . | 22 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 27 Jun . | 29 Jun . | 6 Jul . | 6 Jul . | 7 Jul . | 12 Jul . | 13 Jul . | 14 Jul . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CPB-A | Insecticide application | Insecticide application | X | Insecticide application | X | X | Insecticide application | X | |||||
CPB-EM | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-SL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-LL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
PLH-A | X | X | X | ||||||||||
PLH-N | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Aphid | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Defoliation | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Days after last treatment | 4 | 6 | – | 4 | 6 | 13 | – | 1 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
Count type . | 8 Jun . | 16 Jun . | 20 Jun . | 22 Jun . | 23 Jun . | 27 Jun . | 29 Jun . | 6 Jul . | 6 Jul . | 7 Jul . | 12 Jul . | 13 Jul . | 14 Jul . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CPB-A | Insecticide application | Insecticide application | X | Insecticide application | X | X | Insecticide application | X | |||||
CPB-EM | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-SL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
CPB-LL | X | X | X | X | |||||||||
PLH-A | X | X | X | ||||||||||
PLH-N | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Aphid | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Defoliation | X | X | X | ||||||||||
Days after last treatment | 4 | 6 | – | 4 | 6 | 13 | – | 1 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
Date . | Appl Time . | Wind Dir . | Wind Speed . | Temp. . | RH% . | Sky . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun | 10:00–11:00 | N/NW | 3 mph (4.8 kph) | 71 °F (22 °C) | 57 | cloudy |
16 Jun | 9:30–11:00 | N | 5–8 mph (8–13 kph) | 68 °F (20 °C) | 55 | cloudy |
23 Jun | 9:00–10:30 | E | 2 mph (3.2 kph) | 70 °F (21 °C) | 62 | cloudy |
6 Jul | 9:00–10:00 | W | 2.5 mph (4.1 kph) | 72 °F (22 °C) | 79 | cloudy |
Date . | Appl Time . | Wind Dir . | Wind Speed . | Temp. . | RH% . | Sky . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun | 10:00–11:00 | N/NW | 3 mph (4.8 kph) | 71 °F (22 °C) | 57 | cloudy |
16 Jun | 9:30–11:00 | N | 5–8 mph (8–13 kph) | 68 °F (20 °C) | 55 | cloudy |
23 Jun | 9:00–10:30 | E | 2 mph (3.2 kph) | 70 °F (21 °C) | 62 | cloudy |
6 Jul | 9:00–10:00 | W | 2.5 mph (4.1 kph) | 72 °F (22 °C) | 79 | cloudy |
Date . | Appl Time . | Wind Dir . | Wind Speed . | Temp. . | RH% . | Sky . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun | 10:00–11:00 | N/NW | 3 mph (4.8 kph) | 71 °F (22 °C) | 57 | cloudy |
16 Jun | 9:30–11:00 | N | 5–8 mph (8–13 kph) | 68 °F (20 °C) | 55 | cloudy |
23 Jun | 9:00–10:30 | E | 2 mph (3.2 kph) | 70 °F (21 °C) | 62 | cloudy |
6 Jul | 9:00–10:00 | W | 2.5 mph (4.1 kph) | 72 °F (22 °C) | 79 | cloudy |
Date . | Appl Time . | Wind Dir . | Wind Speed . | Temp. . | RH% . | Sky . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Jun | 10:00–11:00 | N/NW | 3 mph (4.8 kph) | 71 °F (22 °C) | 57 | cloudy |
16 Jun | 9:30–11:00 | N | 5–8 mph (8–13 kph) | 68 °F (20 °C) | 55 | cloudy |
23 Jun | 9:00–10:30 | E | 2 mph (3.2 kph) | 70 °F (21 °C) | 62 | cloudy |
6 Jul | 9:00–10:00 | W | 2.5 mph (4.1 kph) | 72 °F (22 °C) | 79 | cloudy |
. | Treatment/Rate . | CPB-AD 1 . | CPB-AD 2 . | CPB-EM . | CPB-SL . | CPB-LL . | PLHA . | PLHN . | Aphid . | DF . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Untreated | 1.25 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 5.75 a | 407.25 hi | 277.00 j | 5.75 a–g | 25 ef | 4.75 a | 3.83 kl |
