The purpose of this experiment was to evaluate various full-season, reduced-risk, insecticide programs designed to manage Colorado potato beetle (CPB) on potatoes in Wisconsin. With developing neoicotinoid insecticide resistance among CPB populations in the potato production areas in Wisconsin, several systemic-based and foliar-based programs were designed to evaluate their effectiveness on managing the CPB on potato. This experiment was conducted in 2014 on a loamy sand soil at Hancock Agricultural Research station (HAES) located 1.1 mile (1.8 km) southwest of Hancock, WI. Potato, Solanum tuberosum cv. “Russet Burbank,” seed pieces were planted on 2 May. Plants were spaced 12 inches apart within rows and rows were spaced 3 feet apart. The 8-row plots were 24 feet in width by 40 feet in length, for a total of 0.025 acres/plot. Replicates were separated by a 5-feet border of bare ground. Three replicates of 15 full-season insecticide programs were arranged in a randomized complete block (RCB) design. Systemic insecticides were applied in-furrow at planting (2 May for treatments 1–6). The first application of Rimon (treatment 7) was made on 19 June. The first foliar insecticide applications were applied after peak egg hatch and prior to large larval population development (27 June, for treatments 7–12). Subsequent applications were made on 3 July (for treatments 3–6) and 10 July (for treatments 2, 3, and 9–12). Second-generation CPB foliar applications were made to treatments 1, 2, 7, 8, 11, and 12 on 30 July. Treatment information is available in Table 1 . All in-furrow treatments were applied at 11.0 gpa on 2 May using a two nozzle boom equipped with Tee Jet XR8001 flat fan spray nozzles powered by a CO 2 backpack sprayer at 30 psi. Furrows were cut using a commercial potato planter without closing discs attached. Immediately after the in-furrow treatments were applied and all seed piece treatments were placed in open furrows, all seed were covered by hilling. Foliar insecticides were applied using a CO 2 pressurized sprayer with a 24-feet boom operating at 30 psi delivering 20 gpa through 16 Tee Jet XR8002XR flat fan nozzles spaced 18 inches apart while travelling at 4.0 ft/s The efficacy of treatments was assessed by counting the number of egg masses, small larvae, and large larvae per plant on 10 randomly selected plants in each plot. Percent defoliation (% DF) ratings were taken by visual observation of the entire plot. Potato leafhopper (PLH), Empoasca fabae, efficacy was assessed by counting the number of adults collected from 15 sweep net samples in each plot. Aphid and PLH nymph populations were surveyed by visual assessment of 25 leaves per plot. Insect counts occurred on several dates throughout the summer, and reported means were averaged across those dates ( Tables 2 and 3 ). Insect count averages reflect time periods during the summer when specific life stages peaked in the plots. Yield and quality data were collected after harvest (18 September) ( Table 4 ). Data sets were analyzed using analysis of variance, and means were compared using a Fisher’s protected least significant difference mean separation test ( P  = 0.05). No signs of phytotoxicity were observed among treatments.

Table 1.

Full-season, integrated pest and resistance management programs for control of the CPB

