Selected seed-applied, in-furrow liquid at-planting, and foliar broadcast insecticides were evaluated for control of thrips in cotton. ‘DP 1028 B2RF’ cotton was planted 5 May at the Virginia Tech Tidewater Agric. Res. & Ext. Ctr., Suffolk, VA, using 36-inch row spacing. Liquid in-furrow treatments (Belay and Orthene) were applied into the seed furrow at 5 gpa using a microtube mounted between the disc openers, pressurized by CO 2 at 51 psi. The foliar applications (Orthene and Knack) were broadcast at the first true leaf stage on 19 May with a CO 2 -pressurized backpack sprayer calibrated to deliver 14.3 gpa at 18 psi through 8004VS nozzles spaced 18 inches apart on the spray boom. A RCB design was used with 4 replicates; plots were 4 rows by 40 ft. Thrips injury to plants was determined on four dates by visually rating injury using a 0–5 scale, where 0 = no thrips induced plant injury; 1 = 10% injured leaves, no bud injury; 2 = 25% injured leaves, no bud injury; 3 = 75% injured leaves, and 0 to 25% buds injured; 4 = 90% injured leaves, and >25% buds injured; and 5 = dead plants. Yield was determined by harvesting two rows of each plot (end-trimmed to 64 row ft) using a commercial two-row cotton picker. Sub-samples were ginned to determine lint versus seed and trash weight (46.3% lint, 53.7% seed and trash). Data were analyzed using ANOVA and LSD statistical procedures.

There were differences in thrips injury ratings between treatments on each sample date ( Table 1 ). Injury ratings were significantly lower in treated plots compared to untreated check plots on each date. The plots using Aeris-treated seed along with Belay (at 6.4 oz/acre) did not have the lowest thrips injury rating on any date sampled, but did have the highest yield at the end of the season. There was no significant difference in yield between any treatments, including treatments using Knack, an insect growth regulator, and treatments that consisted only of Aeris-treated seed.

Treatment/formulationRate and application method Thrips injury rating a
23 May29 May2 Jun11 JunLint lb/acre
Untreated check3.38a4.25a3.88a4.19a1,515b
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.50c1.38b2.00b1.75b1,939a
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.75b1.31bc2.00b1.75b2,155a
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd1.00cd0.88c0.75e2,140a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.94d1.06c1.00c2,018a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.75de0.56c0.50f2,135a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.38cd0.75de0.88c0.88d2,016a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/A (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd0.50e0.56c0.50f2,208a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/acre (broadcast)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
LSD0.230.360.770.10289.3
Treatment/formulationRate and application method Thrips injury rating a
23 May29 May2 Jun11 JunLint lb/acre
Untreated check3.38a4.25a3.88a4.19a1,515b
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.50c1.38b2.00b1.75b1,939a
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.75b1.31bc2.00b1.75b2,155a
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd1.00cd0.88c0.75e2,140a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.94d1.06c1.00c2,018a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.75de0.56c0.50f2,135a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.38cd0.75de0.88c0.88d2,016a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/A (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd0.50e0.56c0.50f2,208a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/acre (broadcast)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
LSD0.230.360.770.10289.3

Means within a column followed by the same letter(s) are not significantly different (protected LSD, P  > 0.05).

a Thrips injury rated on a 0–5 scale, 0 = no thrips injury and 5 = dead plants.

b Aeris = imidacloprid @ 0.375 mg ai/seed + thiodicarb @ 0.375 mg AI/seed.

Treatment/formulationRate and application method Thrips injury rating a
23 May29 May2 Jun11 JunLint lb/acre
Untreated check3.38a4.25a3.88a4.19a1,515b
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.50c1.38b2.00b1.75b1,939a
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.75b1.31bc2.00b1.75b2,155a
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd1.00cd0.88c0.75e2,140a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.94d1.06c1.00c2,018a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.75de0.56c0.50f2,135a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.38cd0.75de0.88c0.88d2,016a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/A (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd0.50e0.56c0.50f2,208a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/acre (broadcast)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
LSD0.230.360.770.10289.3
Treatment/formulationRate and application method Thrips injury rating a
23 May29 May2 Jun11 JunLint lb/acre
Untreated check3.38a4.25a3.88a4.19a1,515b
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.50c1.38b2.00b1.75b1,939a
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.75b1.31bc2.00b1.75b2,155a
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd1.00cd0.88c0.75e2,140a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.94d1.06c1.00c2,018a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.25d0.75de0.56c0.50f2,135a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.38cd0.75de0.88c0.88d2,016a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/A (broadcast)
Aeris (see footnote b ) 1.31cd0.50e0.56c0.50f2,208a
+ Orthene 97PE12 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Belay 50WDG6.4 oz/acre (in-furrow)
+ Knack 0.86EC10 oz/acre (broadcast)
+ Orthene 97PE6 oz/acre (broadcast)
LSD0.230.360.770.10289.3

Means within a column followed by the same letter(s) are not significantly different (protected LSD, P  > 0.05).

a Thrips injury rated on a 0–5 scale, 0 = no thrips injury and 5 = dead plants.

b Aeris = imidacloprid @ 0.375 mg ai/seed + thiodicarb @ 0.375 mg AI/seed.

* This research was supported by industry gifts of products and research funding.

Author notes

Subject Editor: Jawwad Qureshi

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ ), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact [email protected]