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6 c–g | 30 ab | 5.25 a | 38.25 a–d | 5.50 ab | 28.00 ij | 19.5 ef | 2.5 a | 1.08 ab |
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 2.5 a–g | 31 a–e | 8.00 a | 81.75 c–g | 7.50 a–e | 26.75 hij | 25.5 ef | 6.5 a | 1.08 ab |
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 77.5 a–g | 9.00 a | 51.25 a–e | 7.00 a–d | 21.25 g–j | 22.5 ef | 4 a | 1.33 a–d |
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.75 fg | 31.5 a–d | 10.00 a | 45.25 a–d | 3.25 a | 28.00 hij | 21.75 ef | 3 a | 1.08 ab |
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | 4.75 a–g | 12.5 a | 11.50 a | 32.00 abc | 1.50 a | 20.50 f–j | 16.25 c–f | 2 a | 1.00 a |
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5 b–g | 39 a–f | 8.75 a | 186.75 e–i | 24.75 e–h | 12.00 c–j | 2.5 a–e | 3.5 a | 1.00 a |
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 c–g | 52.25 abc | 11.25 a | 46.50 a–d | 24.25 d–g | 21.50 g–j | 34.25 f | 5.5 a | 1.25 abc |
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 d–g | 93.5 a–g | 12.50 a | 49.50 a–e | 14.00 b–f | 29.25 ij | 43 f | 8.5 a | 1.42 a–e |
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 30.75 a–e | 10.75 a | 54.00 bcdef | 20.00 c–f | 23.00 g–j | 23.5 ef | 4 a | 1.00 a |
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 210 efg | 4.00 a | 571.75 i | 286.25 j | 1.75 a | 9.75 a–f | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 123.75 c–g | 2.75 a | 555.50 i | 287.50 j | 2.25 ab | 8.5 a–f | 4.5 a | 3.83 kl |
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 181.75 d–g | 4.25 a | 371.75 hi | 246.00 ij | 3.25 abc | 11.75 a–f | 5.5 a | 3.33 jkl |
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 159.25 d–g | 1.50 a | 483.50 i | 267.25 j | 3.75 a–d | 11 a–f | 2.25 a | 3.50 jkl |
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.25 a | 146.75 d–g | 3.25 a | 568.50 i | 239.75 ij | 1.50 a | 6.25 a–f | 3.25 a | 3.58 jkl |
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.5 a–g | 199.5 efg | 4.25 a | 522.75 i | 180.50 ij | 3.75 abc | 14 a–f | 1.5 a | 3.08 hij |
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 2.25 a–g | 142 d–g | 4.00 a | 490.75 i | 231.50 ij | 4.00 a–d | 9.25 a–f | 0.75 a | 3.42 jkl |
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 4.5 a–g | 219.75 d–g | 7.50 a | 266.25 ghi | 112.00 ij | 4.75 a–e | 0.75 abc | 9.5 a | 1.75 b–f |
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 278.75 g | 7.25 a | 236.25 f–i | 79.75 hi | 1.75 a | 0.25 a | 7 a | 1.92 c–g |
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 220.5 d–g | 7.00 a | 394.25 hi | 25.75 e–h | 5.00 a–f | 9.25 a–f | 5.25 a | 2.08 efg |
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.5 efg | 155.25 d–g | 8.75 a | 48.00 a–e | 4.00 a | 20.50 e–j | 41.25 ef | 12.25 a | 1.58 a–e |
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 2.5 a–g | 129.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 482.25 i | 217.75 ij | 8.75 b–j | 30.75 ef | 2.75 a | 3.08 hij |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 171.25 d–g | 3.75 a | 279.75 ghi | 150.25 ij | 11.25 b–j | 26 ef | 2 a | 2.42 fgh |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 0.75 ab | 180.5 d–g | 5.50 a | 450.50 hi | 201.75 ij | 8.75 a–i | 27.5 def | 4.25 a | 3.33 jkl |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 156.5 d–g | 3.25 a | 463.25 i | 229.75 ij | 5.75 a–g | 24.5 def | 3 a | 3.42 jkl |