Treatment 1st generation CPB
2nd generation CPB
Application dateInsecticideRateTypeApplication dateInsecticideRateType
12 MayPlatinum 75 SC2.67fl oz/acreIF30 July Besiege 1.25 ZC a9fl oz/aF
22 MayBelay 2.13 SC12fl oz/acreIF30 July Agri-Mek 0.7 SC a3.5fl oz/aF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
32 May Verimark 20 SC a7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.0oz/acreF
42 May Verimark 20 SC a10fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
52 May Verimark 20 SC a13.5fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
62 MayAdmire Pro 4.6SC8.7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
719 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF30 July Exirel 10 SE c6.75fl oz/aF
27 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF
827 June Coragen 1.67 SC c5fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 4.6SC b1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Coragen 1.67 SC c3.5fl oz/acreF
927 June Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d8.5fl oz/acreFNo application
10 July Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d6fl oz/acreF
1027 June Blackhawk 36WG d3.3oz wt/acreFNo application
10 July Blackhawk 36WG d2.5oz wt/acreF
1127 June Radiant 1SC d8fl oz/acreF30 July Actara 25WDG c3oz wt/aF
10 July Radiant 1SC d6fl oz/acreF
1227 June Athena 0.87EC a17fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 550 SC d1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Athena 0.87EC a14fl oz/acreF
Treatment 1st generation CPB
2nd generation CPB
Application dateInsecticideRateTypeApplication dateInsecticideRateType
12 MayPlatinum 75 SC2.67fl oz/acreIF30 July Besiege 1.25 ZC a9fl oz/aF
22 MayBelay 2.13 SC12fl oz/acreIF30 July Agri-Mek 0.7 SC a3.5fl oz/aF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
32 May Verimark 20 SC a7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.0oz/acreF
42 May Verimark 20 SC a10fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
52 May Verimark 20 SC a13.5fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
62 MayAdmire Pro 4.6SC8.7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
719 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF30 July Exirel 10 SE c6.75fl oz/aF
27 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF
827 June Coragen 1.67 SC c5fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 4.6SC b1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Coragen 1.67 SC c3.5fl oz/acreF
927 June Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d8.5fl oz/acreFNo application
10 July Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d6fl oz/acreF
1027 June Blackhawk 36WG d3.3oz wt/acreFNo application
10 July Blackhawk 36WG d2.5oz wt/acreF
1127 June Radiant 1SC d8fl oz/acreF30 July Actara 25WDG c3oz wt/aF
10 July Radiant 1SC d6fl oz/acreF
1227 June Athena 0.87EC a17fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 550 SC d1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Athena 0.87EC a14fl oz/acreF

F, foliar; IF, in furrow.

a MSO 100 L added at 0.25% vol/vol.

b Silwet 100 L added at 0.25% vol/vol.

c MSO 100L added at 0.5% vol/vol.

d NIS 100 L added at 0.25% vol/vol.

Table 1.

Full-season, integrated pest and resistance management programs for control of the CPB

Treatment 1st generation CPB
2nd generation CPB
Application dateInsecticideRateTypeApplication dateInsecticideRateType
12 MayPlatinum 75 SC2.67fl oz/acreIF30 July Besiege 1.25 ZC a9fl oz/aF
22 MayBelay 2.13 SC12fl oz/acreIF30 July Agri-Mek 0.7 SC a3.5fl oz/aF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
32 May Verimark 20 SC a7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.0oz/acreF
42 May Verimark 20 SC a10fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
52 May Verimark 20 SC a13.5fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
62 MayAdmire Pro 4.6SC8.7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
719 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF30 July Exirel 10 SE c6.75fl oz/aF
27 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF
827 June Coragen 1.67 SC c5fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 4.6SC b1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Coragen 1.67 SC c3.5fl oz/acreF
927 June Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d8.5fl oz/acreFNo application
10 July Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d6fl oz/acreF
1027 June Blackhawk 36WG d3.3oz wt/acreFNo application
10 July Blackhawk 36WG d2.5oz wt/acreF
1127 June Radiant 1SC d8fl oz/acreF30 July Actara 25WDG c3oz wt/aF
10 July Radiant 1SC d6fl oz/acreF
1227 June Athena 0.87EC a17fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 550 SC d1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Athena 0.87EC a14fl oz/acreF
Treatment 1st generation CPB
2nd generation CPB
Application dateInsecticideRateTypeApplication dateInsecticideRateType
12 MayPlatinum 75 SC2.67fl oz/acreIF30 July Besiege 1.25 ZC a9fl oz/aF
22 MayBelay 2.13 SC12fl oz/acreIF30 July Agri-Mek 0.7 SC a3.5fl oz/aF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
32 May Verimark 20 SC a7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
10 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.0oz/acreF
42 May Verimark 20 SC a10fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
52 May Verimark 20 SC a13.5fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
62 MayAdmire Pro 4.6SC8.7fl oz/acreIFNo application
3 JulyBlackhawk 36WG3.3oz/acreF
719 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF30 July Exirel 10 SE c6.75fl oz/aF
27 June Rimon 0.83 EC b10fl oz/acreF
827 June Coragen 1.67 SC c5fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 4.6SC b1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Coragen 1.67 SC c3.5fl oz/acreF
927 June Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d8.5fl oz/acreFNo application
10 July Agri-Flex 1.55 EC d6fl oz/acreF
1027 June Blackhawk 36WG d3.3oz wt/acreFNo application
10 July Blackhawk 36WG d2.5oz wt/acreF
1127 June Radiant 1SC d8fl oz/acreF30 July Actara 25WDG c3oz wt/aF
10 July Radiant 1SC d6fl oz/acreF
1227 June Athena 0.87EC a17fl oz/acreF30 July Admire Pro 550 SC d1.3fl oz/aF
10 July Athena 0.87EC a14fl oz/acreF