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | 1.25 a–f | 191.25 d–g | 6.50 a | 301.25 ghi | 140.75 ij | 9.50 b–j | 32 ef | 2.5 a | 2.50 ghi |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | 1 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 2.00 a | 626.50 i | 204.50 ij | 5.50 a–f | 33.5 ef | 4.5 a | 3.17 ijk |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | 3 a–g | 198 efg | 7.75 a | 226.50 ghi | 75.25 ghi | 19.50 e–j | 60 f | 11.5 a | 2.08 efg |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 114.5 b–g | 4.00 a | 474.00 hi | 274.00 j | 3.75 a–d | 17.25 b–f | 0.5 a | 3.83 kl |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–d | 112.75 b–g | 6:00 AM a | 405.25 hi | 220.50 ij | 6.75 a–h | 32.75 ef | 3.5 a | 3.75 jkl |
31 | Untreated | 1.75 a–g | 128.25 b–g | 4.75 a | 418 hi | 226.50 ij | 7.00 a–i | 23.5 ef | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 385.25 fg | 14.25 a | 56.5 a–e | 34.25 fgh | 11.50 c–j | 2 a–d | 0 a | 2.00 d–g |
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | 3 a–g | 144.5 d–g | 5.25 a | 15.5 a | 6.00 abc | 16.00 d–j | 18.5 ef | 2.75 a | 1.92 c–g |
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | 7 d–g | 148.5 b–g | 13.00 a | 17.75 ab | 23.75 def | 22.25 g–j | 41.5 ef | 6 a | 1.83 c–g |
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 180.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 268 ghi | 209.75 ij | 7.00 a–i | 0.5 ab | 0.25 a | 2.50 ghi |
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.25 a–g | 279.25 efg | 7.25 a | 121.75 d–h | 24.75 c–f | 33.75 j | 31.5 ef | 0.75 a | 1.67 a–e |
P | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.0002 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.513 | < 0.0001 | |
HSD | 0.663 | 0.8653 | 0.8114 | 0.5866 | 0.5125 | 0.565 | 1.022 | 1.1744 | 0.7438 |
. | Treatment/Rate . | CPB-AD 1 . | CPB-AD 2 . | CPB-EM . | CPB-SL . | CPB-LL . | PLHA . | PLHN . | Aphid . | DF . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Untreated | 1.25 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 5.75 a | 407.25 hi | 277.00 j | 5.75 a–g | 25 ef | 4.75 a | 3.83 kl |
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6 c–g | 30 ab | 5.25 a | 38.25 a–d | 5.50 ab | 28.00 ij | 19.5 ef | 2.5 a | 1.08 ab |
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 2.5 a–g | 31 a–e | 8.00 a | 81.75 c–g | 7.50 a–e | 26.75 hij | 25.5 ef | 6.5 a | 1.08 ab |
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 77.5 a–g | 9.00 a | 51.25 a–e | 7.00 a–d | 21.25 g–j | 22.5 ef | 4 a | 1.33 a–d |
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.75 fg | 31.5 a–d | 10.00 a | 45.25 a–d | 3.25 a | 28.00 hij | 21.75 ef | 3 a | 1.08 ab |
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | 4.75 a–g | 12.5 a | 11.50 a | 32.00 abc | 1.50 a | 20.50 f–j | 16.25 c–f | 2 a | 1.00 a |
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5 b–g | 39 a–f | 8.75 a | 186.75 e–i | 24.75 e–h | 12.00 c–j | 2.5 a–e | 3.5 a | 1.00 a |
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 c–g | 52.25 abc | 11.25 a | 46.50 a–d | 24.25 d–g | 21.50 g–j | 34.25 f | 5.5 a | 1.25 abc |
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 d–g | 93.5 a–g | 12.50 a | 49.50 a–e | 14.00 b–f | 29.25 ij | 43 f | 8.5 a | 1.42 a–e |
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 30.75 a–e | 10.75 a | 54.00 bcdef | 20.00 c–f | 23.00 g–j | 23.5 ef | 4 a | 1.00 a |
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 210 efg | 4.00 a | 571.75 i | 286.25 j | 1.75 a | 9.75 a–f | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 123.75 c–g | 2.75 a | 555.50 i | 287.50 j | 2.25 ab | 8.5 a–f | 4.5 a | 3.83 kl |
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 181.75 d–g | 4.25 a | 371.75 hi | 246.00 ij | 3.25 abc | 11.75 a–f | 5.5 a | 3.33 jkl |
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 159.25 d–g | 1.50 a | 483.50 i | 267.25 j | 3.75 a–d | 11 a–f | 2.25 a | 3.50 jkl |
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.25 a | 146.75 d–g | 3.25 a | 568.50 i | 239.75 ij | 1.50 a | 6.25 a–f | 3.25 a | 3.58 jkl |
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.5 a–g | 199.5 efg | 4.25 a | 522.75 i | 180.50 ij | 3.75 abc | 14 a–f | 1.5 a | 3.08 hij |
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 2.25 a–g | 142 d–g | 4.00 a | 490.75 i | 231.50 ij | 4.00 a–d | 9.25 a–f | 0.75 a | 3.42 jkl |
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 4.5 a–g | 219.75 d–g | 7.50 a | 266.25 ghi | 112.00 ij | 4.75 a–e | 0.75 abc | 9.5 a | 1.75 b–f |
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 278.75 g | 7.25 a | 236.25 f–i | 79.75 hi | 1.75 a | 0.25 a | 7 a | 1.92 c–g |
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 220.5 d–g | 7.00 a | 394.25 hi | 25.75 e–h | 5.00 a–f | 9.25 a–f | 5.25 a | 2.08 efg |
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.5 efg | 155.25 d–g | 8.75 a | 48.00 a–e | 4.00 a | 20.50 e–j | 41.25 ef | 12.25 a | 1.58 a–e |
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 2.5 a–g | 129.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 482.25 i | 217.75 ij | 8.75 b–j | 30.75 ef | 2.75 a | 3.08 hij |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 171.25 d–g | 3.75 a | 279.75 ghi | 150.25 ij | 11.25 b–j | 26 ef | 2 a | 2.42 fgh |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 0.75 ab | 180.5 d–g | 5.50 a | 450.50 hi | 201.75 ij | 8.75 a–i | 27.5 def | 4.25 a | 3.33 jkl |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 156.5 d–g | 3.25 a | 463.25 i | 229.75 ij | 5.75 a–g | 24.5 def | 3 a | 3.42 jkl |
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | 1.25 a–f | 191.25 d–g | 6.50 a | 301.25 ghi | 140.75 ij | 9.50 b–j | 32 ef | 2.5 a | 2.50 ghi |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | 1 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 2.00 a | 626.50 i | 204.50 ij | 5.50 a–f | 33.5 ef | 4.5 a | 3.17 ijk |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | 3 a–g | 198 efg | 7.75 a | 226.50 ghi | 75.25 ghi | 19.50 e–j | 60 f | 11.5 a | 2.08 efg |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 114.5 b–g | 4.00 a | 474.00 hi | 274.00 j | 3.75 a–d | 17.25 b–f | 0.5 a | 3.83 kl |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–d | 112.75 b–g | 6:00 AM a | 405.25 hi | 220.50 ij | 6.75 a–h | 32.75 ef | 3.5 a | 3.75 jkl |
31 | Untreated | 1.75 a–g | 128.25 b–g | 4.75 a | 418 hi | 226.50 ij | 7.00 a–i | 23.5 ef | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 385.25 fg | 14.25 a | 56.5 a–e | 34.25 fgh | 11.50 c–j | 2 a–d | 0 a | 2.00 d–g |
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | 3 a–g | 144.5 d–g | 5.25 a | 15.5 a | 6.00 abc | 16.00 d–j | 18.5 ef | 2.75 a | 1.92 c–g |
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | 7 d–g | 148.5 b–g | 13.00 a | 17.75 ab | 23.75 def | 22.25 g–j | 41.5 ef | 6 a | 1.83 c–g |
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 180.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 268 ghi | 209.75 ij | 7.00 a–i | 0.5 ab | 0.25 a | 2.50 ghi |
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.25 a–g | 279.25 efg | 7.25 a | 121.75 d–h | 24.75 c–f | 33.75 j | 31.5 ef | 0.75 a | 1.67 a–e |
P | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.0002 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.513 | < 0.0001 | |
HSD | 0.663 | 0.8653 | 0.8114 | 0.5866 | 0.5125 | 0.565 | 1.022 | 1.1744 | 0.7438 |
NIS 100 L added at 0.1% v/v, MSO added at 0.125% v/v. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD test, α = 0.05). Means transformed (square root X + 1) prior to separation. Defoliation scored as follows: 1: 0–2%; 2: 2–5%; 3: 5–10%; 4: >10%.