F, foliar; IF, in furrow.

a MSO 100 L added at 0.25% vol/vol.

b Silwet 100 L added at 0.25% vol/vol.

c MSO 100L added at 0.5% vol/vol.

d NIS 100 L added at 0.25% vol/vol.

Table 2.

Mean lifestage counts per 10 plants of CPBs and percent defoliation

TreatmentAdultsEgg massesSmall larvaeLarge larvae% Defoliation
12.2 bc0.3 bc1.1 d0.6 cd1.0 a
21.8 bc0.2 bc3.9 bcd0.9 bcd1.0 a
32.1 bc1.1 a4.3 abc0.4 d1.0 a
41.8 c0.1 c4.6 ab0.9 bcd1.0 a
50.8 d0.6 ab1.7 cd0.4 d1.0 a
61.5 cd0.2 c3.5 a–d1.3 ab1.0 a
71.1 cd0.3 bc6.8 a0.8 bcd1.0 a
82.9 ab0.5 ab4.2 ab1.5 ab1.0 a
92.0 bc0.5 bc4.5 ab1.2 bc1.0 a
101.6 c0.4 ab3.7 bcd0.8 bcd1.0 a
111.7 cd0.3 ab5.4 ab0.4 cd1.0 a
123.2 a0.5 ab5.7 ab2.0 a1.0 a
P0.00460.17670.02110.00620.000
LSD0.450.150.420.450.00
TreatmentAdultsEgg massesSmall larvaeLarge larvae% Defoliation
12.2 bc0.3 bc1.1 d0.6 cd1.0 a
21.8 bc0.2 bc3.9 bcd0.9 bcd1.0 a
32.1 bc1.1 a4.3 abc0.4 d1.0 a
41.8 c0.1 c4.6 ab0.9 bcd1.0 a
50.8 d0.6 ab1.7 cd0.4 d1.0 a
61.5 cd0.2 c3.5 a–d1.3 ab1.0 a
71.1 cd0.3 bc6.8 a0.8 bcd1.0 a
82.9 ab0.5 ab4.2 ab1.5 ab1.0 a
92.0 bc0.5 bc4.5 ab1.2 bc1.0 a
101.6 c0.4 ab3.7 bcd0.8 bcd1.0 a
111.7 cd0.3 ab5.4 ab0.4 cd1.0 a
123.2 a0.5 ab5.7 ab2.0 a1.0 a
P0.00460.17670.02110.00620.000
LSD0.450.150.420.450.00

LSD, least significant difference. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at α > 0.05. Means transformed (square root X  + 1) prior to separation.

Table 2.