. | Treatment/Rate . | CPB-AD 1 . | CPB-AD 2 . | CPB-EM . | CPB-SL . | CPB-LL . | PLHA . | PLHN . | Aphid . | DF . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Untreated | 1.25 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 5.75 a | 407.25 hi | 277.00 j | 5.75 a–g | 25 ef | 4.75 a | 3.83 kl |
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6 c–g | 30 ab | 5.25 a | 38.25 a–d | 5.50 ab | 28.00 ij | 19.5 ef | 2.5 a | 1.08 ab |
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 2.5 a–g | 31 a–e | 8.00 a | 81.75 c–g | 7.50 a–e | 26.75 hij | 25.5 ef | 6.5 a | 1.08 ab |
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 77.5 a–g | 9.00 a | 51.25 a–e | 7.00 a–d | 21.25 g–j | 22.5 ef | 4 a | 1.33 a–d |
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.75 fg | 31.5 a–d | 10.00 a | 45.25 a–d | 3.25 a | 28.00 hij | 21.75 ef | 3 a | 1.08 ab |
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | 4.75 a–g | 12.5 a | 11.50 a | 32.00 abc | 1.50 a | 20.50 f–j | 16.25 c–f | 2 a | 1.00 a |
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5 b–g | 39 a–f | 8.75 a | 186.75 e–i | 24.75 e–h | 12.00 c–j | 2.5 a–e | 3.5 a | 1.00 a |
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 c–g | 52.25 abc | 11.25 a | 46.50 a–d | 24.25 d–g | 21.50 g–j | 34.25 f | 5.5 a | 1.25 abc |
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 d–g | 93.5 a–g | 12.50 a | 49.50 a–e | 14.00 b–f | 29.25 ij | 43 f | 8.5 a | 1.42 a–e |
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 30.75 a–e | 10.75 a | 54.00 bcdef | 20.00 c–f | 23.00 g–j | 23.5 ef | 4 a | 1.00 a |
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 210 efg | 4.00 a | 571.75 i | 286.25 j | 1.75 a | 9.75 a–f | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 123.75 c–g | 2.75 a | 555.50 i | 287.50 j | 2.25 ab | 8.5 a–f | 4.5 a | 3.83 kl |
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 181.75 d–g | 4.25 a | 371.75 hi | 246.00 ij | 3.25 abc | 11.75 a–f | 5.5 a | 3.33 jkl |
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 159.25 d–g | 1.50 a | 483.50 i | 267.25 j | 3.75 a–d | 11 a–f | 2.25 a | 3.50 jkl |
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.25 a | 146.75 d–g | 3.25 a | 568.50 i | 239.75 ij | 1.50 a | 6.25 a–f | 3.25 a | 3.58 jkl |
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.5 a–g | 199.5 efg | 4.25 a | 522.75 i | 180.50 ij | 3.75 abc | 14 a–f | 1.5 a | 3.08 hij |
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 2.25 a–g | 142 d–g | 4.00 a | 490.75 i | 231.50 ij | 4.00 a–d | 9.25 a–f | 0.75 a | 3.42 jkl |
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 4.5 a–g | 219.75 d–g | 7.50 a | 266.25 ghi | 112.00 ij | 4.75 a–e | 0.75 abc | 9.5 a | 1.75 b–f |
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 278.75 g | 7.25 a | 236.25 f–i | 79.75 hi | 1.75 a | 0.25 a | 7 a | 1.92 c–g |
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 220.5 d–g | 7.00 a | 394.25 hi | 25.75 e–h | 5.00 a–f | 9.25 a–f | 5.25 a | 2.08 efg |
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.5 efg | 155.25 d–g | 8.75 a | 48.00 a–e | 4.00 a | 20.50 e–j | 41.25 ef | 12.25 a | 1.58 a–e |
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 2.5 a–g | 129.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 482.25 i | 217.75 ij | 8.75 b–j | 30.75 ef | 2.75 a | 3.08 hij |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 171.25 d–g | 3.75 a | 279.75 ghi | 150.25 ij | 11.25 b–j | 26 ef | 2 a | 2.42 fgh |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 0.75 ab | 180.5 d–g | 5.50 a | 450.50 hi | 201.75 ij | 8.75 a–i | 27.5 def | 4.25 a | 3.33 jkl |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 156.5 d–g | 3.25 a | 463.25 i | 229.75 ij | 5.75 a–g | 24.5 def | 3 a | 3.42 jkl |
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | 1.25 a–f | 191.25 d–g | 6.50 a | 301.25 ghi | 140.75 ij | 9.50 b–j | 32 ef | 2.5 a | 2.50 ghi |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | 1 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 2.00 a | 626.50 i | 204.50 ij | 5.50 a–f | 33.5 ef | 4.5 a | 3.17 ijk |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | 3 a–g | 198 efg | 7.75 a | 226.50 ghi | 75.25 ghi | 19.50 e–j | 60 f | 11.5 a | 2.08 efg |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 114.5 b–g | 4.00 a | 474.00 hi | 274.00 j | 3.75 a–d | 17.25 b–f | 0.5 a | 3.83 kl |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–d | 112.75 b–g | 6:00 AM a | 405.25 hi | 220.50 ij | 6.75 a–h | 32.75 ef | 3.5 a | 3.75 jkl |
31 | Untreated | 1.75 a–g | 128.25 b–g | 4.75 a | 418 hi | 226.50 ij | 7.00 a–i | 23.5 ef | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 385.25 fg | 14.25 a | 56.5 a–e | 34.25 fgh | 11.50 c–j | 2 a–d | 0 a | 2.00 d–g |
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | 3 a–g | 144.5 d–g | 5.25 a | 15.5 a | 6.00 abc | 16.00 d–j | 18.5 ef | 2.75 a | 1.92 c–g |
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | 7 d–g | 148.5 b–g | 13.00 a | 17.75 ab | 23.75 def | 22.25 g–j | 41.5 ef | 6 a | 1.83 c–g |
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 180.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 268 ghi | 209.75 ij | 7.00 a–i | 0.5 ab | 0.25 a | 2.50 ghi |
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.25 a–g | 279.25 efg | 7.25 a | 121.75 d–h | 24.75 c–f | 33.75 j | 31.5 ef | 0.75 a | 1.67 a–e |
P | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.0002 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.513 | < 0.0001 | |
HSD | 0.663 | 0.8653 | 0.8114 | 0.5866 | 0.5125 | 0.565 | 1.022 | 1.1744 | 0.7438 |
. | Treatment/Rate . | CPB-AD 1 . | CPB-AD 2 . | CPB-EM . | CPB-SL . | CPB-LL . | PLHA . | PLHN . | Aphid . | DF . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Untreated | 1.25 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 5.75 a | 407.25 hi | 277.00 j | 5.75 a–g | 25 ef | 4.75 a | 3.83 kl |