Mean lifestage counts per 10 plants of CPBs and percent defoliation

TreatmentAdultsEgg massesSmall larvaeLarge larvae% Defoliation
12.2 bc0.3 bc1.1 d0.6 cd1.0 a
21.8 bc0.2 bc3.9 bcd0.9 bcd1.0 a
32.1 bc1.1 a4.3 abc0.4 d1.0 a
41.8 c0.1 c4.6 ab0.9 bcd1.0 a
50.8 d0.6 ab1.7 cd0.4 d1.0 a
61.5 cd0.2 c3.5 a–d1.3 ab1.0 a
71.1 cd0.3 bc6.8 a0.8 bcd1.0 a
82.9 ab0.5 ab4.2 ab1.5 ab1.0 a
92.0 bc0.5 bc4.5 ab1.2 bc1.0 a
101.6 c0.4 ab3.7 bcd0.8 bcd1.0 a
111.7 cd0.3 ab5.4 ab0.4 cd1.0 a
123.2 a0.5 ab5.7 ab2.0 a1.0 a
P0.00460.17670.02110.00620.000
LSD0.450.150.420.450.00
TreatmentAdultsEgg massesSmall larvaeLarge larvae% Defoliation
12.2 bc0.3 bc1.1 d0.6 cd1.0 a
21.8 bc0.2 bc3.9 bcd0.9 bcd1.0 a
32.1 bc1.1 a4.3 abc0.4 d1.0 a
41.8 c0.1 c4.6 ab0.9 bcd1.0 a
50.8 d0.6 ab1.7 cd0.4 d1.0 a
61.5 cd0.2 c3.5 a–d1.3 ab1.0 a
71.1 cd0.3 bc6.8 a0.8 bcd1.0 a
82.9 ab0.5 ab4.2 ab1.5 ab1.0 a
92.0 bc0.5 bc4.5 ab1.2 bc1.0 a
101.6 c0.4 ab3.7 bcd0.8 bcd1.0 a
111.7 cd0.3 ab5.4 ab0.4 cd1.0 a
123.2 a0.5 ab5.7 ab2.0 a1.0 a
P0.00460.17670.02110.00620.000
LSD0.450.150.420.450.00

LSD, least significant difference. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at α > 0.05. Means transformed (square root X  + 1) prior to separation.

Table 3.

Mean PLH and aphid counts per 10 plants

TreatmentPLHPLHAphids
adultsnymphs
10.3 e0.0 f0.0 bc
20.4 e0.1 f0.0 bc
33.9 bc0.8 a0.2 abc
47.5 a1.6 a0.2 abc
55.9 ab0.6 ab0.2 abc
61.6 de0.1 ef0.0 c
75.4 abc0.4 bc0.3 ab
83.2 cd0.5 bc0.4 a
91.3 e0.0 f0.0 c
105.6 ab0.4 cd0.2 abc
113.3 cd0.3 cde0.2 abc
120.8 e0.2 def0.1 bc
P0.00010.00010.0751
LSD0.430.080.03
TreatmentPLHPLHAphids
adultsnymphs
10.3 e0.0 f0.0 bc
20.4 e0.1 f0.0 bc
33.9 bc0.8 a0.2 abc
47.5 a1.6 a0.2 abc
55.9 ab0.6 ab0.2 abc
61.6 de0.1 ef0.0 c
75.4 abc0.4 bc0.3 ab
83.2 cd0.5 bc0.4 a
91.3 e0.0 f0.0 c
105.6 ab0.4 cd0.2 abc
113.3 cd0.3 cde0.2 abc
120.8 e0.2 def0.1 bc
P0.00010.00010.0751
LSD0.430.080.03

LSD, least significant difference. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at α > 0.05. Means transformed (square root X +1) prior to separation.

Table 3.

Mean PLH and aphid counts per 10 plants

TreatmentPLHPLHAphids
adultsnymphs
10.3 e0.0 f0.0 bc
20.4 e0.1 f0.0 bc
33.9 bc0.8 a0.2 abc
47.5 a1.6 a0.2 abc
55.9 ab0.6 ab0.2 abc
61.6 de0.1 ef0.0 c
75.4 abc0.4 bc0.3 ab
83.2 cd0.5 bc0.4 a
91.3 e0.0 f0.0 c
105.6 ab0.4 cd0.2 abc
113.3 cd0.3 cde0.2 abc
120.8 e0.2 def0.1 bc
P0.00010.00010.0751
LSD0.430.080.03
TreatmentPLHPLHAphids
adultsnymphs
10.3 e0.0 f0.0 bc
20.4 e0.1 f0.0 bc
33.9 bc0.8 a0.2 abc
47.5 a1.6 a0.2 abc
55.9 ab0.6 ab0.2 abc
61.6 de0.1 ef0.0 c
75.4 abc0.4 bc0.3 ab
83.2 cd0.5 bc0.4 a
91.3 e0.0 f0.0 c
105.6 ab0.4 cd0.2 abc
113.3 cd0.3 cde0.2 abc
120.8 e0.2 def0.1 bc
P0.00010.00010.0751
LSD0.430.080.03