2 | Exirel 10.8 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6 c–g | 30 ab | 5.25 a | 38.25 a–d | 5.50 ab | 28.00 ij | 19.5 ef | 2.5 a | 1.08 ab |
3 | Agri-Mek 2.72 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 2.5 a–g | 31 a–e | 8.00 a | 81.75 c–g | 7.50 a–e | 26.75 hij | 25.5 ef | 6.5 a | 1.08 ab |
4 | Exp1-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 77.5 a–g | 9.00 a | 51.25 a–e | 7.00 a–d | 21.25 g–j | 22.5 ef | 4 a | 1.33 a–d |
5 | Exp1-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.75 fg | 31.5 a–d | 10.00 a | 45.25 a–d | 3.25 a | 28.00 hij | 21.75 ef | 3 a | 1.08 ab |
6 | Exp1-3 + NIS (2 app.) | 4.75 a–g | 12.5 a | 11.50 a | 32.00 abc | 1.50 a | 20.50 f–j | 16.25 c–f | 2 a | 1.00 a |
7 | Besiege 9 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5 b–g | 39 a–f | 8.75 a | 186.75 e–i | 24.75 e–h | 12.00 c–j | 2.5 a–e | 3.5 a | 1.00 a |
8 | Blackhawk 3.3 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 c–g | 52.25 abc | 11.25 a | 46.50 a–d | 24.25 d–g | 21.50 g–j | 34.25 f | 5.5 a | 1.25 abc |
9 | Blackhawk 3.0 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 6.75 d–g | 93.5 a–g | 12.50 a | 49.50 a–e | 14.00 b–f | 29.25 ij | 43 f | 8.5 a | 1.42 a–e |
10 | Blackhawk 2.75 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 30.75 a–e | 10.75 a | 54.00 bcdef | 20.00 c–f | 23.00 g–j | 23.5 ef | 4 a | 1.00 a |
11 | Exp2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 210 efg | 4.00 a | 571.75 i | 286.25 j | 1.75 a | 9.75 a–f | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
12 | Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 123.75 c–g | 2.75 a | 555.50 i | 287.50 j | 2.25 ab | 8.5 a–f | 4.5 a | 3.83 kl |
13 | Exp2 + Exp3-4 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.75 a–g | 181.75 d–g | 4.25 a | 371.75 hi | 246.00 ij | 3.25 abc | 11.75 a–f | 5.5 a | 3.33 jkl |
14 | Exp2 + Exp3-2 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 159.25 d–g | 1.50 a | 483.50 i | 267.25 j | 3.75 a–d | 11 a–f | 2.25 a | 3.50 jkl |
15 | Exp3-5 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 0.25 a | 146.75 d–g | 3.25 a | 568.50 i | 239.75 ij | 1.50 a | 6.25 a–f | 3.25 a | 3.58 jkl |
16 | Exp3-3 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 1.5 a–g | 199.5 efg | 4.25 a | 522.75 i | 180.50 ij | 3.75 abc | 14 a–f | 1.5 a | 3.08 hij |
17 | Exp3-1 + LI-700 (2 app.) | 2.25 a–g | 142 d–g | 4.00 a | 490.75 i | 231.50 ij | 4.00 a–d | 9.25 a–f | 0.75 a | 3.42 jkl |
18 | Gladiator 19 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 4.5 a–g | 219.75 d–g | 7.50 a | 266.25 ghi | 112.00 ij | 4.75 a–e | 0.75 abc | 9.5 a | 1.75 b–f |
19 | Athena 17 oz/a + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 278.75 g | 7.25 a | 236.25 f–i | 79.75 hi | 1.75 a | 0.25 a | 7 a | 1.92 c–g |
20 | Exp4-2 + NIS (2 app.) | 0.75 abc | 220.5 d–g | 7.00 a | 394.25 hi | 25.75 e–h | 5.00 a–f | 9.25 a–f | 5.25 a | 2.08 efg |