LSD, least significant difference. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at α > 0.05. Means transformed (square root X +1) prior to separation.

Table 4.

Mean yield estimates 

TreatmentTotal US 1 (lbs)Proportion US 1-ACWT/A
1130.1 a92.1 b435.4 acc
2131.0 a91.5 b421.6 abc
3115.4 a–e94.0 ab393.3 a–d
4108.7 de94.9 ab374.2 bcd
5115.3 a–e94.1 ab393.6 a–d
6126.3 ab95.3 a436.6 a
7112.9 b–e95.1 ab390.2 a–d
8119.9 a–d95.4 a415.0 ab
9125.4 abc95.0 ab432.9 ab
10109.9 cde95.0 ab379.3 a–d
11103.4 e94.2 ab354.0 d
12108.1 de94.5 ab371.2 cd
P0.03940.65130.0881
LSD6.5431.095.761
TreatmentTotal US 1 (lbs)Proportion US 1-ACWT/A
1130.1 a92.1 b435.4 acc
2131.0 a91.5 b421.6 abc
3115.4 a–e94.0 ab393.3 a–d
4108.7 de94.9 ab374.2 bcd
5115.3 a–e94.1 ab393.6 a–d
6126.3 ab95.3 a436.6 a
7112.9 b–e95.1 ab390.2 a–d
8119.9 a–d95.4 a415.0 ab
9125.4 abc95.0 ab432.9 ab
10109.9 cde95.0 ab379.3 a–d
11103.4 e94.2 ab354.0 d
12108.1 de94.5 ab371.2 cd
P0.03940.65130.0881
LSD6.5431.095.761

LSD, least significant difference. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at α > 0.05. Means transformed (square root X  + 1) prior to separation.

Table 4.

Mean yield estimates 

TreatmentTotal US 1 (lbs)Proportion US 1-ACWT/A
1130.1 a92.1 b435.4 acc
2131.0 a91.5 b421.6 abc
3115.4 a–e94.0 ab393.3 a–d
4108.7 de94.9 ab374.2 bcd
5115.3 a–e94.1 ab393.6 a–d
6126.3 ab95.3 a436.6 a
7112.9 b–e95.1 ab390.2 a–d
8119.9 a–d95.4 a415.0 ab
9125.4 abc95.0 ab432.9 ab
10109.9 cde95.0 ab379.3 a–d
11103.4 e94.2 ab354.0 d
12108.1 de94.5 ab371.2 cd
P0.03940.65130.0881
LSD6.5431.095.761
TreatmentTotal US 1 (lbs)Proportion US 1-ACWT/A
1130.1 a92.1 b435.4 acc
2131.0 a91.5 b421.6 abc
3115.4 a–e94.0 ab393.3 a–d
4108.7 de94.9 ab374.2 bcd
5115.3 a–e94.1 ab393.6 a–d
6126.3 ab95.3 a436.6 a
7112.9 b–e95.1 ab390.2 a–d
8119.9 a–d95.4 a415.0 ab
9125.4 abc95.0 ab432.9 ab
10109.9 cde95.0 ab379.3 a–d
11103.4 e94.2 ab354.0 d
12108.1 de94.5 ab371.2 cd
P0.03940.65130.0881
LSD6.5431.095.761

LSD, least significant difference. Means in a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at α > 0.05. Means transformed (square root X  + 1) prior to separation.

*This research was partially supported by industry gifts including products and research funding.

Author notes

Subject Editor: Vonny Barlow

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ ), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]