21 | Exp4-1 + NIS (2 app.) | 8.5 efg | 155.25 d–g | 8.75 a | 48.00 a–e | 4.00 a | 20.50 e–j | 41.25 ef | 12.25 a | 1.58 a–e |
22 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 2.5 a–g | 129.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 482.25 i | 217.75 ij | 8.75 b–j | 30.75 ef | 2.75 a | 3.08 hij |
23 | Exp6-2 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 171.25 d–g | 3.75 a | 279.75 ghi | 150.25 ij | 11.25 b–j | 26 ef | 2 a | 2.42 fgh |
24 | Exp5-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 0.75 ab | 180.5 d–g | 5.50 a | 450.50 hi | 201.75 ij | 8.75 a–i | 27.5 def | 4.25 a | 3.33 jkl |
25 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 14 day) | 1.5 a–f | 156.5 d–g | 3.25 a | 463.25 i | 229.75 ij | 5.75 a–g | 24.5 def | 3 a | 3.42 jkl |
26 | Exp5-2 (3 app. 7 day) | 1.25 a–f | 191.25 d–g | 6.50 a | 301.25 ghi | 140.75 ij | 9.50 b–j | 32 ef | 2.5 a | 2.50 ghi |
27 | Exp6-1 (3 app. 7 day) | 1 a–e | 172.75 d–g | 2.00 a | 626.50 i | 204.50 ij | 5.50 a–f | 33.5 ef | 4.5 a | 3.17 ijk |
28 | Rimon 9, 8, 7 oz/a (3 app.) | 3 a–g | 198 efg | 7.75 a | 226.50 ghi | 75.25 ghi | 19.50 e–j | 60 f | 11.5 a | 2.08 efg |
29 | Grandevo 3 lb/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–f | 114.5 b–g | 4.00 a | 474.00 hi | 274.00 j | 3.75 a–d | 17.25 b–f | 0.5 a | 3.83 kl |
30 | Venerate 8 qt/a (3 app.) | 1.25 a–d | 112.75 b–g | 6:00 AM a | 405.25 hi | 220.50 ij | 6.75 a–h | 32.75 ef | 3.5 a | 3.75 jkl |
31 | Untreated | 1.75 a–g | 128.25 b–g | 4.75 a | 418 hi | 226.50 ij | 7.00 a–i | 23.5 ef | 2.75 a | 3.92 l |
32 | Belay 3 oz/a + MSO (2 app.) | 10.25 g | 385.25 fg | 14.25 a | 56.5 a–e | 34.25 fgh | 11.50 c–j | 2 a–d | 0 a | 2.00 d–g |
33 | Entrust 10 oz/a (2 app.) | 3 a–g | 144.5 d–g | 5.25 a | 15.5 a | 6.00 abc | 16.00 d–j | 18.5 ef | 2.75 a | 1.92 c–g |
34 | Radiant 8 oz/a (2 app.) | 7 d–g | 148.5 b–g | 13.00 a | 17.75 ab | 23.75 def | 22.25 g–j | 41.5 ef | 6 a | 1.83 c–g |
35 | Sivanto 14 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.75 c–g | 180.5 d–g | 5.00 a | 268 ghi | 209.75 ij | 7.00 a–i | 0.5 ab | 0.25 a | 2.50 ghi |
36 | Coragen 5 oz/a (2 app.) | 5.25 a–g | 279.25 efg | 7.25 a | 121.75 d–h | 24.75 c–f | 33.75 j | 31.5 ef | 0.75 a | 1.67 a–e |
P | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.0002 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | < 0.0001 | 0.513 | < 0.0001 | |
HSD | 0.663 | 0.8653 | 0.8114 | 0.5866 | 0.5125 | 0.565 | 1.022 | 1.1744 | 0.7438 |
NIS 100 L added at 0.1% v/v, MSO added at 0.125% v/v. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (Tukey’s HSD test, α = 0.05). Means transformed (square root X + 1) prior to separation. Defoliation scored as follows: 1: 0–2%; 2: 2–5%; 3: 5–10%; 4: >10%.
Author notes
This research was partially supported by industry gifts including products and research funding.
Section Editor: Jonathan Babcock